Originally posted by capt it up
does it need to be? sicne it speaks abotu eachother's past and event's that happen to logan. they also have alreayd explained how lgoan can get there. I really see no reason fro why they need to mention it.They neevr refferenced othe rone shott's even in non cross over's does that make them no cannon? no it makes them perfectly cannon.
the reaosn other comic's are not cannon liek teen titan x-men is becuase there on explanation of how they got there, there no evidence to support that they ahve been there before. there no evidence that states thing that have happen to them in there normal reality.
It cannon for wolverine that's for sure however is it cannon for darkness I am not sure. it did talk about darknesses past so I believe it be cannon for him as well.
Edit:Their fight has never been mentioned anywhere not in a Wolverine book and not in Logan's biography it is only Capt's speculation.
Originally posted by juggernaut66666
It's not canon for Darkness. 😐Edit:Their fight has never been mentioned anywhere not in a Wolverine book and not in Logan's biography it is only Capt's speculation.
It was cannon for wolverine. all the events mention logan was there during thsoe times . Also ever cross over with wolverine and top cow has been made cannon due to the fact they have explained why logan cna get there
That is fact
Originally posted by Metalmanx
But all of the history prior to the actual death of Xavier (which triggers AOA) is completely the same. Thus, according to your logic, makes it canon.Disagree?
Logan was part of weapon x when magneto found him
Originally posted by juggernaut66666
Jackie Estacado has appeared in crossover storylines involving Painkiller Jane, The Hulk, Batman, and Superman, Aliens, Predator, Witchblade, Wolverine, and Tomb Raider. These are non-canonical.
ya wiki real good evidence.
I said it was cannon for wolverine never said any thing about it being cannon for darkness
Originally posted by capt it upThat crossover is non cannon. It's like saying Superman owning Thor is coninical. Or Hulk vs. Superman is. It is not.
It was cannon for wolverine. all the events mention logan was there during thsoe times . Also ever cross over with wolverine and top cow has been made cannon due to the fact they have explained why logan cna get thereThat is fact
since it was deemed canon in both dc and marvel...
and yeah, actually it is canon as well.. all the access crossover stuff is.. it was referenced in dc in green lantern comics, and a lobo comic, as well as in marvel in exiles comics as events that have taken place. hence. canon.
and who said I think wolverine can beat kyle rayner....
though to play devil's advocate it's not implausible.. the ring runs on willpower yes? and kyle would lose to wolverine any day of the week on a test of wills... hell he lost to deathstroke in that same fashion... and frankly batman's punked him out...
not to say he's not formidable.. and yeah he can take logan.. but you should probably think things through in the future before you go shoving words down other people's throats..
Damn good fight!
Wanted to make this thread because I thought it'd be an awesome fight and probably one of the lowest level people Wolverine fans would actually have to seriously fight about.
I say Midnighter because he'd know everything about the fights before they happened and is close enough to wolverine in everything else to make that all that matters. IMO