this is how it would go down. grievous would take maul and win.anakin and mace are about equal. I think mace would win though through his experience. mace beat sidious in a duel so he could beat anakin barely.so its down to mace and grievous. mace defenitely could have done wat obi did and more. mace probally would've ended at the beggining with his lightsaber.
Originally posted by kamikz
Yup, Anakin disarmed Assaj, but she escaped. Then she was owned in the temple, at the top she managed to disarm him (but Anakin had already done that to her in the last few minutes) but he still won.... And that was padawan Anakin.....
Yeah but Anakin has only trained for a short duration of years, many of the council members disagreed to him being promoted to a knight. But if we are only going to judge his fighting capability then I could say that he would be a master by Obsession so there is no need in calling him a knight in ROTS...... Thing is that either if you call Anakin a padawan or a knight, he did evolve alot during only those last two years in the clone wars as well.
Explain his heroic efforts.
1.) Ok.
2.) I never really understood that. Why too old when he was like 4 years old.
3.) So..since when does training time make a difference. Luke with minimal training bested Vader, Anakin overcame Dooku. Mace at a young age was able to contend with many Knights and Padawans.
They need other things than accomplished feats in war....
Anakin was 9 when he begun his traning. Most or many jedi begun when they were months old.
Luke was still a padawan at the time, and he wasn't trained by an order of jedi, he was trained by Yoda and was the only hope for the future jedi. Anakin did also not evolve as quickly as Luke. (Might be that Luke was already old when he started his traning, thus he learnt faster, and had a less troublled past).
But this is very weird. People are differently powerful, thus you cannot say, "he is at the level of a master so he is a master", they don't have the same potential and skills. For example, Luke was awefully much above Yoda, still they were both grandmasters. Luke did not have a level of super jedi or force god, just a master for the time in NJO. Even if Anakin was better than any other padawan and possibly any knight doesn't mean he is a knight or should be one....
Originally posted by kamikz
They need other things than accomplished feats in war....Anakin was 9 when he begun his traning. Most or many jedi begun when they were months old.
Luke was still a padawan at the time, and he wasn't trained by an order of jedi, he was trained by Yoda and was the only hope for the future jedi. Anakin did also not evolve as quickly as Luke. (Might be that Luke was already old when he started his traning, thus he learnt faster, and had a less troublled past).
But this is very weird. People are differently powerful, thus you cannot say, "he is at the level of a master so he is a master", they don't have the same potential and skills. For example, Luke was awefully much above Yoda, still they were both grandmasters. Luke did not have a level of super jedi or force god, just a master for the time in NJO. Even if Anakin was better than any other padawan and possibly any knight doesn't mean he is a knight or should be one....
Not Luke.
Anakin had more potential than Luke, so I dont understand how he "evolved" slower.
Well thats because master is the last rank someone could recieve. Anakin had the most potential of all Jedi including yoda. His skills were enough to overcome Dooku. One of the best lightsaber to lightsaber duelists. Once again at a young age, Mace was at the level of a master, so he was promoted to one. The same should have happened with Ani.