darth vader metal form or GG

darth vader in 4, 5 and 6 or GG and that isnt correct about darth vader he is more human he only has his arms and legs metal

did i mention that GG has his weakneses fixed up for this battle he is complete machine aswell

Vader wins. he is completely underrated because the OT movies were made when trchnology sucked, and GL had little ambition for the characters and didn't put too much effort into the choreography.

what do people think of this new thread

If you would make threads that actually have two characters that can contest well then people would like it, also make it interesting. Vader easily takes this, quite simply read any of the comics/novels in between ROTS and ANH, it shows Vader's abilities and powers.

Done before. Anyway, depends on which GG. He would be owned against Vader if he was the ROTS version. But if he the ROTS novelization/Clone Wars version, he would put up one hell of a fight before going down to Vader.

Personally, I don't see Vader winning in a lightsabre duel, perhaps with the force, but's he ****ed if it's only a lightsabre fight. Vader simply doesn't have the mobility or speed to deal with Grievous, especially considering it took Obi-Wan Kenobi, the Soresu Master to take him down. So no, in a lightsabre fight, Grievous will win the day.

If it's not? Then I don't see Grievous being able to recover from Vader's force attacks...

Grievous from the Clone Wars might be able to beat OT Vader becuase Vader might not be fast enough to block Grievous's lightsabers. So in Purge Vader killed what? How many Jedi? Cause Grievous beat five Jedi, three which were masters, two of the masters were on the council, at once.

He kills... I believe five Jedi as well before they start turning the tables.

Still, Vader wins.

Tsui Choi was in the party that Vader killed and he was more powerful then any of the people that Grievous faced. This was also Vader still getting used to his suit.

Originally posted by skyflyer
Tsui Choi was in the party that Vader killed and he was more powerful then any of the people that Grievous faced. This was also Vader still getting used to his suit.

He's in numerous comics and could possibly pose a threat to TOTS Grievous.

I believe it would be close. Grievous might be able to take Vader out before Vader can utilize his force powers. Vader CAN'T COMPETE AT ALL in a lightsaber duel, he would be slaughtered FAST.

Originally posted by darthsith19
Yeah, and it's also total bullshit, there's no way Vader could do all that when in RODV he had trouble killing one Knight (Bol Chatak). Are we to assume that Bol Chatak, just some random Knight who managed to survive Order 66, could beat these five Jedi at once or even compete with them? And Tsui Choi was kileld by Stormtroopers, not Vader. And whether he's stronger than Mundi or Shaak Ti would be debatable. What has he ever done to be more powerful than they are?

For once, I agree. You have Vader depicted very well in RoDV, struggling with his new identity and handicap, and in Purge - taking place at the same time, give or take a couple of weeks - he's wrecking Jedi Masters. With a few months or years, yeah, but Purge was queer. . .

Purge DID take place AFTER RODV, so it's not that bad. He was just getting used to the suit in RODV. By Purge, I guess he was warmed up. I mean, he was confident enough to take on a whole bunch of Jedi Masters alone.

btw, Appo was not in Purge.

Originally posted by DePWNZOR
I believe it would be close. Grievous might be able to take Vader out before Vader can utilize his force powers. Vader CAN'T COMPETE AT ALL in a lightsaber duel, he would be slaughtered FAST.

No, Vader would win in a matter of minutes, even without the Force. He's stronger than he might look.

I love how people say that the ancient sith must be quick to produce the power that they do, yet the same people claim that Vader (who is the most powerful force user (power as in strength) is as slow as ****.

But Vader lost to Luke. No matter how emotionally upset he might have been, that's still pathetic. A half trained Jedi who hasn't even dueled another force user before. I can't see Grievous losing to Luke under ANY circumstances.

If Grievous was his dad and loved Luke enough to die for him, yeah I'd see him losing.

I'd see anyone losing.

Originally posted by DePWNZOR
But Vader lost to Luke. No matter how emotionally upset he might have been, that's still pathetic. A half trained Jedi who hasn't even dueled another force user before. I can't see Grievous losing to Luke under ANY circumstances.

You must remember Luke wasn't fighting alone against Vader.
His father Anakin was fighting his battle inside Vaders head....