Originally posted by Validus
I won't call you biased but it isn't a good idea to go around saying Character X is badly written unless, you know, actually read Character X's books.
What kind of logic is that? If I consider a character to be badly written, reading his books is the LAST thing I'm going to be doing. Why would I want to read a poorly-thought out comic?
Originally posted by Soljer
What kind of logic is that? If I consider a character to be badly written, reading his books is the LAST thing I'm going to be doing. Why would I want to read a poorly-thought out comic?
I've never read Spider-Girl so who the hell am I to sit here and say she's badly written as if it were a fact?
Well as for Sentry having random powers, there is an explanation. Sentry's powers have yet to be fully defined and gauged. He has never gone balls to the wall yet. His creators have not yet put a limit on him. Unlike Superman who's powers come out of nowhere with no reasonable explanation except for the fact that he is Superman. Just when you thought Superman has reached his pinnacle of power, another writer totally ignores what others have written and adds on another power.
Originally posted by Validus
Maybe because your idea that he's badly written is based on pure supposition? ohI've never read Spider-Girl so who the hell am I to sit here and say she's badly written as if it were a fact?
*rolls eyes* Get serious, there are three possibilities:
1. A person reads a few of character X's comics, decides X is poorly written, and stops reading.
2. A person reads X on a consistent basis, but still consider's him poorly written. And for some, psychotic reason, the person keeps reading.
3. A person has NEVER read a word of person X's comic, and decides that X is poorly written.
Now, two of the three are just RIDICULOUS. I very much doubt anyone who has never opened an 'X' comic is going to be calling X poorly written. It defies logic. Just as you expecting someone to keep up reading a poorly written comic defies knowledge.
What do you expect the thought process to be? "Well, this comic sucked, was ridiculous, and full of PIS, just like the last three gross I've read, but...you know, maybe the next one will be better! I'll pick it up next week!"
.....
Originally posted by Adam Warlock
Well as for Sentry having random powers, there is an explanation. Sentry's powers have yet to be fully defined and gauged. He has never gone balls to the wall yet. His creators have not yet put a limit on him. Unlike Superman who's powers come out of nowhere with no reasonable explanation except for the fact that he is Superman. Just when you thought Superman has reached his pinnacle of power, another writer totally ignores what others have written and adds on another power.
I thought I was the only one
Originally posted by Soljer
*rolls eyes* Get serious, there are three possibilities:1. A person reads a few of character X's comics, decides X is poorly written, and stops reading.
2. A person reads X on a consistent basis, but still consider's him poorly written. And for some, psychotic reason, the person keeps reading.
3. A person has NEVER read a word of person X's comic, and decides that X is poorly written.
Now, two of the three are just RIDICULOUS. I very much doubt anyone who has never opened an 'X' comic is going to be calling X poorly written. It defies logic. Just as you expecting someone to keep up reading a poorly written comic defies knowledge.
What do you expect the thought process to be? "Well, this comic sucked, was ridiculous, and full of PIS, just like the last three gross I've read, but...you know, maybe the next one will be better! I'll pick it up next week!"
.....
One and Two are based upon actually reading the comic. Not really much to say there.
Number 3 is based on the idea that a comic book is static and nothing ever changes about it. The Flash is one of the most popular super-heroes on this site and there was a time when his comic was easily one of the worst out of DC yet that changed? Why? You don't think it's because his creative team changed? oh
It's a simple fact that a character with a bad writer is going to be badly written. You don't see me singing praises for the Chuck Austen Superman stories. What you see is me singing praises for the Grant Morrison, Geoff Johns and Kurt Busiek written Superman. Who would imagine that a good writer can write a good story?
Some of you guys say the dumbest thing, i wont name names or highlight an individual but someone a few posts up said something about writers increasing supes power inconsistently well at least supes has a set power base. On the other hand the sentry (A.K.A Mr rip of) is said every single time to not have reached his limit yet. Now thats the writers stalling its a way for them to keep boosting sentry i can just imagine it now, writer one: Whose sentry fighting today, writer2: Hmmmmmmm well thors coming back and well sentry isnt that bad, Writer1: Winks at writer2 sure he is his holding back remember.
Originally posted by sexyking
Some of you guys say the dumbest thing, i wont name names or highlight an individual but someone a few posts up said something about writers increasing supes power inconsistently well at least supes has a set power base. On the other hand the sentry (A.K.A Mr rip of) is said every single time to not have reached his limit yet. Now thats the writers stalling its a way for them to keep boosting sentry i can just imagine it now, writer one: Whose sentry fighting today, writer2: Hmmmmmmm well thors coming back and well sentry isnt that bad, Writer1: Winks at writer2 sure he is his holding back remember.
🤨 since when has Superman had a set power base? Sentry is a new character, this his powers aren't defined yet.
[QUOTE=6926564]Originally posted by Soujaboy
🤨 since when has Superman had a set power base? Sentry is a new character, this his powers aren't defined yet. [/QUOTE
🙄 Hear goes
Super breath, xray vision, Scope vision,Heat beams,superhearing,superbreath, the only power of his that does vary is the strength and well that piece of sh.. soul vision but i dont even think thats permanent and to most people birthright isnt canon.
While on the other hand you have Sentry new or not its complete nonsense ohh his powers are unlimited what kind of crap is that and people complain about supes been overpowered basically sentry is as strong as whoever his fighting whether ironman to flaming Galactus.