Anyway, I didn't declare Anakin the winner. I was just saying if the two never knew each other (even though that's impossible) then Anakin SHOULD win. However, Anakin is too arrogant while Vader is more calm-minded and has experience slaying Jedi.
DAR
darthsith19Arm-Wrestler
Anakin is much faster and in better shape, he'd definately win in a saber fight. However, vader is likely slightly stronegr with the Force, but not that much stronger, I go with Anakin, cause I also doubt that vader could beat Tyranus in a fight.
JOL
jollyjim311Scruffy Nerf Herder
In a saber fight? Makashi would suck to the highest degree against Vader. He uses a form V variant, has ridiculous physical strength to counter Makashi, and, the light swings from Makashi most likely couldn't penetrate Vaders armor.
DAR
darthsith19Arm-Wrestler
Light swings of Makashi? He choped off Anakin's arm, even if it took several hits Tyranus is definately stronger than OT Vader with a lightsaber.
EV
ESB VaderRestricted
they never showed OT vaders real power, the shien form of lightsaber combat is a very aggresive form and can beat makashi strength to strength and yet OT vader uses that form with one hand because he has skill and he has incredible strength which rivals anakin