Originally posted by kevdudethen ur argument is tha thanos mini is out of 616. so the hunger isnt a part of 616 either. neither is the fallen one who appeared in annihilation wave.
I've heard that too estacado. Notice he said he was God of 'this reality' and leaving the possibility of other reality's probably meaning DC,Image and others 😖hifty:
so where im going. i have proof. others do not remember this except for a select few.
iwin
[/IMG]
*sigh*
This is getting totally absurd. But it's kind of funny to see someone continue to drown in quicksand while you're trying throw them a rope.
Anyhow...here I am 'getting a clue'...
Originally posted by quanchi112I never claimed that at all.
uhm so thanos series did not happen in 616. where is ur proof? mt proof says it happened. ur proof which u have none.
u claim to argue with marvel writers. 😆 😆You must be dyslexic, cause I never claimed that either.
u are one of the silliest people i have ever meant.Pot.Kettle.Black...and I know there are a ton of people on this board that will agree with me on that one...
a guy who claims he has discussions with marvel writers about all this. 🙄Again...you're out to lunch, cause I never claimed to have any discussions with Marvel writers.
he ferferred to ig and everything else he did.What does 'ferferred' mean? I'll assume you mean referred.
so why count ig and not the end.That's a valid question...one which I posed to former Marvel editor Andy Schmidt, on another board.
u have no answer i win.I gave you my answer...which was the answer Schmidt gave me. (See posts above).
i have proof while ur proof is that marvel has sais its not canon.Well duh...obviously Marvel's word holds weight...don't ya think?
show me something official stating this. ur word is worth nothing. i would never believe a guy who says he sopke with writers or editors. sho wme something official or concede ur point if u have one,You sure you want to see it?
http://forums.comicbookresources.com/showthread.php?t=114874&page=6
Andy Schmidt is answering questions about Annihilation, and other Marvel stuff. Scroll about half-way down the page and you'll see him respond to my question. My response to him is on the next page, (or the page after).
Have fun!
i win.Again, you lose.
this thanos sereis references ig and the end. u just say the ig counts but everyone who reads this knows they both stand.Look kid, I've been through all this before. Everyone doesn't know...and I used to be one of them until I got the official story...now I hope you're enlightened as well.
get a clue and then get back to me.Just did...now it's your turn.
Be a good little quanchi and concede.
💃
Originally posted by Lord Slisten it was referenced in thanos series.
*sigh*This is getting totally absurd. But it's kind of funny to see someone continue to drown in quicksand while you're trying throw them a rope.
Anyhow...here I am 'getting a clue'...
I never claimed that at all.
You must be dyslexic, cause I never claimed that either.
Pot.Kettle.Black...and I know there are a ton of people on this board that will agree with me on that one...
Again...you're out to lunch, cause I never claimed to have any discussions with Marvel writers.
What does 'ferferred' mean? I'll assume you mean referred.
That's a valid question...one which I posed to former Marvel editor Andy Schmidt, on another board.
I gave you my answer...which was the answer Schmidt gave me. (See posts above).
Well duh...obviously Marvel's word holds weight...don't ya think?
You sure you want to see it?
http://forums.comicbookresources.com/showthread.php?t=114874&page=6
Andy Schmidt is answering questions about Annihilation, and other Marvel stuff. Scroll about half-way down the page and you'll see him respond to my question. My response to him is on the next page, (or the page after).
Have fun!
Again, you lose.
Look kid, I've been through all this before. Everyone doesn't know...and I used to be one of them until I got the official story...now I hope you're enlightened as well.
Just did...now it's your turn.
Be a good little quanchi and concede.
💃
ok so ull understand what makes more sense. all these events happened as thanos has refernced them or something similar happened but we dont know what?
i mean come on man use ur brain. this has been referenced. do u consider the thanos series to be canon unto the 616 universe?
do u consider annihilation wave to be canon unto the 616 universe?
answer these questions please and dont tell me what adny schmidt said?
tell me what u think and use ur brain here for once.
somesimilar story it says. hahahhahahahahhahahhahahhahhah
that is the funniest shit i have read in a while. its funny but i guess thanos did something else with the THOTU.
this is ur proof.
this is laughable. now answer my questions and this one as well.
what did thanos do then. other than speculate while my proof is specific please tell me what he did.
Dear quanchi: Can you really be this immature?
How much do you know about comics anyhow? If you were half as intelligent as you try to push on everyone, you'd know that the premise of every 'The End' series is that they are set in alternate universes. 'Marvel: The End' is no exception.
What's clear is that 'The End' was not canon...but elements of which were made canon by Jim Starlin when he began the Thanos series. But there are inconsistencies that prevent it from becoming fully canon, (ie. LT getting pwned). Bottom line is the official word from Marvel holds more weight than your mere speculation and so-called 'proof'.
Originally posted by quanchi112All you've proven is that even monkeys can be taught to type.
listen it was referenced in thanos series.
it was explained. i cannot believe i have tio argue with u over this. its become boring becuz i have proven my point while u keep saying that the editor disagrees with it.
ok so ull understand what makes more sense. all these events happened as thanos has refernced them or something similar happened but we dont know what?I honestly can't make out what you're saying here. Please speak in proper English.
i mean come on man use ur brain. this has been referenced. do u consider the thanos series to be canon unto the 616 universe?Of course the Thanos series and Annihilation series are canon, and part of the 616 universe...I have never, (nor has anyone else), claimed otherwise
do u consider annihilation wave to be canon unto the 616 universe?
answer these questions please and dont tell me what adny schmidt said?What Andy Schmidt says hold far more weight than what your understanding is of what's canon and noncanon. Do you understand?
tell me what u think and use ur brain here for once.LOL...this from you...how ironic.
somesimilar story it says. hahahhahahahahhahahhahahhahhahWell you're free to disagree with it...but it's the official position. All the immature antics in the world won't change it.
that is the funniest shit i have read in a while. its funny but i guess thanos did something else with the THOTU.So you're actually arguing the word of an official Marvel source? That's an uphill climb. And considering that 90% of what comes off your keyboard isn't worth a damn, you're in no position to even speculate on what's funny.this is ur proof.
this is laughable. now answer my questions and this one as well.
what did thanos do then. other than speculate while my proof is specific please tell me what he did.First of all you have no proof...secondly, I don't know what he did. I don't work at Marvel...I don't know if they've even got a story cooked up. I'm personally hoping that they do release a one-shot...like 'Thanos: The Hidden Story' or something, to account for what happened in between 'Infinity Abyss' and 'Thanos' #1.
In the meantime, at last check it was against the rules to cite feats in out-of-continuity stories and present them as evidence.
Originally posted by Lord Swhy do u continue to fight against all logic and thanos reference to his feats as they occurred in marvels the end. u act as if thanos series is canon but the events he spoke about are not. how does tha make any sense.
Dear quanchi: Can you really be this immature?How much do you know about comics anyhow? If you were half as intelligent as you try to push on everyone, you'd know that the premise of every 'The End' series is that they are set in alternate universes. 'Marvel: The End' is no exception.
What's clear is that 'The End' was not canon...but elements of which were made canon by Jim Starlin when he began the Thanos series. But there are inconsistencies that prevent it from becoming fully canon, (ie. LT getting pwned). Bottom line is the official word from Marvel holds more weight than your mere speculation and so-called 'proof'.
All you've proven is that even monkeys can be taught to type.
I honestly can't make out what you're saying here. Please speak in proper English.
Of course the Thanos series and Annihilation series are canon, and part of the 616 universe...I have never, (nor has anyone else), claimed otherwise
What Andy Schmidt says hold far more weight than what your understanding is of what's canon and noncanon. Do you understand?
LOL...this from you...how ironic.
Well you're free to disagree with it...but it's the official position. All the immature antics in the world won't change it.
So you're actually arguing the word of an official Marvel source? That's an uphill climb. And considering that 90% of what comes off your keyboard isn't worth a damn, you're in no position to even speculate on what's funny.
First of all you have no proof...secondly, I don't know what he did. I don't work at Marvel...I don't know if they've even got a story cooked up. I'm personally hoping that they do release a one-shot...like 'Thanos: The Hidden Story' or something, to account for what happened in between 'Infinity Abyss' and 'Thanos' #1.
In the meantime, at last check it was against the rules to cite feats in out-of-continuity stories and present them as evidence.
what event took place then with thanos and the heart of the universe then. u keep saying something similar. what exactly. i bet u have no clue. so please tell me what happened? what was thanos referring to in his series? tell me.
again someone claiming they are andy schmidt and actually talking to him are two different things. show me this on an offical marvel website. not just some internet debating on some site.
u are very clueless and u really have no stance. ur stance is something similar happened but the hell if i know?
when thanos told u what happened and guess what its the same outcome that happened in marvels the end.
i win.
The problem with Andy saying this, is that Mr. M seems have evidence that goes the other way. Before you brought this up, I would have just said The End was canon and left it alone.
But if Marvel's handbooks and official guides say one thing, and Andy Schmidt another, who is to be believed?
It's a moot point anyways. It's not a feat for Thanos because TOAA set him up from the beginning. 😛
Originally posted by TricksterPriesti cannot believe u actually agree with me. im sure it was hard for u to post this. andy schmidt isnt even saying this on his official website if he has one. its someone answering questions. if it isnt on marvels official website then its not marvels official stance. get it lord s as everyone else does but u.
The problem with Andy saying this, is that Mr. M seems have evidence that goes the other way. Before you brought this up, I would have just said The End was canon and left it alone.But if Marvel's handbooks and official guides say one thing, and Andy Schmidt another, who is to be believed?
It's a moot point anyways. It's not a feat for Thanos because TOAA set him up from the beginning. 😛
😆
it is a feat for thanos as he did everything on his own and wasnt helped along. he chose his path and didnt have it chosen for him.
thanos got the heart and became the supreme being. it wasnt just given to him.
when darkseid was killed by spectre and wasnt allowed to die it wasnt by anything darkseid did but by his importance to the universe. thanos role in this story means he was the only one who could save all of marvel but he had to accomplish these things and didnt just sit there and wait for them to happen.
see the diff.
Originally posted by quanchi112I already did...look in the previous post.
what event took place then with thanos and the heart of the universe then. u keep saying something similar. what exactly. i bet u have no clue. so please tell me what happened? what was thanos referring to in his series? tell me.
again someone claiming they are andy schmidt and actually talking to him are two different things. show me this on an offical marvel website. not just some internet debating on some site.Do you know that CBR is perhaps the largest comic book community online? A site with a lot of credibility, which draws a lot of writers and editors...and I'm more than certain they wouldn't stoop as low as to bring an imposter on just to try to hoodwink little quanchi.
u are very clueless and u really have no stance. ur stance is something similar happened but the hell if i know?My stance is clear...maybe you should actually read what I've wrote before spewing gibberish.
when thanos told u what happened and guess what its the same outcome that happened in marvels the end.No the outcome of 'Marvel: The End' was Thanos dying...maybe you missed that. How did he come back to life? 😕
i win.Only in your mind...in reality you continue to lose.
andy schmidt isnt even saying this on his official website if he has one. its someone answering questions. if it isnt on marvels official website then its not marvels official stance. get it lord s as everyone else does but u.You're a retard...plain and simple.
Originally posted by Lord Swhere is marvel officially denouncing the end. i dont see an official stance on this. i see a comic which u say is in continuity reference the end. one again read the scan.
I already did...look in the previous post.Do you know that CBR is perhaps the largest comic book community online? A site with a lot of credibility, which draws a lot of writers and editors...and I'm more than certain they wouldn't stoop as low as to bring an imposter on just to try to hoodwink little quanchi.
My stance is clear...maybe you should actually read what I've wrote before spewing gibberish.
No the outcome of 'Marvel: The End' was Thanos dying...maybe you missed that. How did he come back to life? 😕
Only in your mind...in reality you continue to lose.
You're a retard...plain and simple.
[/IMG]
Originally posted by quanchi112
where is marvel officially denouncing the end. i dont see an official stance on this. i see a comic which u say is in continuity reference the end. one again read the scan.[/IMG]
NOTICE IT SAYS ADAM WARLOCK SAY HE WAS AWARE OF HIS CONTINUED EXISTENCE.
LOOK MY THEORY MAKES SENSE AND IS IN AN ACTUAL COMIC WHEREAS URS IS IN SOME COMIC BOOK FORUM.
WHICH ONE TO BELIEVE,
MY PROOF MAKES SENSE WHILE URS MAKES NO SENSE WHATSOEVER.
Originally posted by quanchi112Instead of reducing myself to your childish level...let me provide the following link of a forum topic from Comixfan in a section run by Marvel's senior editor, (and I hope you've heard of him), Tom Brevoort, (which I'm sure you'll dismiss as being an imposter, but oh well), entitled 'Tales from the TomB':
where is marvel officially denouncing the end. i dont see an official stance on this. i see a comic which u say is in continuity reference the end. one again read the scan.[/IMG]
http://www.comixfan.com/xfan/forums/showthread.php?t=22495
It's an interesting read as they were talking about the canonicity of 'The End' back in 2003.
Note the line: "It's also possible that Thanos lived through a similar adventure that we never saw on the printed page, but in which certain details were different."
That seems to be their official stance. Sort of like Sentry's 'stalemating' of Galactus...we don't know the particulars of it, but can only speculate.