punisher vs. nightwing h2h

Started by jgiant4 pages

punisher vs. nightwing h2h

who would win if this were a straight up h2h fight...they are in an abondond warehouse that has empty wooden crates all over the place...

Frank is a very good fighter and has a lot of military experience, but he can't compete with Nightwing's skills and speed.

Most of all, not with Nightwing's speed and agility. Nightwing also has better skills, but Frank has more experience, durability and he's one mean S.O.B.. I would say Nightwing takes the majority, but it's no landslide.

Nightwings not as good as Daredevil, and Frank fights on even terms with him, so I say Frank wins 6 or 7/10

Frank is a freaking monster! The guys durability and damage soak are superhuman with out a doubt. He takes damage that Dick couldn't even dream of dishing out. He'd beat Nightwing 10 times out of 10 by simple out lasting him and ontop of that I would seriously argue that he is at least as skilled a fight as Nightwing. Big mismatch.

I think this will be a close fight, but Frank will come out on top. As others have said Frank can fight the likes of Daredevil, Batman etc. On fairly even terms.

When Punisher takes on Blockbuster or Slade without weapons and can walk away then he can talk about being tough.Nightwing too good and fast plus he has massive durability and stamina.Nw 9/10

Originally posted by superbatman86
When Punisher takes on Blockbuster or Slade without weapons and can walk away then he can talk about being tough.Nightwing too good and fast plus he has massive durability and stamina.Nw 9/10

Frank took three rubber bullets point black to the face before he was knocked out budy. He once had a shotgun blast out one of his ribs was stabbed a few times he still fought one and then after he beat the guy he was fighting he tossed his body out a second story clear a cross a parking lot... then he jumped out the window himself cleared the parking lot himself and landed on the body.

Read some Punisher so you know what you're talking about.

Originally posted by superbatman86
When Punisher takes on Blockbuster or Slade without weapons and can walk away then he can talk about being tough.Nightwing too good and fast plus he has massive durability and stamina.Nw 9/10

Not saying he hasn't, but has Nightwing ever faced Slade or Blockbuster with no gadgets, weapons, or foreign objects?

Originally posted by Nightstick
Not saying he hasn't, but has Nightwing ever faced Slade or Blockbuster with no gadgets, weapons, or foreign objects?

He did recently. He was dancing around Slade pretty well. However, I would more think that Frank would grab his leg and swing him around like a baseball bat like he did to the Mongolian.

Frank 6/10

for some reason I don't image that this would be much different that DD's fights with castle which basically consist of DD kicking punisher around panal after panal...

Originally posted by Dayscribe
He did recently. He was dancing around Slade pretty well. However, I would more think that Frank would grab his leg and swing him around like a baseball bat like he did to the Mongolian.

Frank 6/10

You wouldn't happen to have scans or links for the Slade fight would you?

Originally posted by Nightstick
You wouldn't happen to have scans or links for the Slade fight would you?

I saw it in the Ins and Outs of Slade Wilson thread. Willrules posted it.

Originally posted by jinzin
for some reason I don't image that this would be much different that DD's fights with castle which basically consist of DD kicking punisher around panal after panal...

The most recent DD/Pun fight I can think of is in Means and Ends(Punisher vs Daredevil) in which the Punisher more or less gave as good as he got.

Originally posted by jinzin
for some reason I don't image that this would be much different that DD's fights with castle which basically consist of DD kicking punisher around panal after panal...

Daredevil is what NW would be if he had a) superhuman senses b) had peak human strength and c) was a much better fighter. Matt has way more going for him then Dick does and Frank still holds his own.

Originally posted by Nightstick
The most recent DD/Pun fight I can think of is in Means and Ends(Punisher vs Daredevil) in which the Punisher more or less gave as good as he got.
Yup...frank and dd were pretty much even and frank was even on top for a while...i will have to disagree with u jin, but frank has taken on dd and held his own for quite some time now...granted frank has taken a few beatings and dd has come out on top, but lets go back to when they first fought...the only shot dd got on frank was a cheap one with a billy club and a follow up kick, frank kicked his ass from there on...and even in the next iss...dd had to shoot frank just to keep him down...and they have fought since then and frank has put up a good fight every time, only time when he doesn't is when he is luring dd into a trap...nightwing cant put up nearly as good of fight as frank does against dd...

Originally posted by jgiant
Yup...frank and dd were pretty much even and frank was even on top for a while...i will have to disagree with u jin, but frank has taken on dd and held his own for quite some time now...granted frank has taken a few beatings and dd has come out on top, but lets go back to when they first fought...the only shot dd got on frank was a cheap one with a billy club and a follow up kick, frank kicked his ass from there on...and even in the next iss...dd had to shoot frank just to keep him down...and they have fought since then and frank has put up a good fight every time, only time when he doesn't is when he is luring dd into a trap...nightwing cant put up nearly as good of fight as frank does against dd...

to my knowledge dd has a winning record.. not to mention the fact that frank has admitted on at least two occasions that he doesn't stand as chance against dd...

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
Daredevil is what NW would be if he had a) superhuman senses b) had peak human strength and c) was a much better fighter. Matt has way more going for him then Dick does and Frank still holds his own.

does he not have peak human strength? 😕
fighting ability I'd say is debatable as well...

Nightwing win's this.

Originally posted by jinzin
to my knowledge dd has a winning record.. not to mention the fact that frank has admitted on at least two occasions that he doesn't stand as chance against dd...

does he not have peak human strength? 😕
fighting ability I'd say is debatable as well...

I said dd has the majority, but u fail to mention how punisher has kicked dd's ass before and how he is able to hang with him and even give dd an ass whoopin...so what u are saying is that nightwing can beat dd, or give dd more of a beating than frank does...

Originally posted by jinzin
does he not have peak human strength? 😕
fighting ability I'd say is debatable as well...

No he doesn't have peak human strength. He has peak human speed and agility. Batman has peak human strength while he doesn't have peak human speed or agility. You would need to combine Batman and Nightwing into one package to get one Daredevil.

And if Daredevil isn't as skilled as Batman (which he is) he is defiantly close which means he is better then Nightwing.