Anakin Skywalker vs. Darth Sidious

Started by Nupe Kill Droma4 pages

lol damn, i didn't even have time to edit before you got me! lmao I was looking at two forums! lmao good catch on that one!

Lol

At the beginning I put "Chancellor Palpatine reveals himself as Darth Sidious to Anakin, and instead of going to Mace Windu, he strikes at Palpatine, and they engage in a duel..."

So this is Anakin before the Mustafar duel.

ahhh! that you did! good stuff, but I think I'm going to take Sidious... I'd probably take pre-suit Vader if the scenario were different... but, yeah, I'll go with Sidious... but not by much, especially if we're just talking sabres.

Anything goes, but considering the emptiness of the hall in which Sidious reveals himself, there would be nothing more than simple force pushes.

how bout this? Had Anakin attacked Palps, Papls might have used it as an opportunity to test Anakin himself, being that he is better than Dooku, and maybe, just maybe might underestimate Anakin himself, which Anakin could capitalize on. We dont know if Palps would have used the force in the duel. He could prefer lightsabers until he deemed force powers necessary. If so, Anakin could win, although not easily, otherwise, at THAT point in the movie, Sidious takes him, but not easily either.

Also as far as the Dooku/Anakin thing, this just kinda came to me. Dooku did have an advantage...it was more or less his ship which he knew the layout of (as stated), he KNEW he was going to fight the Jedi and had time to prepare, whereas Anakin didnt know he was going to be fighting Dooku. Also, if you want to take Dooku's word itself...he apparently reveres lighsaber skill as more pertinent than knowledge of the force, kinda like a tie breaker.

"It's obvious this contest can not be settled with our knowledge of the force, but with our skills with a lightsaber."

Or something close to that. Im sure if I messed up even one word, Rampant will be quick to correct me, but to me that means he holds lightsaber combat "in such high esteem".

Anyway, just wanted to add that to further PROVE that Anakin>Dooku... 😄

Sidious. Dooku would have won agaisn't anakin if he hadn't been angry. Sidious is above dooku and also isn't weak to strength attacks and is much faster than anakin and greater in the force by this time. So yes I'd say Sidious.

Originally posted by Gideon
Anakin is among the best-of-the-best in terms of lightsaber ability. In that alone, he can compete and possibly defeat Sidious. However, in an all out fight, Anakin would lose, due to Sidious's superior Force powers.

Agreed.

It's too soon for Anakin to fight Sidious.

Originally posted by McP
It's too soon for Anakin to fight Sidious.

It's always too soon.

Mortis!Anakin, tho.

Yeah. Unless this fight takes place on Mortis, Sidious can take his erstwhile apprentice. Even if Anakin goes Invisible Hand on him, Sidious still has it.

Originally posted by Gideon
Anakin is among the best-of-the-best in terms of lightsaber ability. In that alone, he can compete and possibly defeat Sidious. However, in an all out fight, Anakin would lose, due to Sidious's superior Force powers.

LMAO

Gideon continues to astound 👆

He has actually underrated Sidious' dueling skills in several occasions.