Jack and Liz vs. Will and Liz

Started by LovelyOne14 pages

I'm convinced that its not Jack its going to happen to..she left him and he loved her for it 😂

She leaves Will..and he turns into a jerk..

I'm not sure it would really bother Jack if Liz was engaged. That kiss kind of implied it was all over anyway.

I think is should be Jack and Liz. I love thir chemistry
Ever noticed how thier last manes are both Birds, Sparrow and Swann, Maybe that means they will fly( sail) away together in the end 🙂

Originally posted by willofthewisp
I'm not sure it would really bother Jack if Liz was engaged. That kiss kind of implied it was all over anyway.

uh.....what?...its in no way over after that kiss..did you not see her staring at his lips trying desperatley not to kiss him again ..even he went in to kiss her again.. 😛 .. he saw that she still wants him and smiles with pride "pirate"..as in "Ah so you aint really Wills then ay? you are MINE *****!"..he's gonna keep chasing after that key believe me..

Jack's character has taken on a new level of clarity for me. i HAVE to go see the movie again, to get the full effect.

I originally thought that Jack honestly didnt know what he wanted, and didnt start thinking about Liz till she showed up.

But with this news from Ted, its pretty clear Jack has wanted her all along, and that is really hott.

its like, little by little throughout two, Jack is getting more and more of what he wants.

it also makes me think Jack is testing them both... testing WIll to see if he really wants Elizabeth, and testing Elizabeth to see if she would really be happy with Will. you know?

So once Will gets on the kick about his dad, Jack's attitude towards him changes somewhat. do you notice that?

And once Elizabeth kisses him, he realizes she WONT be happy with Will.

make sense? 🙂

I feel kinda bad for Will though. He's a good guy really and he really cares for Liz. I mean its not really his fault he's not as awesome as Jack.

No, LovelyOne. I meant to say that the kiss showed things were over between Liz and WILL. Sorry if I was unclear. I saw her go in for another one.

Originally posted by LovelyOne
uh.....what?...its in no way over after that kiss..did you not see her staring at his lips trying desperatley not to kiss him again ..even he went in to kiss her again.. 😛 .. he saw that she still wants him and smiles with pride "pirate"..as in "Ah so you aint really Wills then ay? you are MINE *****!"..he's gonna keep chasing after that key believe me..

I agree.....as always 😄

Sorry if I'm interrupting but I think this is a really interesting topic. I also agree with blackpearl44. 🙂 May I join your disscussion?

I think Will and Elizabeth should stay together. 🙂

Originally posted by Lizzy1212
I think Will and Elizabeth should stay together. 🙂
.oh you poor thing...i'll pray for you...

hahahah

Originally posted by blackpearl89
Sorry if I'm interrupting but I think this is a really interesting topic. I also agree with blackpearl44. 🙂 May I join your disscussion?

Sure, of coarse you can 🙂

I hope Will and Jack become friends again. They work so great as a team they watch their backs for eachother the problem is that they watch their backs against eachother too(<<does that makes sense??)
Anyways hopefully Will will see Jack as a good pirate and a good man. I hope they can still be friends/aquintance, hopefully Will will come to realize that liz is gonna be happy with jack and that jack will make her happy. I really feel awefully bad for Will but i shouldnt pitty him bc im sure he'll find a better suitor than elizabeth.

Lizzie12, may I please ask why you feel that way? I won't try to argue with you or anything. I just want to know.

PS: Sorry I spelled your name wrong.

honestly Will turner is a stick in the mud..jack sparrow isn't..they both make good couples with liz..who would i choose..i don't know i am not a match maker

How are Liz and Will a good match? The critics blasted their relationship, saying it left Keira Knightley as little more than the token love interest and that she and Orlando Bloom are very stiff and have no chemistry. True, anyone looks stiff next to Jack, but they proved in the second movie they can loosen up. Were they just bad actors in the first one and then suddenly were able to show depth? I'm just thinking their characters don't mesh well.
Liz is too much of a pirate at heart to settle down. What could possibly attract her to Will?
What could Will possibly be attracted to in Liz? They just don't seem to have anything in common and there is never a scene with the two of them just being together. They're always explaining things to each other or fighting evil together and whatnot. They don't have the preump the curiosity scene had, where she and Jack were just sitting around being themselves.
Their faces! Come on! Will has two looks when he sees Liz, the puppy dog look that is well, pathetic, and then stern, oh-liz-what-were-you-thinking look. He gives this one to her less often. Liz has several different facial expressions and even her eyes seem to express her feelings when she's around Jack.

I totally agree with you willo.

In wikipedia is written that:

Knightley accurately sums up this character with the words, "She's some kind of modern girl stuck in the world of the 18th century." Elizabeth, in essence, has the capacity to act with the propriety and breeding of a noble lady, or with the wit and will of a pirate wench. Elizabeth often desires more independence than would normally be given to a woman of her rank during the 18th century.

So why should she coose Will???????? And give up the pirate life?

SHE WOULDN'T!! that's a good exerpt 🙂