Prove to me that you have a soul.

Started by Emperor Ashtar28 pages
Originally posted by Shakyamunison
I feel that all animals, including humans, are the same where it come to the question of a soul.

Well, all organisms have a life-force/Energy, but a soul is not something your born with it's something you discover in my belief system.

Originally posted by Emperor Ashtar
Well, all organisms have a life-force/Energy, but a soul is not something your born with it's something you discover in my belief system.

How can you discover something you do not have?

Originally posted by Shakyamunison
How can you discover something you do not have?

You do have it, but it's just not there at birth I should say. It's something that you develop by knowing the self. similiar to what Christians call the "Personal relationship with God".

Originally posted by Emperor Ashtar
You do have it, but it's just not there at birth I should say. It's something that you develop by knowing the self.

My cat has a very well developed sense of self. She has a strong opinion about what she wants and does not want. If it is not her idea, even if she wants it, she will not do it. However, she has found a way around this; if I call her on my lap to get a brushing, that she loves, she will not come right away. She will pretend to ignore me, but I can tell by the direction of her ears that she is listening to me. When I have stopped calling her, and enough time has past, she will jump onto my lap to get a brushing. Does my cat have a soul?

Originally posted by Shakyamunison
My cat has a very well developed sense of self. She has a strong opinion about what she wants and does not want. If it is not her idea, even if she wants it, she will not do it. However, she has found a way around this; if I call her on my lap to get a brushing, that she loves, she will not come right away. She will pretend to ignore me, but I can tell by the direction of her ears that she is listening to me. When I have stopped calling her, and enough time has past, she will jump onto my lap to get a brushing. Does my cat have a soul?

That's not what I mean by discovering yourself.
Think more along the lines of:

-The Heroes Journey
-The Trials of Hercules
-Odin's journey
- Crusifiction of Jesus

The Soul is the result of Self Discovery

Originally posted by Emperor Ashtar
That's not what I mean by discovering yourself.
Think more along the lines of:

-The Heroes Journey
-The Trials of Hercules
-Odin's journey
- Crusifiction of Jesus

The Soul is the result of Self Discovery

You have now lost me. Walk me through it.

Originally posted by Shakyamunison
You have now lost me. Walk me through it.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daimonic

It's a real common religous mottif associated with Solar/Light based diety's.

Originally posted by Emperor Ashtar
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daimonic

It's a real common religous mottif associated with Solar/Light based diety's.

I understand. I would call this my entity, and I have spoke with my entity. IMO an entity is not a soul.

Originally posted by Shakyamunison
I understand. I would call this my entity, and I have spoke with my entity. IMO an entity is not a soul.

A "Soul" is just a name, it's definition is subjective. A "Soul" to me is the self or Self-Discovery. Also, I wasn't talking about the daimon itself more so than the process.

I believe there is a connection between the word "Soul" and "Sol" as a motif in Western Religion.

I don't believe in a "me" but I believe in reincarnation, for instance...both of which would be consistent with Buddhism, where there is no "soul". But for the reincarnation belief, something has to carry on, so it's a tricky distinction. I think that the main issue comes from the conflict between the Western idea of 'soul' and Eastern concepts of unity and no-self.

I believe the ends are similiar between Western & Eastern mysticism, just difference in concepts. I believe in the self and I'm more of a Panentheist than a Pantheist.

They seem to be different interpertations of the samething.

Originally posted by Emperor Ashtar
I believe the ends are similiar between Western & Eastern mysticism, just difference in concepts. I believe in the self and I'm more of a Panentheist than a Pantheist.

They seem to be different interpertations of the samething.

Please explain. I've heard of Pantheism, but never heard that variation on it.