so far you have all depended on feat showing the only problem with that is while it does show how well a character fairs against a certain power or situation, it doesn't guarantee that's how things would work 100% of the time noe every fight is going to be the same different people fight different ways sometimes a character would loose to another character one battle and he would win the next superman could fight someone of a certain power set one day and win and loose to another person of the same power set the next (of course we all know dc would never let that happen) if you think every battle will work out the same because of a showing against a different opponent then you don't know much about fighting noting every works out the way you want it 100% of the time, nothing is set in stone so saying superman wins because he already beat someone of a similar power type is foolish because that doesn't take into account how the other person would fight and implement their powers