to recast

It's probably been done before, but let's say you were casting for POTC and you couldn't get Johnny, Keira, Orlando, and the rest. Who would you cast in their place?

Liz: Rachel McAdams (see Red Eye)

Will: Tobey Maguire, ha ha ha ha ha Spider-Man in the 1600s.

Norrington: Ben Affleck, he's good at playing a stiff. In fact, it's the only role he does well.

I can't even think of where to begin for the rest.

oh no! not ben affleck as norrington! norri's got voice to die for, really 😄 and ben.. well, too sweet guy, and for sure NOT too sexi ;D

liz: natalie portman (we won't see difference) ;D

and for sure: no tom cruise in cast! lol ;D

Ha ha, yeah, no Tom Cruise! And I agree with you about Norrington. He needs to be played by a worthy actor.

ok, but maybe tom really wants to play in PotC... let's give him sth... ;D f.e. do ya remember pigd that gibbs was sleeping on? one of those pigs, i think... lol ;D tom-piggy ;D

I really cant think of anyone else doing CAPTAIN JACK SPARROW!!! i think if it were to have been anyone else the movie wouldnt have been that great!!!

yeah, johnny has made jack on his own... sb else would do it in the other style... on no, no, no, no other jack sparrow! 😎 🏴‍☠️

Originally posted by akanai
ok, but maybe tom really wants to play in PotC... let's give him sth... ;D f.e. do ya remember pigd that gibbs was sleeping on? one of those pigs, i think... lol ;D tom-piggy ;D

haha, you're too cruel!!

if johnny didn't do jack sparrow then he would be totally different just like you guys said, johnny said in a interview that they were picturing jack sparrow alot different

Originally posted by akanai
oh no! not ben affleck as norrington! norri's got voice to die for, really 😄 and ben.. well, too sweet guy, and for sure NOT too sexi ;D

liz: natalie portman (we won't see difference) ;D

and for sure: no tom cruise in cast! lol ;D

I think will could be played by ethier heath ledger or brad pitt

i still think carey elwes when he was younger could play Jack Sparrow

we discussed the recast 4 jack Sparrow, and we decided that Cary Elwes was the best choice if johnny didnt exist (heaven forbid). in case u dont know who that is.. he played westly in Princess Bride, the evil uncle in Ella Enchanted, and Sir ERobin of Locksly in Men In Tights. hes actually pretty ssexxi.......

Originally posted by ivebeendepped43
we discussed the recast 4 jack Sparrow, and we decided that Cary Elwes was the best choice if johnny didnt exist (heaven forbid). in case u dont know who that is.. he played westly in Princess Bride, the evil uncle in Ella Enchanted, and Sir ERobin of Locksly in Men In Tights. hes actually pretty ssexxi.......

*hugs* and all this time i thought i was talking to a wall! inlove

Cary is REALLY cute. hot accent. awesome actor

mmmmhhhmmmmmmm...........

i just wish he was in more movies

yeah he was twister....

can someone post a pic of natalie Portman? ive never seen her...actually n/m *goes 2 photobucket and looks her up* holy freakin crap! they do look similar! but, i think Natalie is prettier, and i dont just say tha cuz i h8 keira................wait, yes i do

yeah well kiera knightly played her lady in waiting double in star wars EPI

why couldnt she b the STUNT DOUBLE! maybe she would die in the filming..... i wish those french fishermen left her and her mom on that Caribbean island a few years ago.......

theres a picture of her
but thats not one that looks alot like keira
there are others that look ALOT like her