Thing vs. Hulk(Not what you think)

Started by ankur295 pages

cathes cap's sheild just like that

Originally posted by Lucid Lui
Hulk wins in a foot race, and Thing wins in combat speed.
I love the Avatar and sig.

And Thing wins.

hulk speed shown against jack ov hearts

hulk leaping at the speed of a nucleur missile?

a guy like pre crisis supes recognises hulks speed?

Originally posted by snoopdogg
While in my heart I know Hulk is a faster runner but I didn't have any scans to prove it so they said it's not true.

The main problem there is that Hulk jumps rather than runs. I think the closest I ever came to seeing him run was when he did very small leaps along a small distance.

Originally posted by snoopdogg
Well they showed a scan of Thing catching the Hulk or some sh!t like that and said there isn't any proof that Hulk is the faster runner.
Originally posted by snoopdogg
This is the scan Jonathanos used to prove Thing was indeed the faster of the two in running speed.

Both of these posts are untrue.

The scans I posted were in regard to combat speed. You originally stated:

Hulk is way faster than Thing or Colossus.

And you laughed when I said you were wrong about Hulk and Thing's speed. So I posted scans on page 3 of the thread. And you continued to argue the point. Then, on page 7 you suddenly switched to saying:

I was talking about running speed.

And I'm sorry but I don't buy that. If that had been the case, you would have pointed it out immediately after the scans were posted.

I did not ever claim that any scan I posted proved either was a faster runner.

Originally posted by ankur29
a guy like pre crisis supes recognises hulks speed?

That is not Pre-Crisis Superman.

ok the way i see it is getting the official bio form the handbook and checking the power grid , hulk is a 3 and thing is a 2 that expalins it all

someone pls post this i have the ultimate version if you guys want it

Originally posted by Jonathanos
That is not Pre-Crisis Superman.

is it not?

well i apologize as i seem to have made an error but the statement still stands

Originally posted by ankur29
ok the way i see it is getting the official bio form the handbook and checking the power grid , hulk is a 3 and thing is a 2 that expalins it all

someone pls post this i have the ultimate version if you guys want it

Continuity holds more weight than grids. In the Hulk handbook that came out a year or two ago, the grids have the Maestro being less powerful and not as intelligent as the Hulk. Continuity contradicts that.

Continuity has stated the Thing is the faster of the two.

i fail to undertstand what type of fast you are comparing them for?
in a fight or a race?
thing can duck , dive dodge more than hulk

hulk can sprint a hell of a lot faster than thing

do you have any scans that show things speed ?

pls post we will see which charecters seped scans determine who is faster

Originally posted by Jonathanos
Continuity holds more weight than grids. In the Hulk handbook that came out a year or two ago, the grids have the Maestro being less powerful and not as intelligent as the Hulk. Continuity contradicts that.

Continuity has stated the Thing is the faster of the two.

The problem with that is continuity way too inconsistent.

It's been settled Thing is a faster fighter than Hulk.

Now it's a footrace.

exactly so we must beileve the handbooks and according to the handboks hulk is faster

Originally posted by ankur29
i fail to undertstand what type of fast you are comparing them for?
in a fight or a race?
thing can duck , dive dodge more than hulk

hulk can sprint a hell of a lot faster than thing

do you have any scans that show things speed ?

pls post we will see which charecters seped scans determine who is faster

I can't post the links. The board won't allow me to.

We were originally talking about combat speed and I posted scans stating Thing was faster and a couple supporting it visually.

A day or two later, he switched to running speed and I repeatedly said I had no way of proving either was the faster runner. Hulk's sprinting speed is unknown. It's just speculation. If Hulk wants to travel fast, he leaps.

Originally posted by snoopdogg
The problem with that is continuity way too inconsistent.

And I don't understand that mindset at all. Yes, continuity is inconsistent. So are the handbooks. Why do you choose to believe the characters are capable of feats they have never managed or incapable of feats they have managed simply because a Handbook says so?

The Handbooks originally stated the Hulk could not survive a ground zero nuclear detonation. Yet before the first Handbook was printed, the Hulk had already survived several unharmed. So the Hulk couldn't survive nukes even though he had?

The Handbook also stated the Hulk would freeze at temperatures below -250 degrees Fahrenheit and burn at temperatures exceeding 3000 degrees. Hulk had already weathered temperatures below the -250 limit and nukes vastly exceed 3000 degrees. Would you say the Hulk couldn't survive those temperatures even though he had?

no but looking towards the handbooks is the only way we can solve who is faster of the two in race

With so many incorrect statements in the handbook, I put no trust in it.

Originally posted by Jonathanos

We were originally talking about combat speed and I posted scans stating Thing was faster and a couple supporting it visually.

You were originally talking about combat speed. As I told you countless times I put combat/running speed into the same category cause they are both movements. Flight is a diff. category.
Originally posted by Jonathanos

A day or two later, he switched to running speed and I repeatedly said I had no way of proving either was the faster runner. Hulk's sprinting speed is unknown. It's just speculation. If Hulk wants to travel fast, he leaps.
It's generally accepted that Hulk is the faster runner.