Darth Maul vs. Kit Fisto and AOTC Anakin

Started by Advent3 pages

Cont.

I will believe that Anakin and Kit are uncoordinated together when I have seen proof!

You have offered no proof at all that they will be coordinated other than

"z0mg m4ce n' k1t w3re w0rk1ng t0geth3r for tw0 sec0ndz s0 an4k1n and k1t w1ll be 4n unst0ppab13 du0". You're a fanboy, there's no evidence they will mesh good together. There's actual some contrary to them meshing together.

You have no proof, Medvock, because Kit lasted two seconds with Windu, doesn't mean they were:

a.) Coordinated.
b.) Any good.
c.) Will be good with Anakin.

Kit Fisto is a Jedi Master. Obi-Wan was a padawan. Anakin did a better job against Dooku than his Master (I suppose that's arguable though). Anakin isn’t that terrible!

Yes, he is. And again QUIT COMPARING OBI-WAN TO KIT FISTO, Kit Fisto isn't on par with Qui-Gon Jinn, and Anakin isn't on par with Obi-Wan.

Look, Kit Fisto and AOTC Anakin will never be as coordinated as Qui-Gon Jinn and Obi-Wan were in TPM. To assume they would be is ridiculous, and that is what you are doing. They worked together for twenty plus years, they fought together countless times, and neither Fisto or Anakin have ever worked together, ergo they will not be as coordinated, if they even are coordinated.

Now, keeping that in mind:

"So they challenged the Sith Lord quickly, and just as quickly I discovered that their best efforts were not good enough to achieve an early resolution."

Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan's best efforts weren't good enough. Qui-Gon > Fisto, Obi-Wan > Anakin. And in coordinated Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan >>> Kit Fisto and Anakin, so it's only logical to assume their efforts will be just as futile.

someone said earlier, that isn’t necessarily too much of an issue in a 2 on 1 fight – chances are Darth Maul will be too distracted with Kit to be able to find an opening in Anakin anyways.

Yes, and that someone was pwned, because it was a stupid point:

Originally posted by Advent
How can you say that? Maul was able to defend against two Jedi at once, and I highly doubt either Qui-Gon or Obi-Wan were leaving themselves open. If they were, they would've been killed. Notice Maul, when they are going two on one, is literally beating the brains out of both of them.

I mean, when Kenobi jumped behind him, he blocked his attack while not even looking. He jump kicked Qui-Gon while defending against both of them. He kicked Kenobi, and literally knocked him back ten feet. He pushed Qui-Gon away with just sheer Force, and did the same to Kenobi immediately after. And, gave a spin kick to Kenobi, and he fell down to a completely different platform.

Now any one of those could've been fatal if either Kenobi or Jinn left themselves open, as Anakin would do. So, what do you mean "capitalize" when he was able to capitalize on opponents that were guarding themselves, and fighting smart - [b]not aimlessly as Anakin tends to do. [/B]

And you'll notice he wasn't too busy dealing with both Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan to search for an opening:

"His agility and dexterity allowed him to keep them both at bay, constantly attacking while at the same time effectively blunting their counterattacks, relentlessly searching for an opening in their defense."

So, quit making stupid assumptions, especially when the novel, and movie trump your idiocy.

Nay! I refuse to believe this! WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA!!!

Is that the Kit Fisto "bird call"? Please, Medvock, you're a fanboy, and a delusional one at that. Kit Fisto isn't god, and he will be toppled by Maul. Qui-Gon Jinn was on par with TPM Windu, by the way.

Originally posted by Advent

If we saw anything through your eyes, it'd probably be a Kit Fisto porno.

😆 😆 😘

Sama, I know you really want to put Medvock in his place, and, yeah, it's easy cookies to win this debate, but...

"Originally posted by MEDVOCK
Hehehe. I truly feel sorry for you. Nothing you or any other person on this board says will make me change my mind. You are merely continuing an endless debate. "

Yeah, he's a biased fanboy and you're really just proving things to everyone but him. He won't give up.

By the way "I wish people saw that scene through my eyes..."
If we saw anything from your eyes it would be browsing over the forums all day and looking for any threads with Kit in it, and reciting those same quotes from CD, your personal bible, from memory.

No, he didn't. Because he didn't get killed, he kept up with Maul?

Precisely! How else do you describe Kenobi being able to defend himself against Maul?

Lawls. Let's do a recapulation on the two on one:

- Blocked Kenobi's attack while not even looking.
- Jump kicked Qui-Gon while defending against Obi-Wan.
- Kicked Kenobi and knocked him back ten feet (so much he had to run to catch up).
- Pushed Qui-Gon away with just sheer Force.
- Did the same to Kenobi.
- Spin kicked Kenobi and he fell down to a completely different platform.

And yet, despite his efforts, he was unable to kill a padawan.

"their efforts at attack, at assuming the offensive against this dangerous adversary, were woefully inadequate. "

Now, how is it that a superior duo's attacks were useless, and they were getting pwned, but he can't do it to Kit Fisto and Anakin? Remember, this isn't a one on one, so stop treating it like it is.

“He was the best swordsman Obi-Wan had ever seen, but he was getting old.” That is ultimately the reason why Qui-Gon lost. His age had affected him during the duel. As a result, he was not as fast as his padawan was, and thus gave him quite a large disadvantage against Maul. He is very powerful though.

Kit Fisto does not suffer from old age. Actually, his age is unknown, but considering ROTS is only a few years after AOTC, in which he seemed fairly young, he’s still as fast as he ever was. And Kit Fisto is fast! Not to mention, his flexibility obviously surpasses both Maul’s and Qui-Gon’s. My point here is, Kit is faster and more flexible than Qui-Gon. And considering it is ultimately Maul's speed and youth that gave him the upper hand against Qui-Gon, Kit, being fast himself, should put up more than a great fight against Maul.

We're not arguing about AOTC Obi-Wan, or TPM Obi-Wan for Kit. Kit Fisto would be the Qui-Gon of the match, and Anakin would be the Kenobi.

So, I don't see how it's relevant that he's superior to TPM Obi-Wan, when he's not superior than Qui-Gon, and AOTC Anakin is at the most equal to TPM Kenobi, though, I'd argue TPM Obi-Wan > AOTC Anakin. Adding to the fact that Qui-Gon Jinn > Kit Fisto.

I’m not going to argue that Kit’s more powerful than Qui-Gon. However, he has a higher advantage over Maul than what Qui-Gon had (being younger, faster and more flexible than Qui, and having a faster and more precise sense of timing).

You're a L-I-A-R. He didn't become "slightly aggressive", and I quote from the novelization:

"He struck at the Sith Lord with his lightsaber as if his own safety meant nothing, lost in a red haze of rage and frustration, consumed by his grief for Qui-Gon and his failure to prevent his friend's fall. "

Seems "slightly aggressive" is bullshit, he didn't even care about himself, he was furiated, and was attacking wildly.

Fair enough, he used his “full anger” in the duel then. Either way, the fact that a Jedi, utilizing his anger to an advantage for the first time was capable of causing a Sith Lord, someone who is suppose take advantage of their anger all the time in a duel, to struggle goes to show something. At least IMO…

"But Darth Maul was the stronger of the two and was driven by a frenzy that surpassed even the frantic determination that fueled Obi-Wan. Eventually, the Sith Lord began to wear the young Jedi down. Bit by bit, he pressed him back, carrying the attack to him, looking to catch him off guard."

OO! Goody Goody! Maul's wild frenzy was ALMOST enough to kill a padawan! Remember, Obi-Wan was just a padawan, and yet he was able to keep up with Maul, and ultimately kill him.

Maul regained control as soon as Obi-Wan breaks his lightsaber in half.

Ooo! Yes, I see it now.

Anyways, what does Fisto being aggressive have to do with anything? Qui-Gon was aggressive, it didn't save him, now did it?

Well… considering that Obi-Wan fought better when he was “aggressive” – and Kit’s a master of a form which is said to be aggressive…

Forms now? Lol. He uses freaking Form I. Younglings know Form I. Darth Maul uses Juyo, which is highly more effective.

Everyone is taught the basics of form I. And yet, only ONE Jedi has ever mastered Form I.

"When the wall between QUI-GON and DARTH MAUL opens, QUI-GON is in a
split second fighting the DARK LORD with a ferocity not seen before."

So it wasn’t from the novel! Anyways… how’d you know that it’s in the script? Is it online somewhere?

Your point? And in the actual novel, he's described as:

"He had found a fresh reserve of strength during his meditation, and now he was attacking with a ferocity that seemed to have the Sith Lord stymied. "

That’s what I thought you meant…

Sense of timing? Lol. Didn't we already have this debate in which I handed you your ass?

I am more than happy to keep debating this if I must. Having just turned round from a 360 degree spin, with his arms up in the air with all intentions focused on delivering the final blow on Darth Sidious, how the heck was he suppose to dodge/block the move? He may have noticed the blade beforehand, but even with his super fast sense of timing, getting his hands down or moving his body to the left fast enough would have been an impossible feat. Even for Kit!

Obviously not good enough, Kit, because guess what? You're dead.

Your clippidy clip ain’t movin.

If we saw anything through your eyes, it'd probably be a Kit Fisto porno.

0_0

So, because Saesee and Agen died first, and Kit managed to clash sabers with Sidious once, he's coordinated with Mace Windu? And how did he "seem to remain coordinated fairly well". HE DIED IN THE FIRST THREE SECONDS.

😉 But within those three seconds, he was indeed coordinated with Mace! Dammit, watch the scene again. Look at how fluently Kit moves in conjunction to Mace’s attacks!!!

Dueling Sidious? I don't call clashing blades one time "dueling". It was a slaughter. And you're saying he kept up with Mace for 2 seconds? Uh, buddy, those 2 seconds were where Agen and Saesee died.

It was two times!!! Anyway, it wasn’t a coincidence that he managed to survive longer than both of them. Saesee and Agen were just idiots.

Two seconds and you say he's z0mg coordinated, and so he'll be coordinated with Anakin? This has to be a joke.

I don’t see why he wouldn’t be coordinated with Anakin. Considering Kit’s got a rather unorthodox fighting style himself, I doubt it’d be too much trouble for Kit to be able to remain coordinated with Anakin. But meh, coordination doesn’t mean everything.

What the f*ck are you talking about? They fought together for two seconds! And they didn't do a "fairly good job", as Kit Fisto didn't even move from where they started fighting.

At least he wasn’t just standing there!

Yes, there is.

1.) Kit Fisto has never worked with Anakin.
2.) Anakin is foolhardy, headstrong, and an idiot.
3.) Anakin wouldn't even listen to his own master.
4.) Anakin wasn't even coordinated with his own master.

Which could also turn out to be a good thing! Anakin may be able to dazzle Maul so much with his “not thinking before attacking” habit, that Kit’d be able to finish Maul off while he’s still in shock!

Anakin may be an idiot. He may, indeed, run headfirst into battle with Maul, without thinking. That does not mean it is impossible for Kit and he to work together. Like I said, Kit could use Anakin’s temper to an advantage. Heck, Maul struggled against an enraged Kenobi – imagine how he’d go against an enraged Anakin? Anyway, Kit has an ability here that may actually prove useful. Because Kit can sense emotion, he would be able to sense the second Anakin becomes angered, and either try and prevent him from doing anything silly, or use his anger as an advantage. What I mean by this is, while Anakin is using his anger against Maul, chances are Maul’d be slightly dazzled, and be focusing on defending himself against Anakin instead of Kit, hence giving Kit an opportunity to finish Maul off.

Now, tell me why Kit Fisto and Anakin will mesh good together? You can't? Thought so.

Read above.

Just because he lasted two seconds against Sidious (lol) doesn't mean he "coordinated" with Mace, or even that he will with Anakin.

True. But then, he doesn’t necessarily need to remain coordinated with Anakin to be able to win this duel.

You have offered no proof at all that they will be coordinated other than

"z0mg m4ce n' k1t w3re w0rk1ng t0geth3r for tw0 sec0ndz s0 an4k1n and k1t w1ll be 4n unst0ppab13 du0". You're a fanboy, there's no evidence they will mesh good together. There's actual some contrary to them meshing together.

They need not mesh together well! If they are terribly coordinated together, than Maul may be driven back by their unpredictability.

Cont.

You have no proof, Medvock, because Kit lasted two seconds with Windu, doesn't mean they were:

The winner of this fight is not only determined by how well Anakin and Kit remain “coordinated” with each other. So stop determining the outcome of the duel around this.

a.) Coordinated.

Actually, If you watch the scene, Mace and Kit were extremely well coordinated. Hell, they even attacked Sidious together, at the exact same time, almost in the exact same position!

b.) Any good.

Mace and Kit were legendary together, even before the duel. Although they never actually dueled someone together before…

c.) Will be good with Anakin.

Read last post.

Yes, he is. And again QUIT COMPARING OBI-WAN TO KIT FISTO, Kit Fisto isn't on par with Qui-Gon Jinn, and Anakin isn't on par with Obi-Wan.

Where is the proof that TPM Obi-Wan is better than AOTC Anakin? And Kit Fisto has certain advantages that may make the outcome of the duel different to that of Qui-Gon vs Maul.

Look, Kit Fisto and AOTC Anakin will never be as coordinated as Qui-Gon Jinn and Obi-Wan were in TPM. To assume they would be is ridiculous, and that is what you are doing. They worked together for twenty plus years, they fought together countless times, and neither Fisto or Anakin have ever worked together, ergo they will not be as coordinated, if they even are coordinated.

I’m over that. Anyways, throughout most of the duel, Obi-Wan and Qui-Gon weren’t even dueling together. If they WERE, Qui-Gon would have likely never died. Obi-Wan states how he was angry with himself by how he was “unable to save his friends life” -- had he been there at the time, perhaps he could have saved Qui-Gon's life.

Now, keeping that in mind:

"So they challenged the Sith Lord quickly, and just as quickly I discovered that their best efforts were not good enough to achieve an early resolution."

Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan's best efforts weren't good enough. Qui-Gon > Fisto, Obi-Wan > Anakin. And in coordinated Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan >>> Kit Fisto and Anakin, so it's only logical to assume their efforts will be just as futile.

Qui-Gon was at a major disadvantage because of his age. Kit Fisto is not at a disadvantage because he is not that old. And how’s TPM Obi-Wan better than AOTC Anakin Skywalker?

Is that the Kit Fisto "bird call"?

LOL!

Please, Medvock, you're a fanboy, and a delusional one at that. Kit Fisto isn't god, and he will be toppled by Maul. Qui-Gon Jinn was on par with TPM Windu, by the way.

I would like to see the proof that Qui-Gon was on par with Windu. I have no doubts that he was, though.

this is how the story goes.

Maul:Hey ankian ur going to turn to the darkside, so why not letme be ur b**ch and we can kill that stupid fish.
Anikan:ITS ALL OBI-WAN'S FALUT HES HOLDING ME BACk

*Kit fisto stops to play with a rock on the ground.

Maul:Listen, Ani, i love u. And your all i care about. So please why not let me be ur slave. I mean u are the strongest jedi ever.....and u will be the storngest sith ever to.

Anikan😄o u really mean that?(Starts to look deeply into mauls eyes)

Maul😮f cousre i do.
(both of them turn off there lightsabers, and then apporch each other then hug, followed by three housr of hardcore sex)

*kit fisto walks away, only to be eaten by jabba the hutt 15 mintues later*

*In the middle of the anikan maul sex. mauls dual lightsabbers come one and then they cut a whole in both of there stomcahs and they die*

Fianl verdict😄RAW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Originally posted by MEDVOCK
Precisely! How else do you describe Kenobi being able to defend himself against Maul?

You said "defend against Maul for the majority of the duel". That was bullshit, and I posted everytime Kenobi got his ass kicked.

And yet, despite his efforts, he was unable to kill a padawan.

Actually, it was due to his arrogance that he lost. He had Obi-Wan beat, this is made apparent in the script and novelization (I'm not counting the movie since a lot of people have different perspectives), and had he not stood over Obi-Wan for a good twenty seconds taunting him, he'd have killed him.

Darth Maul > Obi-Wan on paper.

“He was the best swordsman Obi-Wan had ever seen, but he was getting old.” That is ultimately the reason why Qui-Gon lost. His age had affected him during the duel. As a result, he was not as fast as his padawan was, and thus gave him quite a large disadvantage against Maul. He is very powerful though.

It seems you misunderstood what I wrote, or you're plainly an idiot. I'll go with the latter.

Explain how a superior duo was getting pwned by Maul, but Kit Fisto and Anakin, a less coordinated duo won't get owned?

Do you understand? Qui-Gon Jinn > Kit Fisto, and TPM Kenobi > AOTC Anakin. So, why will Kit Fisto and Anakin win as a duo, when a more superior duo was getting their asses handed to them?

Kit Fisto does not suffer from old age. Actually, his age is unknown, but considering ROTS is only a few years after AOTC, in which he seemed fairly young, he’s still as fast as he ever was. And Kit Fisto is fast! Not to mention, his flexibility obviously surpasses both Maul’s and Qui-Gon’s. My point here is, Kit is faster and more flexible than Qui-Gon. And considering it is ultimately Maul's speed and youth that gave him the upper hand against Qui-Gon, Kit, being fast himself, should put up more than a great fight against Maul.

Actually, it was Maul's

"The Sith Lord he battled with Obi - Wan was more than his equal in weapons training, and he had the advantage of being younger and stronger."

It was Maul being Qui-Gon's superior in lightsaber combat, and being stronger than Qui-Gon himself. Maul is physically stronger than Kit Fisto.

I’m not going to argue that Kit’s more powerful than Qui-Gon. However, he has a higher advantage over Maul than what Qui-Gon had (being younger, faster and more flexible than Qui, and having a faster and more precise sense of timing).

That made no sense. Qui-Gon's more powerful, but Kit Fisto will beat him!

Fair enough, he used his “full anger” in the duel then. Either way, the fact that a Jedi, utilizing his anger to an advantage for the first time was capable of causing a Sith Lord, someone who is suppose take advantage of their anger all the time in a duel, to struggle goes to show something.

Actually, it doesn't show a thing. It shows that Maul didn't expect Kenobi to attack like a wild dog.

At least IMO…

And in your opinion, Kit Fisto would beat Yoda, Vader, Sidious, Inuyasha, Goku, Superman, and so on. So, your opinion is pretty much shit because you're such a fanboy.

OO! Goody Goody! Maul's wild frenzy was ALMOST enough to kill a padawan! Remember, Obi-Wan was just a padawan, and yet he was able to keep up with Maul, and ultimately kill him.

Again, I'll just say: Actually, it was due to his arrogance that he lost. He had Obi-Wan beat, this is made apparent in the script and novelization (I'm not counting the movie since a lot of people have different perspectives), and had he not stood over Obi-Wan for a good twenty seconds taunting him, he'd have killed him.

Darth Maul > Obi-Wan on paper.

Well… considering that Obi-Wan fought better when he was “aggressive” – and Kit’s a master of a form which is said to be aggressive…

You're an idiot. Form I is not aggressive. F*cking Jedi Younglings use it. Juyo is more aggressive than Form I. Obi-Wan's form in TPM, Ataru, is more aggressive than Form I.

And Obi-Wan only fought better because he was attacking like a lunatic that just escaped from your basement (and I can't blame him, I would go crazy, too). When Qui-Gon tried to do that, he ended up like so:

Subtitles: "Pwned".

I highly doubt Kit Fisto is going to give into his anger, and attack in complete and utter rage. He'll do what Qui-Gon did, which was attacking very aggressively, and dying.

Everyone is taught the basics of form I. And yet, only ONE Jedi has ever mastered Form I.

Yeah, because Form I is a basic form. It's not demanding, it's not advanced, it sucks. Which is why Kit Fisto mastered it, because he, like the form, sucks. "The basics of attack, parry, body target zones, and the practice drills called velocities are all here."

Form I is the basic form, it's not special . . . unlike Juyo, which is the most demanding of all forms.

So it wasn’t from the novel!

I never said it was, you idiot. Here's where I first mentioned it:

Originally posted by Advent
Second, in the actual script and novelization "QUI-GON is in a split second fighting the DARK LORD with a ferocity not seen before.", and the novel confirms it.

Do your spectacles need an examining? You'd better put them on, that's probably why you're wrong 10 out of 9 times (impossible, but you manage to do it anyways). I said the actual script says it, and the novel confirms it, I never said the novel exactly said that line.

Anyways… how’d you know that it’s in the script? Is it online somewhere?

google.com

^

Google it, perhaps? IMSDB.

That’s what I thought you meant…

If you'd have read what I wrote, or got your spectacles fixed - you wouldn't have that problem.

I am more than happy to keep debating this if I must. Having just turned round from a 360 degree spin, with his arms up in the air with all intentions focused on delivering the final blow on Darth Sidious, how the heck was he suppose to dodge/block the move?

Because he's supposed to be a "motion blur", and have a "sense of timing faster than some bullshit x". If his sense of timing is so great, he would've timed that shit, and not have died. Your hyperbolic descriptions (and yes, they are hyperbole) don't make sense.

He may have noticed the blade beforehand, but even with his super fast sense of timing, getting his hands down or moving his body to the left fast enough would have been an impossible feat. Even for Kit!

Oh? If he has a sense of timing that good, he would be able to do it. If it is a "motion blur", he would be able to do it.

Sadly, since these are all hyperbolic descriptions they are inadmissable.

Your clippidy clip ain’t movin.

Or maybe you just don't want it to move because Kit Fisto dies? It's working perfectly on my computer. Turn off your Anti-Fisto Firewall, it's protecting you from seeing anything against Kit.

But within those three seconds, he was indeed coordinated with Mace! Dammit, watch the scene again. Look at how fluently Kit moves in conjunction to Mace’s attacks!!!

Fluently? He moved as fluently as Roblio Darte, Master Tsui, and others did. Which, in actuality, was shit. Two seconds, and he moved "fluently"? No, all he did was clash sabers once, and die.

It was two times!!! Anyway, it wasn’t a coincidence that he managed to survive longer than both of them. Saesee and Agen were just idiots.

You're right, it wasn't coincidence. It was a filler, and luck. Luck that Sidious went after Agen and Saesee first.

I don’t see why he wouldn’t be coordinated with Anakin.

Because there's no proof? Because they never worked together? Because Anakin's a foolhardy idiot? Because Kit Fisto is unorthodox, and Anakin doesn't know anything about him?

Considering Kit’s got a rather unorthodox fighting style himself, I doubt it’d be too much trouble for Kit to be able to remain coordinated with Anakin. But meh, coordination doesn’t mean everything.

That didn't make sense. Because Kit's got an unorthodox fighting style, he'd be coordinated with Anakin? Wow, you really are daft.

What the f*ck are you talking about? They fought together for two seconds! And they didn't do a "fairly good job", as Kit Fisto didn't even move from where they started fighting.

Which could also turn out to be a good thing! Anakin may be able to dazzle Maul so much with his “not thinking before attacking” habit, that Kit’d be able to finish Maul off while he’s still in shock!

What the f*ck are you talking about? And why would he be able to "dazzle Maul"? That was the stupidiest thing I've heard all day. "In shock"? The only one that will be "in shock" is Kit Fisto when he gets killed for a second time.

Anakin may be an idiot. He may, indeed, run headfirst into battle with Maul, without thinking. That does not mean it is impossible for Kit and he to work together. Like I said, Kit could use Anakin’s temper to an advantage.

You don't make sense. There's nothing, absolutely zilch to suggest they can work well together, so stop treating it like they will be.

The winner of this fight is not only determined by how well Anakin and Kit remain “coordinated” with each other. So stop determining the outcome of the duel around this.

Coordination, and how well a team meshes together is a HUMONGOUS point you have to deal with. I'm serious, if you knew a damn thing about swordfighting - you'd know that. It can change a lose to a win, and often does if the team is good enough.

Sadly, Kit Fisto and Anakin aren't.

Mace and Kit were legendary together, even before the duel. Although they never actually dueled someone together before…

WTF FANBOY

You are truly the epitome of a fanboy. Holy shit. They are legendary together, but they never even dueled together? ROFL.

I’m over that. Anyways, throughout most of the duel, Obi-Wan and Qui-Gon weren’t even dueling together. If they WERE, Qui-Gon would have likely never died.

*Yawn* More bullshit, Medvock? Should I really be surprised at this point? As a team, there's efforts were futile:

"His agility and dexterity allowed him to keep them both at bay, constantly attacking while at the same time effectively blunting their counterattacks"

"So they challenged the Sith Lord quickly, and just as quickly I discovered that their best efforts were not good enough to achieve an early resolution."

"their efforts at attack, at assuming the offensive against this dangerous adversary, were woefully inadequate. "

Hm, their best attacks were not good enough, Maul was able to counterattack and attack at the same time while holding them off, and their offensive was "woefully (deplorably, or "horribly"😉 inadequate (meaning ineffective)", but Qui-Gon would've lived? Hell no, he would've been killed had they continued working as a team, so would Obi-Wan. As a team, they got pwned by the following attacks:

- Blocked Kenobi's attack while not even looking.
- Jump kicked Qui-Gon while defending against Obi-Wan.
- Kicked Kenobi and knocked him back ten feet (so much he had to run to catch up).
- Pushed Qui-Gon away with just sheer Force.
- Did the same to Kenobi.
- Spin kicked Kenobi and he fell down to a completely different platform.

Edited for maximum effect:

Originally posted by jollyjim311
Maul.

Maul was able to almost overwhelm Sidious, who, if I remember correctly, punked Fisto in about three seconds. The only reason Kit lasted that long was because Sidious was killing two other Jedi.

Also, Maul has a definite terrain advantage. Being Maul, he won't get tired... Maul>Fatigue.
Kit, however, while he seemed to do okay on Geonisis, is still a fish-man. After the constant beating Maul will give him, he'll get tired (like Qui Gon was on Tattoine, after about, what? 20 seconds of dueling?), and dry out possibly. Qui Gon was described as the best duelist Obi Wan had ever seen and, also, on par with Mace Windu. Still, Maul showed him a thrashing. Kit is not as good as him.
Also, Maul is great at fighting multiple targets, as seen in TPM, those four comics, and possibly Shadow Hunter (I haven't read it yet, I'm not sure I will). Also, Kit Fisto and Anakin have no previous track record, and it is very likely that they couldn't coordinate their attacks at all, nevermind as well as Obi Wan and Qui Gon. Without coordination, and with Kit's "Spin around like a fairy with his unlimited vertabrate!!111!!!1!!" style, he will probably get in Anakin's way more than anything.

A few last things:
Qui Gon> Kit.
Obi Wan is about equal to Anakin, I mean, Obi Wan was just days away from being a Knight during him TPM days, and a darn good Knight, too.
Obi Wan and Qui Gon's synergy >>> Kit and Anakins' synergy.

Okay, my initial point pretty much sums it up. Sama, your arguments are great, they can only be refuted by him, due to his love for a fish.

Sorgo and I had a debate like this a long time ago with Medvock about how Kit would get his ass handed to him in a fist fight on Tattoine. He won't give up. In his eyes: Kit>>> facts and/or common sense.

herbwank <- Medvock.

Actually, it was due to his arrogance that he lost. He had Obi-Wan beat, this is made apparent in the script and novelization (I'm not counting the movie since a lot of people have different perspectives), and had he not stood over Obi-Wan for a good twenty seconds taunting him, he'd have killed him.

Possibilities, possibilities. You know, had Kit completed that spin of his, and had Sidious still been in his saber lock with Mace, Kit would’ve killed Sidious! But that never happened, nor did Maul ever kill Kenobi.

Explain how a superior duo was getting pwned by Maul, but Kit Fisto and Anakin, a less coordinated duo won't get owned?
Do you understand? Qui-Gon Jinn > Kit Fisto, and TPM Kenobi > AOTC Anakin. So, why will Kit Fisto and Anakin win as a duo, when a more superior duo was getting their asses handed to them?

Because, as I stated, what possibly cost Qui-Gon his life was his age. Had he been faster and younger, he may have just been able to beat Maul. And Obi-Wan seemed to do fairly well against Maul, so if Anakin and Kit can work together, even for just a short amount of time, the two should come out victorious. But as I said earlier, I can see this duel turning out either way.

"The Sith Lord he battled with Obi - Wan was more than his equal in weapons training, and he had the advantage of being younger and stronger."

It also states, “Qui-Gon was nearing sixty; his youth was behind him and his strength was beginning to diminish”. Thus, perhaps if Qui-Gon was not held back by his old age, maybe he would have defeated Maul?

Notice that Maul was said to “have the advantage of being younger and stronger"

It was Maul being Qui-Gon's superior in lightsaber combat, and being stronger than Qui-Gon himself. Maul is physically stronger than Kit Fisto.

As stated above, Maul was stronger than Qui-Gon because he was younger; because of Qui-Gon’s old age, his strength was beginning to diminish. Now, Maul may be somewhat physically stronger than Kit, but not so much that Kit’d be at a major disadvantage.

That made no sense. Qui-Gon's more powerful, but Kit Fisto will beat him!

Kit Fisto is faster, younger, and has a faster sense of timing than Qui-Gon. Not only this, but his fighting style has awed Jedi Masters of the highest esteem (Obi and Mace). Might I also add the fact that Qui-Gon states in TPM that, although his apprentice was not yet as powerful as he was, he believed that someday he would surpass him. Add the fact that Kit surpassed Obi-Wan, and we have reason to assume that Kit should put up a great fight against Maul.

Actually, it doesn't show a thing. It shows that Maul didn't expect Kenobi to attack like a wild dog.

Even after this “anger driven assault”, it states that Obi-Wan and Maul were fighting somewhat evenly. Even as Maul finally regained the offensive, it mentions Obi being able to elude his antogonist’s efforts due to his speed.

And in your opinion, Kit Fisto would beat Yoda, Vader, Sidious, Inuyasha, Goku, Superman, and so on. So, your opinion is pretty much shit because you're such a fanboy.

Did you know, that apparently, Kit Fisto’s master during apprenticeship was Yoda?

Again, I'll just say: Actually, it was due to his arrogance that he lost. He had Obi-Wan beat, this is made apparent in the script and novelization (I'm not counting the movie since a lot of people have different perspectives), and had he not stood over Obi-Wan for a good twenty seconds taunting him, he'd have killed him.

And yet, Obi-Wan managed to defend himself throughout the majority of the duel to be able to finally make that comeback and slice Maul in two. Anyway, Maul’s arrogance could be all the more reason why he may lose this duel too.

Darth Maul > Obi-Wan on paper.

You're an idiot. Form I is not aggressive. F*cking Jedi Younglings use it. Juyo is more aggressive than Form I. Obi-Wan's form in TPM, Ataru, is more aggressive than Form I.

Well, in CD it states that Kit Fisto’s form was fierce, deadly, aggressive etc. However, because Kit’s fighting style was described to be so “unpredictable and irresistible” and unorthodox, it is reasonable to assume that Kit may have added his own unique saber style into his fighting form.

And Obi-Wan only fought better because he was attacking like a lunatic that just escaped from your basement (and I can't blame him, I would go crazy, too). When Qui-Gon tried to do that, he ended up like so:

Might I also point out that Qui-Gon was a master of Ataru. Ataru practitioners are at a great disadvantage if fighting in a small area. In TPM, Qui-Gon was killed by Darth Maul in a confined space. This could also contribute to the reason as to why Qui-Gon was defeated. And Qui-Gon was almost able to defeat Maul – in the book, it mentions how Maul was beginning to become worried by Qui-Gon’s ferocious assault, and that he had to resort to jumping away from him in order regain an advantage.

Subtitles: "Pwned".

I highly doubt Kit Fisto is going to give into his anger, and attack in complete and utter rage. He'll do what Qui-Gon did, which was attacking very aggressively, and dying.

Luckily, Form I’s simplicity is it’s strength. Kit should not need to go on an anger driven rage since his form is already about using strength anyway. Not to mention it also being described as aggressive, deadly, etc.

Yeah, because Form I is a basic form. It's not demanding, it's not advanced, it sucks. Which is why Kit Fisto mastered it, because he, like the form, sucks. "The basics of attack, parry, body target zones, and the practice drills called velocities are all here."

“It’s simplicity is its strength”. Form I may be the basic form, but it is a form that specializes against numerous different styles, due to its simplicity. Anyway, as stated above, It is likely, given how Kit’s fighting style was described in Cestus Deception, that Kit would have incorporated his own personalized fighting style into Shii-Cho.

Form I is the basic form, it's not special . . . unlike Juyo, which is the most demanding of all forms.

I find it special, considering that Kit has awed some of the highest level of Jedi Master’s with it.

I never said it was, you idiot. Here's where I first mentioned it:
quote: (post)

Originally posted by Advent
Second, in the actual script and novelization "QUI-GON is in a split second fighting the DARK LORD with a ferocity not seen before.", and the novel confirms it.

Do your spectacles need an examining? You'd better put them on, that's probably why you're wrong 10 out of 9 times (impossible, but you manage to do it anyways). I said the actual script says it, and the novel confirms it, I never said the novel exactly said that line.

Calm down. I was just a little dazzled with how you could gain access to the script. That’s all.

google.com

^

Google it, perhaps? IMSDB.

Okay, thank you. I will look for the script straight away.

If you'd have read what I wrote, or got your spectacles fixed - you wouldn't have that problem.

I did read what you wrote I just didn’t think it was possible to gain access to TPM script, that’s all. But now I know. Cheers.

Because he's supposed to be a "motion blur", and have a "sense of timing faster than some bullshit x". If his sense of timing is so great, he would've timed that shit, and not have died. Your hyperbolic descriptions (and yes, they are hyperbole) don't make sense.

Unfortunately, no matter what, what is stated in Cestus Deception remains fact. Darth Maul was killed by a padawan, does that mean that he sucks? Likewise, Kit Fisto was killed by a SITH LORD, does that mean he sucks? Anyway, watch the scene again, and look at how fast Kit manages to move himself from the left of the screen to the right. I still can’t believe it with my own eyes!

Oh? If he has a sense of timing that good, he would be able to do it. If it is a "motion blur", he would be able to do it.

It states this in Cestus Deception, and in no way is their any reason to assume it is hyperbole. I find it ironic how you seem to be basing all of Kit’s abilities with how he managed to do against Darth Sidious.

Sadly, since these are all hyperbolic descriptions they are inadmissable.

Unfortunately for you, for however long they remain in Cestus Deception, these statements are fact. You won’t be able to convince me that they’re “hyperbole”.

Or maybe you just don't want it to move because Kit Fisto dies? It's working perfectly on my computer. Turn off your Anti-Fisto Firewall, it's protecting you from seeing anything against Kit.

Just a question; did you get that pic from the Maul vs Fisto thread? God I miss that thread!

Fluently? He moved as fluently as Roblio Darte, Master Tsui, and others did. Which, in actuality, was shit. Two seconds, and he moved "fluently"? No, all he did was clash sabers once, and die.

It was twice. Anyway, if you bother to watch the scene again, and manage not to keep your eyes closed, no matter how much you deny it, you will see what I mean.

You're right, it wasn't coincidence. It was a filler, and luck. Luck that Sidious went after Agen and Saesee first.

Is It luck that the script called for Kit to last longer than Agen and Saesee? Kit was meant to last longer than the other two, and that’s a fact.

Because there's no proof? Because they never worked together? Because Anakin's a foolhardy idiot? Because Kit Fisto is unorthodox, and Anakin doesn't know anything about him?

Also note in TPM, it states that Obi-Wan was at a major disadvantage because he had only fought in a few battles in his life and was not “battle hardened”. Assuming this Anakin is the one that has fought Dooku, at least he’d be able to understand what the Sith are capable of and think before he leaps.

Anyway, while you have numerous good points up there, coordination does NOT mean everything. As I stated somewhere, Kit could use this to his advantage.

If Anakin did try any funny business, and did leave himself open, Kit could use this to his advantage so that when Maul is attacking Anakin, Kit could attack Maul -- similarly to how Qui-Gon attacked Maul when Obi-Wan was kicked away.

You don't make sense. There's nothing, absolutely zilch to suggest they can work well together, so stop treating it like they will be.

And there is no evidence that Kit and Anakin will fail together! Sure, they may have never been in a battle together before, but these are Jedi for goodness sake! They know what they’re doing!

Anakin ran headfirst to Dooku because he was angry with what Dooku had done to the Jedi. There is no reason to suggest that Anakin will be angry like he was with Dooku because Maul has done nothing to upset him. Therefore, if Anakin is not driven by his anger, perhaps he would be able to work well with Kit.

Add the fact that both Anakin and Kit are fast, fairly young, and powerful, and I think the two will do very well together.

Coordination, and how well a team meshes together is a HUMONGOUS point you have to deal with. I'm serious, if you knew a damn thing about swordfighting - you'd know that. It can change a lose to a win, and often does if the team is good enough.

Sadly, Kit Fisto and Anakin aren't.

There is no reason to suggest that Anakin and Kit will fail at remaining coordinated!!! Kit Fisto’s experiences have taught him many ways with dealing with different situations. Trying to remain coordinated with Anakin will be a minor feat compared to what he’s done in the past.

WTF FANBOY

You are truly the epitome of a fanboy. Holy shit. They are legendary together, but they never even dueled together? ROFL.

They’ve fought enemies together. This is possibly the reason why Mace not only chose Kit as one of four Jedi leaders in the Battle of Geonosis, but also chose him to aid him in arresting Supreme Chancellor Palpatine.

*Yawn* More bullshit, Medvock? Should I really be surprised at this point? As a team, there's efforts were futile:

"His agility and dexterity allowed him to keep them both at bay, constantly attacking while at the same time effectively blunting their counterattacks"

"So they challenged the Sith Lord quickly, and just as quickly I discovered that their best efforts were not good enough to achieve an early resolution."

"their efforts at attack, at assuming the offensive against this dangerous adversary, were woefully inadequate. "

I’m only going to reply to this with the following facts:

- Qui-Gon was 60 and became weary often in the battle
- Obi-Wan was a Padawan who had been in few battles (according to the book!), has never fought a Sith and yet managed to Kill Maul.
- What Maul showed us in that duel was his best efforts, yet he was still unable to KILL A PADAWAN

One on one, Qui-Gon was actually doing very good against Maul -- however, it was his old age that led to his downfall. He became weary, his face had become "bathed with sweat and taut with fatigue" -- he could not continue fighting the Sith Lord for long which is thusly why he failed. Add the fact that, as I mentioned earlier, Qui-Gon's form puts him at a major disadvantage when fighting in a small area. HAD Obi-Wan been there at the time though, Qui-Gon would have likely survived.

Because Kit is fairly young, fast, flexible, strong and has a fast sense of timing, he should be able to last long enough against Maul for the duo to finish him off. Anakin is confident (evident as he runs headfirst into battle), powerful and fast too -- the novel mentions Obi-Wan beginning to lose his edge because he was losing his confidence.

Imagine two Kenobi's attacking Maul at the same time. What I mean here is, imagine two people who are both young, fast, and strong attacking Maul instead of one person who is old and one who is fast. Kit and Anakin are very much alike (besides from Anni being an idiot at times) so who's to say they won't fight well together?

This is a good thread. TPM Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan > AOTC Anakin and ROTS Kit and Maul was practically even with that duo so I'm tempted to say he could take this.

Okay, no one make any really long posts, (I'm not sure how long this'll be, but sorry if it is) because reading through all Medvock's BS really pains me.
Stuff like this:
Qui Gon was beat due to a confined space: Maul needs a lot of space too, just look at how he fights. He uses a double lightsaber.
Qui Gon is less effective than Fisto due to his age: Windu was about his age, right? How old is Yoda? Dooku? Sidious? I mean, even DN Luke has to be getting near 60. You can use the Force to make you stronger or faster, got it?
Mace and Obi were surprised that Kit didn't suck up a storm because he uses form I: Cool. He doesn't suck.
Coordination doesn't mean anything when they're both young: Okay. Wait... let me check... you're wrong.
Anakin wouldn't run in like a madman and be owned, because he has nothing personal against Maul: Yeah, he killed Qui Gon, the one who saved him from slavery, was going to train him to be a Jedi, even against the councils will, because he believed in him. Anakin would rush in.
Mentions nothing about Maul: Okay, I will, he was trained to be a weapon to kill Jedi by Sidious, nothing else. Oh yeah, http://www.swtimeline.ru/?comics=232&page=06 , http://www.swtimeline.ru/?comics=232&page=07 , http://www.swtimeline.ru/?comics=232&page=08 , http://www.swtimeline.ru/?comics=232&page=09 , I would post more, but the other three comics aren't on the site.
Mentioning nothing about the environment: They are fighting on Tattooine. Qui Gon was tired after fighting Maul for maybe 30 seconds on Tattooine. I doubt a fish man would do any better.

Guys, you should give Medvock a break. So what if you don't agree with him, this is an internet forum and so what if he's a fanboy, pretty much everyone is a fanboy of someone and it's not like he's been making rediculous claims, so try and keep it civil.

Anyways imo, all you have to do is read CD to know that Kit would take Maul.

Anyways imo, all you have to do is read CD to know that Kit would take Maul.

Yeah, Sith'ari, I'm sure reading stuff like "Kit's a martial hurricane", a "blur of motion", and other hyperbole will do any good. I've read about half, maybe 2/3 of Cestus Deception, Kit Fisto will not win.

Read any of the Maul comics, or Shadow Hunter, or, judge purely by the movies, and then tell me who will win.

Anyways imo, all you have to do is read CD to know that Kit would take Maul.

I agree.

Of course you agree, Medvock. To you, it's like your version of Hustler. Why don't you read Shadow Hunter? Saboteur? The Darth Maul comics? Just watch The Phantom Menace? Just read the TPM novel? I've read 2/3 of the Cestus Deception, it's filled with hyperbole, and quite frankly - it's unimpressive, doesn't show his superiority at all.

Maul > Kit Fisto. Nothing you're deluded fanboy perspective can do to change that. I mean, Sorgo and I completely trampled over you in the fist fight thread, but you kept on saying "l0l k1t w1ll w1n cuz h3 h4s un[]_1mit3d v3rt4bra3!!!!///!!ONE!!!".

"If you’ve got $5, and you don’t know what to do with it, instead of buying something useless, BUY KIT FISTO! You won't regret it."

ROFL! Good advertising, Meddie-boy.

Originally posted by Advent
Of course you agree, Medvock. To you, it's like your version of Hustler. Why don't you read Shadow Hunter? Saboteur? The Darth Maul comics? Just watch The Phantom Menace? Just read the TPM novel? I've read 2/3 of the Cestus Deception, it's filled with hyperbole, and quite frankly - it's unimpressive, doesn't show his superiority at all.

Maul > Kit Fisto. Nothing you're deluded fanboy perspective can do to change that. I mean, Sorgo and I completely trampled over you in the fist fight thread, but you kept on saying "l0l k1t w1ll w1n cuz h3 h4s un[]_1mit3d v3rt4bra3!!!!///!!ONE!!!".

"If you’ve got $5, and you don’t know what to do with it, instead of buying something useless, BUY KIT FISTO! You won't regret it."

ROFL! Good advertising, Meddie-boy.

Unfortunately, I haven't read Shadow Hunter or Saboteur, but I've read a few of the Maul comics. I've also seen TPM. Lovely movie. Oh, and as made evident throughout this "debate", I've also read TPM novel.

And quite frankly, I highly doubt you've read Cestus Deception. Why the hell would you buy the book if you aren't going to read it?

Even people on here who don't show any signs of being a big Fisto Fan admit that he was awesome in the novel.

Read it -- it's not only about Kit, but it does feature him a fair bit.

Originally posted by MEDVOCK
And quite frankly, I highly doubt you've read Cestus Deception.

You "highly doubt" I've read the Cestus Deception? You also "highly doubted" Maul could beat Fisto in a fist fight, but you couldn't have been more wrong, and got your arguments destroyed. So, what's your point? Do you want me to write out an entire chapter for you. . .?

Why the hell would you buy the book if you aren't going to read it?

Obviously you're a dumbass. When did I ever say I wasn't going to read it? I even said exactly that "I read 2/3 of it", damn Medvock, you're a freaking idiot.

Even people on here who don't show any signs of being a big Fisto Fan admit that he was awesome in the novel.

"People"? These so called "people" are only one person, who would be Nebaris. Your point?

Read it -- it's not only about Kit, but it does feature him a fair bit.

Didn't I just say "I read 2/3 of it". . .? Damn, Medvock, get back on your medication. You're delusional.