The JSA vs The JLA

The JSA:
Hawkman
Cap.Marvel
G.L Alen Scott
Stargirl
Power Girl
Flash
Hawkgirl

vs

The JLA:
Batman
Superman
G.L Kyle
Wonder Woman
Manhunter
Flash
Aquaman

No prep. Who wins ?

thats a hard one cause jsa older more experince

Originally posted by Malo
The JSA:
Hawkman
Cap.Marvel
G.L Alen Scott
Stargirl
Power Girl
Flash
Hawkgirl

vs

The JLA:
Batman
Superman
G.L Kyle
Wonder Woman
Manhunter
Flash
Aquaman

No prep. Who wins ?

Flash = Flash
Alan >> Kyle
Superman/WW > Powergirl/Marvel
Manhunter/Aquaman > Stargirl/Hawkpeople
Batman is a non-factor.

For me it comes down to Alan. He would dispatch Kyle more quickly than Supes and WW would beat Marvel and Powergirl (who isn't a slouch). Then it becomes a bit lopsided.

Good fight though. And the JLA could definitely pull it out if they play their cards correctly. That, and since Supes is a walking PIS machine, the writers of this fight might just have him go uber and win the thing himself. But I'd give it to the JSA 6-7/10

Originally posted by DigiMark007
Flash = Flash
Alan >> Kyle
Superman/WW > Powergirl/Marvel
Manhunter/Aquaman > Stargirl/Hawkpeople
Batman is a non-factor.

For me it comes down to Alan. He would dispatch Kyle more quickly than Supes and WW would beat Marvel and Powergirl (who isn't a slouch). Then it becomes a bit lopsided.

Good fight though. And the JLA could definitely pull it out if they play their cards correctly. That, and since Supes is a walking PIS machine, the writers of this fight might just have him go uber and win the thing himself. But I'd give it to the JSA 6-7/10

*Badabing Batkicks Digi square in the....." *😛

id say jsa i agree that alen could take kyle but it would be harder then u think cause he does develop to be a perrty badass gl

Originally posted by He-guy88
id say jsa i agree that alen could take kyle but it would be harder then u think cause he does develop to be a perrty badass gl

Fair enough, but any group fight still comes down to the few most powerful members. And once Alan beats Kyle, it's downhill for the JLA, unless they focus on taking him out (which wouldn't be easy with the others there as well) since he's the only major advantage the JSA has in this fight.

o yeah i agree wit that

I say JLA. I don't see the Society taking a majority without a Dr. Fate in their ranks. He's the sole reason why I've usually considered the JSA a notch above the League.

thats a good point but i still say jsa just by pure exp

their so old they perrty know all the stragitys lol

Originally posted by Validus
I say JLA. I don't see the Society taking a majority without a Dr. Fate in their ranks. He's the sole reason why I've usually considered the JSA a notch above the League.

I'd say their experience edge is offset by the flat out superior power levels of the JLA especially looking at Digi's match ups which include WW Vs Power Girl and J'onn/Orin Vs the Hawks.

yeah they do have higher power levels but u cant win a fight by pure power u gotta be able to think on ur feet and out smart the opponent

Originally posted by He-guy88
yeah they do have higher power levels but u cant win a fight by pure power u gotta be able to think on ur feet and out smart the opponent

There's a 100% chance that WW beats Power Girl and MM/Orin beat the Hawks before Alan beats Kyle and thats if Alan beats Kyle at all considering it's far from a sure thing.

ok then look at this mm no telapath powers just for argument sake if hawk can manover mm to a bad postion then he can win

Originally posted by Malo
The JSA:
Hawkman
Cap.Marvel
G.L Alen Scott
Stargirl
Power Girl
Flash
Hawkgirl

vs

The JLA:
Batman
Superman
G.L Kyle
Wonder Woman
Manhunter
Flash
Aquaman

No prep. Who wins ?

J'onn is faster, stronger, smarter, more versatile, and better than the Hawks at just about everything important involving a fight. Unless Carter is packing the Claw of Horus, he wouldn't last 2 minutes in a non PIS/CIS fight.

The JLA has have the advantage (if I'm not mistaken) of having the only telepaths in this fight on their team. I'd also give the edge to the JLA if we are talking about Jay vs Wally in terms of the teams respective Flashs.

The way I see it there are two key fights here: Superman vs Captain Marvel and Kyle vs Alan. Superman and Cap are on fairly even ground so that is a stalemate for a while at least. And if Kyle is able just to hold his own against Alan for a little while then that would leave WW vs Powergirl, Wally vs Jay, MM & Aquaman vs the Hawlpeople & Stargirl all of which I see the JLA members winning fairly quickly.

Then they would be able to overwhelm Captain Marvel and Alan with sheer numbers, imo.

i have to agree wit some of that but wally is made to be a littel less powerful then the other flashes now if barry allen were to take his place then barrey easy hes faster then speed of light all the other falshes and superman only got up to speed of light thats how he died he ran so fast not even the speed force could protect him

Originally posted by diabloman
what does the jsa stand for ?