Originally posted by Avalonofthewind
I'm delighted to bring thoughtful scenarios for those who like to think about their battles. 😉 Even if I bring up what iniatially may sound as a "blasphemous" point...there is usually good reason behind it even if I don't spell it out right away.Superman does have the strength without problem as witnessed when
physically beating Darkseid. At the very least, even "Jobberseid" is stat for stat even with Thanos. I've also never seen Thanos punch anyone across the Solar System at faster than light speeds and shake the earth when landing behind them.Let's remember, if Supes didn't job in his comics somewhat...his title would last as long as SS series... 😆
Durability is in the eye of the beholder, fox example...lets swap enemies.
Superman vs Odin - Odin has a distinct magical advantage, given the same magical blasts used against Superman..life would indeed be a painful one for our man of steel.
Thanos vs Asmodel - This too is a magical opponent, but Thanos would not have survived the light of heaven attack due to it's nature. Given his status at the time, death would not have tried to reverse the decision against Thanos dying either.
Black Hole - This has been gone over.
Tyrant - Thanos obviously had prep on this one, Supes with the same prep would have done just as well..he does have some nice kryptonian toys as well.
He's also had trouble with Thor when facing him one on one as well as
Morg, Adam Warlock, Ka-zar...etc. Concidently, enemies that SS has fared quite well against on his own.Against Herald powered enemies, he's shown to have used it instantly.
Against ridiculously powerful cosmic beings, it takes effort. Due to the
massive difference in speed levels, it would not be a problem to use on Thanos at all.
ya see, this is what happened on the supes v thanos thread. my GUT tells me from everything i've seen thanos should/would beat supes. but there IS a lot of evidence suggesting supes could stand up to him.
to a couple of your points -- don't forget i'm using all characters at what i perceive to be their most consistent levels, so uber high end feats don't count . . . that's more a disadvantage to supes cuz thanos doesn't have many low showings. the gem is usually what does it with adam (and adam is a totally weirded out character anyway who's own stats seem to fluctuate wildly . . .) thor HAS had some good showings, unfortunately, most were retconned and more recent showings have thanos being well above him. 🙁 though in thor's defense he wasn't written to potential. 😉
supes survived asmodel because of his nature, not durability, so i'll discount that, but supes and ss DO have some feats that seem to put them in thanos's class.
already avy, i'm not really debating this with you because we're pretty close in how we're seeing things, but you gotta answer this then: why does thanos so easily beat herald level characters and, well, any other top tier? and please don't resort to the fact that they 'job' . . . he's done it with far too much consistency for me to accept that answer. so . . . how does he do it??
(oh, and we sort of ARE on topic still . . . kinda . . . in an esoteric, spirt-of-the-thread kinda way . . . sorta . . . er . . . right.)
😄