Mr. Majestic vs Beta Ray Bill

Started by Soleran5 pages

Yes but I will never forget the speedblitzing mail room Superman! Blatant criminal of the US postal service!

Ive never believed BRB is more powerful than Thor. The simple thing is he holds back less. He fights more all out. Thor usually dosnt and its been stated several times on panel. Thor during the blood and thunder saga was Thor bot holding back. Just reg ol' Thor not holding back beat Surfer, then BRB then the infinity watch. He only got the power gem after he had beaten the infinity watch. Thats what Thor can do when he fights all out.

Originally posted by Validus
Probably because it didn't take place in the same time period. Doesn't change whether it's canon or not.

Actually it was both in 2004, and before Ragnarok Thor was King of earth and 100 years in the MU future. Thor had been king Thor since 99 or 2000?

Originally posted by Soujaboy
Actually it was both in 2004, and before Ragnarok Thor was King of earth and 100 years in the MU future. Thor had been king Thor since 99 or 2000?

I would say based on the lineup of both teams and Kurt Busiek's comments it took place in 1997-1998. Not to mention time was changing within the story hence the appearances of Electric Superman, Barry Allen, etc.

Originally posted by Validus
I would say based on the lineup of both teams and Kurt Busiek's comments it took place in 1997-1998. Not to mention time was changing within the story hence the appearances of Electric Superman, Barry Allen, etc.

In 98 The war with Surtur was going on, and the death of Odin occurred. Makes no since for that comics to be cannon.

yea it's kind of gay that that is considerded cannon, I mean so many much weaker characters that Thor take ass whoopings from Superman and they aren't knocked out in one and and these people are far less durable too. Wonder Woman comes to minds. Thats PIS for ya 🙁

Originally posted by Soujaboy
In 98 The war with Surtur was going on, and the death of Odin occurred. Makes no since for that comics to be cannon.

Considering the theme of the story was time travel and fluctuations it does make sense.

We can argue all day but it IS canon, like it or not. Face it, Marvel sold out Thor to Superman. 😛

Originally posted by Validus
Considering the theme of the story was time travel and fluctuations it does make sense.

We can argue all day but it IS canon, like it or not. Face it, Marvel sold out Thor to Superman. 😛

PIS

Originally posted by Validus
Considering the theme of the story was time travel and fluctuations it does make sense.

We can argue all day but it IS canon, like it or not. Face it, Marvel sold out Thor to Superman. 😛


That being the only way Supes could beat him 😄 I was sadly dissapointed by that 🙁 . Not so much that Thor was beaten that happens to all characters sooner or later, but its the way it happened and the fact that he was whored out to a non marvel character 😠

Originally posted by Soujaboy
PIS

The whole story isn't PIS just because you didn't like it.

Originally posted by Validus
The whole story isn't PIS just because you didn't like it.

😐

No the story was just filled with PIS filled moments.

In the Ultron unlimited series, Thor was almost killed by Ultron, and in the Superman/ F4 crossover Superman was hit by a laser that could cut Adamantium, and was COMPLETELY unphased, and the same robot (Ultron) that almost killed Thor was made out of Adamantium, and boasted that if he wanted he could "sear the flesh from Thor's Bones", and yet Superman took a laser to the chest that could have cut Ultron in half. What does that say about Thor?

Everyone says that Thor is more powerful than superman, but in terms of raw strength, invulnerability, and speed, Thor is lacking compared to Superman.

Thor has never lifted a planet, superman has.

Thor has never reacted at lightspeed, superman has.

Thor has never taken an Adamantium cutting laser to the chest of flown through the sun and survived unscathed, Superman has.

So withall of this said, isn't it a stupid fanboy notion to try to hang on to the false unfounded notion that "Thor is stronger than Superman". Like it or not, the comics don't lie, the truth is Thor has been bested by Superman in every crossover, his hammer has been caught by Superman, he's been K.O.ed with one punch by Superman, and still people say "Its just a crossover" well what the heck else do you want, it's going to be a crossover either way you slice it, its two characters from different universes duking it out and in this case, Superman wins, not by strength or speed or invulnerability, but simply because he is superior the superior character.

Originally posted by Sirius77
In the Ultron unlimited series, Thor was almost killed by Ultron, and in the Superman/ F4 crossover Superman was hit by a laser that could cut Adamantium, and was COMPLETELY unphased, and the same robot (Ultron) that almost killed Thor was made out of Adamantium, and boasted that if he wanted he could "sear the flesh from Thor's Bones", and yet Superman took a laser to the chest that could have cut Ultron in half. What does that say about Thor?

Everyone says that Thor is more powerful than superman, but in terms of raw strength, invulnerability, and speed, Thor is lacking compared to Superman.

Thor has never lifted a planet, superman has.

Thor has never reacted at lightspeed, superman has.

Thor has never taken an Adamantium cutting laser to the chest of flown through the sun and survived unscathed, Superman has.

So withall of this said, isn't it a stupid fanboy notion to try to hang on to the false unfounded notion that "Thor is stronger than Superman". Like it or not, the comics don't lie, the truth is Thor has been bested by Superman in every crossover, his hammer has been caught by Superman, he's been K.O.ed with one punch by Superman, and still people say "Its just a crossover" well what the heck else do you want, it's going to be a crossover either way you slice it, its two characters from different universes duking it out and in this case, Superman wins, not by strength or speed or invulnerability, but simply because he is superior the superior character.

Thor is more than likely the more powerful character overall.
Superman maybe a bit stronger, but not a large margin.
Physically, Superman may have the edge, but the same can be said about him in comparison to Surfer.

We all know who's more powerful outta those two.

And for the record, Thor has tossed aliens out of the solar system, and sat in the sun unharmed.

Superman isn't the only one who has feats.

Supermans biggest arguable feat, is taking a blast of antisunlight, which could have destroyed half a galaxy, so many solar systems. Impressive.

Thor absorbed an attack that would have destroyed a fifth of the universe...........So countless galaxies, and even more solar systems. More impressive.

Superior character is Superman?? Debateable.

And until JLA/Avengers is referenced outside of the handbooks, why should we count it as cannon for Marvel??

Cuz DC does?

Not a good enough reason.

And the adamantium cutting lasers happened in a noncannon Superman/FF4 crossover.
Nothing to stand on.

Thor also has lifted something as heavy as a planet. The serpant. In fact not once but twice. Thor took blasts from celestials, several of them and lived. Which of the attacks had more power you think, the adamantium cutting laser or a celestials energy???? I think Ill take the celestial over the laser. Big T has all kinds of crazy feats to. Including time travel, anti matter particals, matter transmutation, soul transmigration ect, ect, ect...... Hell Mjolnir is like Dr. Strange on a stick...

Who says it was Thor, it might have been his hammer, and if it was then you should know that Superman has caught it, and Wonderwoman has picked it up.

He defeated Imperiex with a speed blitz, can Thor can't do that.

So what if Supes caught it and ww picked it up? First it was a crossover and they couldent use it like Thor does if they wanted to. No, Thor dosnt do much speedblitzing. Everyone knows that. What does all that have to do with anything? Thor is more versitile than Supes plain and simple and yea mjolnir is a big part of that. Well anyway thats my opinion and everyone else is welcomed to thiers. I think we have gotten things a little off topic.

Originally posted by Sirius77
He defeated Imperiex with a speed blitz, can Thor can't do that.

A force of the universe being beaten with a speedblitz doesn't reflect well on the power of the force.

Mr. Majestic is way over estimated, I think Beat Ray Bill could win this battle.

Originally posted by Sirius77
He defeated Imperiex with a speed blitz, can Thor can't do that.

Well you can't really say that Superman defeated Imperiex since it wasn't a base lv Supes. Even so, Classic Thor defeated Galactus, and ego the living planet.