ROTS Obi and Yoda vs ROTS Anikan and Sidious

Hmm....Im sure this has been done somewhere but I can't find it. Search button doesn't work very well for me. 😮

Anyway, setting is The Generals Quarters on the Invisible Hand (the place where the duo fought Dooku)\

EDIT :Apologize for spelling. I messed up

Sidious's team wins. One way, Anakin and Obi-Wan fight while Yoda takes on Sidious. Sidious vs. Yoda could go either way but Sidious beat him before so I give it to him. Lucas stated that Anakin > Obi-Wan. I know Obi-Wan beat him in ROTS, but that was Vader he beat, not Anakin. But this way'd be extremely close.

The other way Anakin fights Yoda while Sidious fights Obi-Wan. Sidious's pwn Obi-Wan with the Force, just like Dooku did. Meanwhile, Anakin would be losing to Yoda but he'd be able to hold him off until Sidious pwnd Obi-Wan. Then Anakin and Sidious together would destroy Yoda.

Eitther way, Sidious and Anakin win.

According to Lucas, Anakin should be way more powerful than Obi wan, so in a real fight not taking into account Anakin making some dumbass mistake, Anakin would defeat Obi. Sidious and Yoda are at the very least equal, I would argue Sidious is stronger. Regardless, Anakin defeats Obi and then turns the tide of the Sidious vs Yoda duel.

I don't believe that "according to Lucas" crap. No offense, GV, but Lucas doesn't make any sense and people always say that he said something, but never show where or when.

I'd say that Obi-wan would go after Anakin, killing him, and Yoda would go after Sidious, killing him. Yoda and Obi-wan win without losses.

Or Sidious just annihilates Obi-wan without trying

And Yoda does the same to Anakin. Then Yoda kills Sidious in a drawn out battle.

Actually, Yoda loses. In pretty much any EU source, he realizes any continued battle with Sidious would end in his death

More of your BS?

ROTS novelization. NEC.
Trying to ignore what the EU says?

Originally posted by Darth_Glentract
I don't believe that "according to Lucas" crap. No offense, GV, but Lucas doesn't make any sense and people always say that he said something, but never show where or when.

I'd say that Obi-wan would go after Anakin, killing him, and Yoda would go after Sidious, killing him. Yoda and Obi-wan win without losses.

Regardless of whether GL makes sense or not, he is the absolute authority.

Keep in mind Anakin was completely overwhelmed by grief on Mustafar. You tend not to duel very well when you can't concentrate. Assuming Anakin's clearminded/knows what he's doing... There are also some quotes made by GL pointing to him being more powerful than Sidious himself. Making him possibly the most powerful of the PT era.

Sidious/Anakin win.

Originally posted by Lightsnake
ROTS novelization. NEC.
Trying to ignore what the EU says?

Where in the NEC does it say that?

he was unable to defeat the most powerful sith in history, quote unquote

Originally posted by Lightsnake
he was unable to defeat the most powerful sith in history, quote unquote

Okay, he was unable to defeat him, however, that has nothing to do with what you said:

he realizes any continued battle with Sidious would end in his death

Then you went on to say the NEC clarifies it as well, which it doesn't. Maybe the ROTS novelization confirms it, however, the NEC does not.

Fair enough, ROTS novelization then

Originally posted by Razielim
Keep in mind Anakin was completely overwhelmed by grief on Mustafar. You tend not to duel very well when you can't concentrate. Assuming Anakin's clearminded/knows what he's doing... There are also some quotes made by GL pointing to him being more powerful than Sidious himself. Making him possibly the most powerful of the PT era.

Sidious/Anakin win.

So Obi-Wan was happy as a daisy?

he wasn't psychotic over his lover's 'betrayal'

Originally posted by Lightsnake
he wasn't psychotic over his lover's 'betrayal'

And I'm sure he wasn't torn by the fact someone he calls his "brother", turned to the Darkside.

still, he wasn't dealing with what Anakin was...he came there with the intention of defeating Anakin

Originally posted by Lightsnake
still, he wasn't dealing with what Anakin was...he came there with the intention of defeating Anakin

Didn't Anakin even point out that Obi-Wan "hesitated", and then went on further to even say "the flaw of compassion" or something like that, and if I remember, this was during their battle.

And, as well Obi-Wan loved Anakin. Not in the way you love Sidious 😛 but like a brother as I've said. Of course he'd be conflicted during the fight, and still in emotional shambles -- you realize even though Obi-Wan is a Jedi, and a fictional character, he does have human feelings and emotions. I mean when Anakin gets burned up, he can't even stand to look.