Reasons why Tia = Bad News! Supporting evidence from LovelyOne and Myself

Originally posted by ESB -1138
[B]1. Who is to say she actually brought back Barbossa? No one knows is she did or not. And she might need the body for all we know and Barbossa is the only one who can get to the World's End to save Jack.

It doesnt take an idiot to notice that she had the dead body of Barbossa and towards the end he is alive. WHY would it be anyone else who brings him back? there were no other magical charaters brought into the movie so its OBVIOUSLY Tia who brought him back from the dead..she IS a voodoo lady..

2. If she didn't like Jack she wouldn't have told them how to bring him back and tell them the only person who could and "brought back" the only person who could to save Jack.

3. A lot of girls slapped the crap out of Jack. She did say Jack has been gone for a long time; he might have left her like all the rest like that. Women get pissed off.

4. Black Ring had nothing to do with the bad things happening. If you haven't noticed nothing bad happened to Jack until the Black Spot returned on his hand.

5. You have nothing to back up your claim. That was the only time Tia actually said anything to Will; the rest of the time she was talking to Jack or the group as a whole.

6. Liz really wants Jack to the point she leaves him handcuffed to the Pearl. If you haven't noticed she didn't need to do that. Jack had already escaped the Pearl and the Kraken did not go after him; instead it continued to attack the ship. Sounds more like Liz wanted to protect herself and Will from certain death.

Liz wanted Jack so much that she was AFRAID of it towards the end. Thats why she did that to him. It wasn't to really save Will and herself from Davy/Kraken. It was to get rid of the temptation of Jack before it gets too much for her. So by doing that to Jack she forces herself to stick with Will...even if its not what her heart really wants.

It obviously wasn't to really keep will safe from Davy because she then agrees only hours later to go in search of Jack again..which would mean bringing Davy after her and Will again. Obviously the fact the Kraken/Davy was after them wasnt her reason for chaining Jack up.

GOSH. why doesnt everyone just agree that JACK WANTS LIZ and LIZ WANTS JACK and basically thats how it goes. LOL. 😉

Originally posted by katelovespirate
GOSH. why doesnt everyone just agree that JACK WANTS LIZ and LIZ WANTS JACK and basically thats how it goes. LOL. 😉

I agree!✅

holy crap lovelyone you did it it AGAIN!

i read all those things against mine and i was like 'what? that doesnt even make sense!' and i was gunna comment on all of them, then i went to the next page and whats the first post? you doing it! haha. dang, get it.

how exciting! me, lovelyone, and katelovespirate are all on at the same time. haha. just thought i'd point it out! 🙂

Originally posted by jdl1224
holy crap lovelyone you did it it AGAIN!

i read all those things against mine and i was like 'what? that doesnt even make sense!' and i was gunna comment on all of them, then i went to the next page and whats the first post? you doing it! haha. dang, get it.

how exciting! me, lovelyone, and katelovespirate are all on at the same time. haha. just thought i'd point it out! 🙂

LOL believe me! you make much more sense then that guy with your theories.. 😮‍💨 I always confront him with a reply and he never responds to me...hope he does this time..

and yes its cool to all be online..I miss lovethemtigers, blackpearl44, Sweetkat and vegaofthelyre...I wonder what has become of those 4 😕

Originally posted by LovelyOne
and yes its cool to all be online..I miss lovethemtigers, blackpearl44, Sweetkat and vegaofthelyre...I wonder what has become of those 4 😕

aw i dont know who they are! did they make good theories? because if they do... they should definatley come back! 🙂

Yeh they make very good theories 🙂

i think i just saw that lovethemtigers was on! how exciting!

AWE!!!! its like the posse... gosh i love you guys. 🙂 i am so stupid today. i cant think of any good theories. LOL.

LOL im sleepy ^^ I'm in stupid mode too 😄

our posse is AWSOME 😄

Yeah it is... we are the best. tee-heee. 🙂 the non fan girls obsessing over how hott Jack and Liz are.... YAY! 🙂 😆

haha! yall are so cool!! internet is so awesome. lovely is in the UK im in the US and... katelovespirate is in... her dreams? haha.

Okay, so im having a thought here.

Why did the Isle de Muerta go all pear-shaped, and why was it reclaimed by the sea?
WHo is the sea? Either Davy or Tia, right? WHY did they reclaim the island?
And perhaps this means Davy and Tia were in league about Barbossa... ??? Perhaps Davy brought him to Tia to resurrect.

hahaha i dont know what im talking about

I'm just confused at the moment...I dont remember the Isle de muerta thingy being swallowed by the sea?? 😕 😂

Sorry guys i have to agree with katelovespirates. Why if she was working with the EITC would she give the jar of dirt to Jack to help protect him.

Originally posted by sccch
I agree!✅

I'm with you two on that. 😄

Originally posted by tia dalma
Sorry guys i have to agree with katelovespirates. Why if she was working with the EITC would she give the jar of dirt to Jack to help protect him.

the jar didn't protect him. it made things worse for him.

Originally posted by tia dalma
Sorry guys i have to agree with katelovespirates. Why if she was working with the EITC would she give the jar of dirt to Jack to help protect him.

Because she knew that it wouldn't REALLY help him..how is a jar of dirt going to stop Davy or his men getting to Jack? It obviously wasn't a big threat to Davy..he just looked at it as if to say "WTF is that all about Jack?"

If it wasn't for that blasted jar of dirt then in no way would the EITC gain the heart at the end. Its obvious that the Jar of dirt wouldn't really help Jack..Tia knows that jack will cling onto a material possesion if he thinks it will keep him safe, she knows that he will cling onto it as if it was his first born son..so she knows that he will think it safest to put the heart in there..when it really isnt safe to put it in there..and we find out why in the end when Norrington takes it. That the Jar of dirt was no help at all..Actually it caused Jack more pain than help..he even fell down the stairs because he held it..I think the audience seriously overlook that falling down the stairs thing..They will be thinking "oh stupid drunken Jack" but why add such a random and meanigless moment into a movie? Answer..its not random and meaningless...there is something fishy about that Jar...

😂

^^^what she said.
i just wasnt in the mood to explain lol.