the writers added the 'peas in the pod' for a reason..
they also added the 'We are alike...I and you, you and I...us' line for a reason aswell.
The writers added this because they WANT us to see the connection between these two characters, and they WANT us to want this relationship even though it is wrong (because shes with someone else...).
The writers want us to be in the same dilemma as Elizabeth, because she has choices to make in the third movie...they want us to have these discussions amongst ourselves...because that way, we talk about allsorts of theories and then at the end we begin to doubt ourselves anyway!
This is the only film trilogy i have ever seen where there is so much confusion and theory issues between the fans...and thats because the writers have done a wonderful job of crossng lines and making the impossible out to be possible.
And the writers will not leave us dry...even if they go down the elizabeth/will path, you know they are going to give us jack/elizabeth fans some kind of closure, because otherwise they would be bad writers!
However...i get the feeling that the writers like to make things as complicated as possible. they've already stated that in life people like the interesting side of things....the unexpected. I think this is what they are going to give us.
THEY KNOW Jack is the hero, whenever they have interviews it is JACK they talk about, and then how the other characters evolve around him.
The KNOW the elizabeth/jack relationship theory is out there because they have obviously thought about it themselves...And johnny depp has stated that the climax of the third film was a surprise for him...because he did not expect his character to go down that path.....
Johnny knows his character is deep...he knows his character is a little eccentric...but the one thing that no one thought the character of Jack Sparrow could have would be (as lovelyone states time and time again!) 'LOVE'.
We dont really know much about his past, and this is why this third film is important to the story. the past leads to who you are in the present.
I think the interview where ted and terry are talking about the fact that they could end the story of DMC there and feel comfortable is a BIG hint for good things of Elizabeth/Jack IMO.
So yeah she chained him to the mast...but before she did it she told him he was a good man...she kissed him...he told her she was a pirate. They completely swapped roles, which is why they are peas in a pod.
Jack HAD elizabeth at the end of the film, and will watched on in confusion. And jack also became the HERO....he did something good and reeped the rewards, just as Elizabeth said he secretly wanted.
If this was the end of the films (and there was no 3rd installment) i would have been happy with this ending...because jack got the girl, got the hero's exit....and elizabeth finally realised what it was she wanted .... freedom.
Ok ill stop speaking now 🙂
IM KEEPING THE FAITH!!!! 🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂