Anakin Skywalker versus Obi-Wan Kenobi

Setting is in the temple training room. This is dark side Anakin as he was at the end of ROTS. This is ROTS Obi-Wan.

u idiot did u even c rots they did fight and obi won

On mustufar...

Sidious vs Yoda in the senate chamber.

Clothing: Pink bathrobes. Which one wins?

Originally posted by BLAK FOX
Setting is in the temple training room. This is dark side Anakin as he was at the end of ROTS. This is ROTS Obi-Wan.

The temple room as it is described in the game ROTS? Well, there are not many things to claim a high ground here, but I don't know if that is Obi's only chance of survival. I don't know...

Obi dies. Anakin thinking clearly + no highground = dead Kenobi.

Anakin+darkside=not thinking clearly..

Anakin wins. Obi-Wan was getting tired at the end of their duel on Mustafar. "This is the end for you, my Master." Anakin knew Kenobi was getting tired. With no high ground and mostly-flat terrain in the Temple I can't see Obi-Wan walking away alive.

Originally posted by tdtd
Anakin+darkside=not thinking clearly..

Not always. He used the Dark Side against Dooku and... well, dropped him in a minute and a half.

I wouldn't call it the same thing, he used anger sure. When he's fully turned by the fight on Mustafar, he's an imbecile.

Honestly, I think that had most to do with Padme. I mean, he must have been going through alot to have her turn against him like that. He was badly emotionally conflicted. That, along with Kenobi knowing him inside out, and Kenobi managing to take a highground advantage, led to his defeat.

Though his mental problems seemed to dissapear when Obi removed three of his limbs.

Perhaps, which ANakin is this?

Originally posted by darthsith19
Anakin wins. Obi-Wan was getting tired at the end of their duel on Mustafar. "This is the end for you, my Master." Anakin knew Kenobi was getting tired. With no high ground and mostly-flat terrain in the Temple I can't see Obi-Wan walking away alive.

Huzzah for literalism! Do you know what taunting an opponent is?

Originally posted by Swirly Girl
Huzzah for literalism! Do you know what taunting an opponent is?

Anakin is an ill tempered brute.

Obi wan would probably say, "ZOMG Padme was soooooooo good," and Anakin, angry, would charge in and get owned.

Anakin is incompetent

Anyone with a sturdy temperament and half a brain could pwn Anakin.

We've seen Kenobi rape Anakin and he was on par with him during the entire fight.

Anakin would start to get mad and swing widly like he did with Asajj, who sucked too much to defend Anakin's rage.

Kenobi has virtually mastered Soresu and would most likely defend his enraged attacks, find a flaw and take out his limbs again.

Anakin is the better duelist, but he's stupid and arrogant. Kenobi takes the victory.

anakin's styles totally different from obi-wan;s. anakin is showy. obi-wan is direct with his strikes. that's why he's tired at the end.
even though obi-wan has more experience, and i believe he was holding back beacause of his relationship with anakin.

Lol, look at the Dooku fight. Obi gets pwnd, Anakin wins. He's superior to Obi-Wan.