if Obi-Wan Was a padawan, it would be an increadibly tough fight(padawan against a Knight ), but I think He'd win. we don't know much about Serra, but Obi-Wan did something spectacular for a Jedi of his Rank: Stood his ground, and defeated a Sith Lord in Blade-To-Blade Combat. any rank above padawan for Obi-Wan, and he'd completely crush her.
Darthsith; two lightsabers doesn't equate to WTFpwnage. Obi-Wan could probably go toe-to-toe with Qui-Gon as of TPM, considering he floored Darth Maul, not to mention that he held his own against the renegade Xanatos when he was hardly thirteen or fourteen. I wouldn't give the hyped up Keto a prayer against him.
Originally posted by darthsith19
Serra Keto wins. She was a Knight, not a padawan, and she was Cin's strongest student. She was also a prodigy in making. She uses two lightsaber and is far beyond her years. TPM Obi-Wan's just not quite strong enough to beat her, IMO.
Maul used a double bladed Lightsaber.
Predicting someone will win the fight because they have more Lightsabers is outright silly, to be honest.
Sera loses.
Originally posted by Faunus
Darthsith; two lightsabers doesn't equate to WTFpwnage. Obi-Wan could probably go toe-to-toe with Qui-Gon as of TPM, considering he floored Darth Maul, not to mention that he held his own against the renegade Xanatos when he was hardly thirteen or fourteen. I wouldn't give the hyped up Keto a prayer against him.
Originally posted by DarkNemesis
Hmm...I see...where can I get some good SOLID info on Serra? Because when I read the Serra vs. Maul thread, everyone said Maul would pwn Serra, so I decided to put her up against TPM Obi-Wan, who did put on a pretty good show against Maul in TPM.
But when Obi battled Maul one on one Obi-Wan was winning that.
Well Obi didn't "beat" Maul in saber combat, Maul was (like all Sith lords) too arrogant and decided to taunt Kenobi when he was hanging on for his life when he could have just killed him. And Maul, like Anakin, and Like Palpatine, all get killed because they are too sure of themselves, too arrogant. In the Eps. III game Serra gets pwned by Anakin, sure, but TPM Obi-Wan would get curbed stomped by ROTS Anakin and Serra didn't do too bad considering.
I think Serra would more then likely win, though it wouldn't be easy.
Originally posted by darthsith19
Never said two lightsabers = wtf pwnage. Qui-Gon would beat Obi-Wan, if Obi-Wan had gone against Maul all along with no Qui-Gon there... well, about five seconds into the duel he gets kicked halfway across the room. He only got lucky at the end when he managed to cut Maul in half and before he got pushed into the pit he only stood a chance against Maul cause of his anger. And it's not like I said Serra'd pwn, I said Obi-Wan's just not [B]quite as strong. [/B]
Maybe, but barely. I believe Obi-Wan and Qui-Gon have already fought in the Jedi Apprentice series, and that was when the former was in his early teens. And again, Kenobi's already taken on Xanatos, a Dark Jedi, and Bruck, another renegade. He defeated the latter alone.
Kicked across the room? He had to maneuver around Qui-Gon to attack Maul, and when he got his chance, Maul kicked him in the jaw. Obi-Wan just back-flipped neatly and started hammering him again. We saw Qui-Gon get kicked aside, too, and he actually cartwheels away. So no, I'd say that Obi-Wan could contend very well with Qui-Gon. Are there any sources that show Serra could do the same?
u
And again, Kenobi's already taken on Xanatos, a Dark Jedi
and Bruck, another renegade. He defeated the latter alone.
Kicked across the room? He had to maneuver around Qui-Gon to attack Maul, and when he got his chance, Maul kicked him in the jaw.
Obi-Wan just back-flipped neatly and started hammering him again.
We saw Qui-Gon get kicked aside, too, and he actually cartwheels away.
So no, I'd say that Obi-Wan could contend very well with Qui-Gon.
Are there any sources that show Serra could do the same?
Re: u
Originally posted by darthsith19
With Qui-Gon's help, right?
Most of the time they were separated, so not really.
Bruck was only the same age as Obi-Wan. Obi-Wan had already defeated him when they were younglings, so he beat him again. So what? it's not like Bruck was anything special.
Yet that alone is more to his name than Serra has to hers.
You lie. I just checked. Check again, Faunus. There in the dorway leading to the power generator room. Obi-Wan's attacking Maul's left side, Qui-Gon's attacking Maul's right side. Maul blocks Qui-Gon's swing and then kicks's Obi-Wan in the jaw.
Right. I lie. Of course, there isn't the slightest possibility that I don't have TPM on hand, is there.
No, he landed on the ground and rolled sideways. It took him six seconds to get back to Maul.
Six seconds? Please.
He kicks Qui-Gon and Qui-Gon falls onto the ground, but doesn't move across the room, he falls right there and gets right back up.
I don't really believe that; I distinctly remember him going off-screen. Time to rent TPM. . .
I highly doubt it, he got lucky when he killed Maul and he nearly died when Maul kicked him the second time, too (when he fell off the catwalk). Qui-Gon put up a good fight the entire time and was even driving Maul back for a while.
He was clever; there's a difference. And there aren't ''nearly died'' points in duels. Anakin and Obi-Wan ''nearly died'' a hundred times apiece in their duel. Maul ''nearly died'' when Obi-Wan hacked in two his lightsaber, and almost hit him when he flipped over his head. Obi-Wan landed hard and slipped off, but he was back up in a couple of seconds.
And actually, it was Maul driving Qui-Gon back - and defending against Obi-Wan simultaneously - in the hangar. Qui-Gon later pushed him back alone, yeah, but so did Obi-Wan.
We don't have much info on Serra. She's only in a video game, so.
So, you really have no case.
Re: u
Originally posted by darthsith19
No, he landed on the ground and rolled sideways. It took him six seconds to get back to Maul.