Revan versus Yoda and Mace Windu

Originally posted by Darth Sexy
Yup, that's lightsnake's email.

that is janus mail, he was the 1 who posted it, i mean come on some guys opinion can overrite other things? Seems weird for ROTS palpatine to be the strongest

Originally posted by zephiel7
That was before Dan came in here and said it was all interpretive. I remember that back in the day when LS came back and the AnteDiluvians were told to leave by Ush. 🙁

Actually no, because lightsnake told me those emails are like a few months old. And it's pretty obvious the email is real, but who signs up for this forum is impossible to tell. Dan Wallace doesn't contradict himself.

yea but he said in the email its his opinion only that palpatine is the strongest, and he did say something that sidious is the strongest on his era which is damm true, because GL confirmed it

remember the mail "Both of them were the most powerful in their eras 5000 years apart"

Originally posted by Kadesh
yea but he said in the email its his opinion only that palpatine is the strongest, and he did say something that sidious is the strongest on his era which is damm true, because GL confirmed it

remember the mail "Both of them were the most powerful in their eras 5000 years apart"

In the email he said that Sidious could defeat Marka Ragnos, and that he WAS the strongest ever.

yea but he said thats his opinion only and its made canon

Originally posted by Kadesh
yea but he said thats his opinion only and its made canon

His opinion is pretty much canon, as well as the NEC that he wrote.

so ok if he like said and wrote in the nec that if exar would be the strongest, would that be true? well he is the one who can write what ever he want in the nec as long as it doesnt contradict

Originally posted by Darth Sexy
His opinion is pretty much canon, as well as the NEC that he wrote.

But he immediately came to the forums and stated that it was interpretative... giving us permission to see to it as we will without violating canon.

Originally posted by zephiel7
But he immediately came to the forums and stated that it was interpretative... giving us permission to see to it as we will without violating canon.

#1. Look at the dates, which one is first.
#2. His emails confirms as him..ANYONE can sign up to this forum and be Dan wallace.

Originally posted by Kadesh
so ok if he like said and wrote in the nec that if exar would be the strongest, would that be true? well he is the one who can write what ever he want in the nec as long as it doesnt contradict

um can some1 answer this?

As long as it doesn't contradict GL's plans, it can be true sure.

Originally posted by Darth Sexy
#1. Look at the dates, which one is first.
#2. His emails confirms as him..ANYONE can sign up to this forum and be Dan wallace.

1)he one on the boards is 24th the message is the 21st...

2)OH COME ON...even LS who would despise the comment "quotes can be interpretative" would admit that it was legitimate.

Originally posted by zephiel7
1)he one on the boards is 24th the message is the 21st...

2)OH COME ON...even LS who would despise the comment "quotes can be interpretative" would admit that it was legitimate.

look Zeph, he wrote the NEC, then he confirmed it with the email. So either you're misinterpreting the msg here or it was not Dan Wallace.. If you want I'll email him again.

Originally posted by Darth Sexy
look Zeph, he wrote the NEC, then he confirmed it with the email. So either you're misinterpreting the msg here or it was not Dan Wallace.. If you want I'll email him again.

Er...what?

I agree he wrote the NEC.

I am saying he came on the boards AFTER LS sent the email.

Originally posted by zephiel7
Er...what?

I agree he wrote the NEC.

I am saying he came on the boards AFTER LS sent the email.

can you prove it was him? No. Can I prove it was his email? Yes. And his email confirms what he wrote in the NEC, so he won't come on here and contradict it.