Originally posted by ESB -1138
Mind giving me a full review because I'm still debating about this game and I trust your judgment.
Hmmmm.....
Basically, its a 15-20 hour adrenaline rush. Incredible new gameplay early in the game as you ease into the story, while epic storytelling carry the last three acts which are light on gameplay.
The first two acts showcase the all the new innovations brilliantly. Sneaking on hectic battle grounds with two sides fighting oblivious to your presence, unless you choose to takes sides, which can be beneficial to advancing up the battlefield. The controllable camera from Subsistence never acts up, the new third person shooting cam and ability to run while crouch make the series finally feel modern, and some of the best action gameplay I have played(at least in the first two acts). The Drebin blackmarket item system makes the game more approachable for players seeking action who lack the patience to sneak.
In the last three acts Kojima really pours on the storytelling with gameplay taking a backseat. Act III is basically two sections of gameplay. The first section is new to the series, but not exactly the intense fun of the earlier game. This is about the time the 30-40 minute scenes kick in, which I dont count against the game, because they are that good.
Act IV is basically straight up Metal Gear nostalgia, which ends in what can best be called a MGS fan's wetdream. Act 5 features little real gameplay aside from the opening section and 2 bossfights(and another funny bit of fan service). But you can deny the epicness, if thats a word, of the final act. The score kicks into overdrive, the stakes are raised for every character and one extremely well done interactive sequence makes you endure the pain Snake is going through. The ending makes a lot of contradictions to the previous games, and even segments in this game just hours before. Kojima seemed to struggle with pleasing fans of all the games and all the character, and suffers from leaving too many questions until the end.
Presentation, probably the best game I have played on all fronts. The graphics damn near perfect, the sound effects and score are bombastic and inspire you at all the right times. The cutscenes are long and frequent, but 99% of the time they are terrific, aside from some strange dialogue and a few unbelievable "WTFs". The voice acting is terrific aside from a few horrible lines, David Hayter's Snake is probably the most impressive voice work in a game I have seen.
Metal Gear Online is hard for me, I have been playing Xbox Live since it launched, and I just cant stand the setup for this game. You have to setup mutliple IDs and passwords, but of course they cant be the same. You can make one character who you cant go back and edit, and must pay to make a new character. Plus side, the gameplay is cool(maps too small for me) and lag free from what I saw.
Overall: The best game I have played this year, and it struck me emotionally more than any game I have played. Incredibly intense, and perfectly epic feel for the "last" of the Snake saga. The game is short, and only replayable for completionists. My personal distaste for the online may differ from normal PS3 players, but I cant see myself playing much in the future. If you have a PS3, by all means, buy this game. If you dont have one, dont buy it solely for this game, unless you are the most hardcore of MGS fan, who have probably already done just that. I'd score the game a 9 or 9.5. And there is always the factor of a directors cut version coming just like the previous games.