ANH Kenobi vs RotS Kenobi.

Started by jollyjim3113 pages

Dooku couldn't beat Sidious. As simple as that.

Hm, I'm pretty damn sure Dooku can take him in a saber fight but when Sidious whips out the force... I don't see Dooku taking it.

No. Sidious is greater than Dooku in every aspect.

If Dooku were greater, he would have killed Sids. The Sith philosophy is "Survival of the Fittest"

Originally posted by jollyjim311
AotC Dooku was good with his saber, and who was he practicing with? Greivous? At that point in time? Barely, if any at all. He didn't seem dusty at all.

Ummm....Sidious maybe?

True, but not often, Sidious had a lot of public appearances to make as chancellor. By the way, if Dooku was better than Sidious in a lightsaber fight, they would have been sparring, and Dooku would have surprised and killed him. He not only didn't, he couldn't. Sidious is better than Dooku. (<- Period.) Anyway, let's get back on topic. The saber fight seems to be the biggest issue of debate. I'm still undecided on this one.

Dooku practiced with Grievous, as stated in LOE, and he practiced against his other Dark Acolytes and against other Jedi who attacked him (he fought Sora Bulq and Tholme, Yoda twice and Mace Windu). That's how he stayed in shape.

Yea but his question was who was Dooku training with before the Clone Wars began. Grievous and his Acolytes didn't much exist at that point. (except Komari Vosa, but she was killed)

So at least he practiced with Vosa and Sidious before AOTC that I know of.

Originally posted by Great Vengeance
Well, something you 'recall' doesnt have much worth. You need to give a link or something that proves that this quote actually exists.

Lucas says it in the Feel the Force documentary that the reason for the style of fighting being so different, was that in the OT the only people doing so were an old man, someone who was half machine, and a boy who had very little training, compared to the PT where we were seeing fully trained Jedi in their prime.

Originally posted by ((The_Anomaly))
Yea but his question was who was Dooku training with before the Clone Wars began. Grievous and his Acolytes didn't much exist at that point. (except Komari Vosa, but she was killed)

So at least he practiced with Vosa and Sidious before AOTC that I know of.


No, he practiced with Jedi, probably Syfo-Dyas, and then he joined the Sith and got to busy creating the Clone Army and forming rhe CIS to practice.

I thought he killed Syfo-Dyas...?

How long before AOTC did Dooku leave the Jedi Order? I actually dont know.

Originally posted by ((The_Anomaly))
I thought he killed Syfo-Dyas...?

How long before AOTC did Dooku leave the Jedi Order? I actually dont know.

He did, and Syfo-Dyas is noted in LoE IIRC to be a friend of his or something. And Dooku left the Order not long post-TPM.

I think it was a little over 10 years ago. Sifo Dyas died 10 years ago, and he and count dooku ordered the clones for prep. already. I don't really know, but at least 10 years.

Yea I thought so, So Dooku couldn't of dueled with Dyas pre-AOTC.

No, Syfo Dyas ordered the Clone army. He dead a little after TPM so there was time to duel him. But, like I said, Dooku was to busy to practice alot.

Originally posted by darthsith19
No. Sidious is greater than Dooku in every aspect.

No, not so much. I think Dooku could take Sidious in a Lightsaber fight after a while. But when the Force comes? Sidious takes it. By far.

Originally posted by Xavius
No, not so much. I think Dooku could take Sidious in a Lightsaber fight after a while. But when the Force comes? Sidious takes it. By far.

Sidious did better against Yoda, even in the saber duel. It's close but Sidious would take him even in a saber fight.

Wow.....I saw it comming, but..... I can't belive this just turned into a Dooku vs Sidious thread.