The Exil vs Exar Kun

Exar Kun is neither the first nor the second..

Kevin J. Anderson puts him as strongest Sith of ancient times, making him one of the top

Again, show me your credible source lightsnake. Kun was the strongest of his time but logically he was nowhere near the "Ancient Sith". If you forget, he learned maybe a fraction or maybe a lot of Sadow's teacher, which only THAT elevated his status.

It was mentioned by anderson in a commentary or something that Exar>Ragnos>simus>naga>Ludo>the rest of the sith> or = the average jedi. Exar>Exile in other words. And where does it say that exile is a girl?

Where was it mentioned that Exar Kun is more powerful than any of the ancient sith? Its not logical not to mention I've never seen anyone say that.

I rate Exar on par with the more powerful ancient sith such as Sadow or Simus.

what's your reasoning for this? Simus was like the best sith alchemist of his time or ever I think. Kun would be below the ancient sith and on par with Nadd, or higher than Nadd since we know very little about him.

The only thing that the ancient sith have on Exar Kun is better equipment. Exar Kun has way more potential.

Why? The AUTHOR of the ancient sith comics, the one who has gotten full credit for the ancient sith, says that Kun is better....

And this is logical because? And this isn't your opinion? Explain yourself, how does Kun have more potential? And if you remember, the ancient sith CREATED their equipment, the ancient sith were masters of sith alchemy and sith magic, Sadow created the amulet that gave Kun his power. By that virtue alone, Sadow had more knowledge and power than Kun.

Exactly. They were all great alchemists. That however does not help them in a vs. match.

Youre right, forget the fact that Sadow has his amulet which he had no trouble controlling while Kun had to learn to control it, forget the fact that Sadow's dark side powers were natural to him because he was a sith, as opposed to Exar Kun who had to fall to the dark side to use his abilities, forget the fact that Sadow swung his incredibly heavy sword with the speed of a lightsaber. Kun is simply outmatched.

I'm going to ignore most of tha because it is completely rediculous.

"forget the fact that Sadow swung his incredibly heavy sword with the speed of a lightsaber"

As fast as a saber? Since when?

Ridiculous? You mean fact? Have you read the TOTJ companion or GAOTS? I didn't think so..

Fact? So Sadow swinging his sword as fast as a saber is FACT?
And this (Youre right, forget the fact that Sadow has his amulet which he had no trouble controlling while Kun had to learn to control it, forget the fact that Sadow's dark side powers were natural to him because he was a sith, as opposed to Exar Kun who had to fall to the dark side to use his abilities) really is rediculous.

@ Darth...........:
Listen, the one who got full credit by the guy who CREATED them said Kun is better, this should be proof enough, why are you arguing against it? It isn't my opinion, it is Kevin J Andersons, it is YOUR opinion that the ancient are above him...

It's not ridiculous LOL. You notice how in GAOTS the sith didn't have to FALL to the dark side? Dark side magic to the sith is natural, as it was when the outcast jedi found them. And the ancient sith were known to swing their sabers as fast as anyone swung their light sabers, meaning they were physically more powerful than humans and most jedi. And again, Sadow had enough power to control the amulet he created, and if you saw the power of the amulet, you'd understand the incredible power that Sadow had to put into it, which puts him above Kun.

Originally posted by kamikz
@ Darth...........:
Listen, the one who got full credit by the guy who CREATED them said Kun is better, this should be proof enough, why are you arguing against it? It isn't my opinion, it is Kevin J Andersons, it is YOUR opinion that the ancient are above him...

Show me the quote. I'd like to see a definitive statement. All I've seen on this forum is talk, but nobody can provide this proof. I did see a fake email by someone from a long time ago.

Problem is: Logic doesn't outweigh the creator's opinion.

Darth Sexy is a sock.