Originally posted by Lord Lucien
A killer and an outlaw finally getting gunned down. Not sad.
A killer and outlaw went through the effort of personally reforming himself, earning a living, and adequately raising a son, trying to put the bloody past of his behind him. He specifically wants his son to live a better life than the one he was forced into by circumstance, and actually seems to be succeeding.
Then, Edgar Ross holds his wife and son hostage, and forces him to kill once more, but promises a full pardon for his past acts if he brings in three deadly outlaws, which John actually manages to do.
Then Ross goes against his word and attacks John's farm, for the purpose of killing John and his family. John has his son and wife ride away from him while he goes out to stall the military, and that is all he can do, stall them, and he is promptly gunned down.
But apparently gunning down a farmer who by now has received a pardon for his past crimes is just cool. 👆
Oh but there's more! A few years later, after John's wife (I honestly forgot her name), Jack Marston has become an outlaw and gunslinger, and promptly murders Ross, who has by now proven himself to be traitorous scum, for revenge. Only... This is the exact opposite of what John wanted for Jack, and in-game dialogue indicates that Jack lives a hollow, empty life. This is a downer ending.
Are you trolling?