ROTS Anakin versus ROTJ Luke

1. Space battle
2. Fist fight
3. Lightsaber duel

I think that Anakin would win the space battle and the lightsaber duel but Luke would win the the fist fight.

Why would you say Anakin wins the saber duel? Remember that Luke did defeat Darth Vader in a saber duel.

Anakin has the bigger frame, so I am tempted to say he wins the fist fight. However Luke did outmuscle Vader in ROTJ. Luke probably wins the fist fight too.

The space battle, definately Anakin. He seems to have this thing with spaceships, including the incredibly stupid feats he pulled off in TPM.

I think that we can all agree that Anakin would win the space battle. So there is no need to comment on that.
I think that Luke wins the fist fight because in the movies he seems incredibly athletic with all his flips. Im not saying that Anakin isnt physically strong but I think Luke would pull it off. And at the end of ROTJ you did see Luke dragging the full weight of Vader along.
The saber duel I gave to Anakin because he is extremely fast and has had proper saber training. Luke has had a quick bit of training with Yoda which doesnt account for much. Plus Luke bet Vader for two reasons. Firstly Vader was in his big clunky suit which limits his movements greatly. Secondly I dont think Vader was going all out. I think he still thought that Luke would join him so they could overthrow the emperor.

Anakin WTFdestroys Luke in all of these.

Anakin takes off his belt and delivers some fatherly discipline.

I say Anakin wins all of them.

Yup Anakin wins all of these.

Yep. His fairly great Force Powers have probably developed far beyond Luke at this point. In piloting, Anakin excels beyond Luke as well, and in a saber match, he obviously pwns him.

So yer, Anakin wins them all.

Anakin had a much more extensive teaching on saber combat, and was also probably more advanced in hand-to-hand combat. In a space battle however, Anakin will undoubtedly defeat Luke, being perhaps the finest pilot of all time.

Anakin Kicks Lukes ass In every Battle

Originally posted by Janus Marius
Anakin WTFdestroys Luke in all of these.

Originally posted by zephiel7
1. Space battle
2. Fist fight
3. Lightsaber duel

1. Anakin was the best star pilot in the galaxy. Luke was quite a good pilot (according to Obi-Wan) but not the best. Anakin wins.

2. Anakin, easily. Did you se how strong he is in ROTS when he had his shirt off? Luke's not that strong.

3. Anakin wins. He's like twice as fast and he killed Dooku, who'd pwn Luke.

Originally posted by darthsith19
2. Anakin, easily. Did you se how strong he is in ROTS when he had his shirt off? Luke's not that strong.

Originally posted by Blaxican_Hydra
Anakin takes off his belt and delivers some fatherly discipline.

Originally posted by darthsith19
2. Anakin, easily. Did you se how strong he is in ROTS when he had his shirt off? Luke's not that strong.

And you were paying attention to these kind of details?

Who WASNT?

Me... ermm

Originally posted by tdtd
Who WASNT?

Hayden Christian's chest muscles are not something I am generally interested in... 🙄

Now Padme...

They're non existent.