Thor vs. GL Hal

Started by Supreme being7 pages
Supreme being Astet controller
Originally posted by dvampire
Why do people always choose classic Thor? Is the current Thor to weaker?

Lol current Thor is blind and asleep somewhere in space or asgard.

sexyking Senior Member

Hal Jordan to take a vast Majority against Thor a non playing Gl of Hals caliber isn't to be taken lightly

Priest Senior Member

Originally posted by dvampire
Why do people always choose classic Thor? Is the current Thor to weaker?

Current thor, the last we accually seen him is a elder god. He'l beat HAl 10/10.
Classic thor would is just a better match.
Anyways on topic, this would probally be a stailmate. Written to full potential both characters cant really do anything to the other.
Going by average showings, thor's seem to be more impressive tho.
Like i said before, if i had to pick id give Thor a slight majority.

jrodslam Senior Member

Hal.

nvrbeenwthagirl Restricted

Originally posted by Beta Ray Howard
Lots of things have "potential" but it doesn't mean that the wielder will always be competent to use it to its full limits.

Anyone can pick up a sword and swing it. However, not many can really use a weapon like a GL Ring or an Uru Hammer and both of their abilities correctly in a fight.

Thor and HAL certainly can use thier weapons the best. Period.

masterbruce Senior Member

Originally posted by Beta Ray Howard
Lots of things have "potential" but it doesn't mean that the wielder will always be competent to use it to its full limits.

Anyone can pick up a sword and swing it. However, not many can really use a weapon like a GL Ring or an Uru Hammer and both of their abilities correctly in a fight.

my point was that a fullpotential GL Ring is greater than a fullpotential Mjonlir

WrathfulDwarf THE LOOSE CANNON

I'm willing to accept Thor can beat Hal...if some of you are willing to accept that Thor defeats Silver Surfer.

(Ooooh....stalemate)

Priest Senior Member

I always thought that thor can take 5/5 against surfer.

Accel Senior Member

Hal and Surfer both have every advantage that matters in a fight against Thor. Either one of them should take the comfortable majority against him.

nvrbeenwthagirl Restricted
Originally posted by Accel
Hal and Surfer both have every advantage that matters in a fight against Thor. Either one of them should take the comfortable majority against him.

True, surfer's speed and use of the power cosmic clearly trumps thor's use of his hammer.

Hal trumps thor with his ability to literally pummel thor with al kinds of living constructs and creative uses.

WrathfulDwarf THE LOOSE CANNON

Technically both Hal and SS possess Cosmic feats. To me Thor is on a different level of power. Both magical and cosmic.

I never consider SS or a GL to take on a god. Thus I've always consider Thor to be more powerful.

nvrbeenwthagirl Restricted

Originally posted by WrathfulDwarf
Technically both Hal and SS possess Cosmic feats. To me Thor is on a different level of power. Both magical and cosmic.

I never consider SS or a GL to take on a god. Thus I've always consider Thor to be more powerful.

Thor is a small God. He is even mortal. I don't consider him to above cosmic beings. Cosmic beings have always trumped God's in comics anyway.

Priest Senior Member

Originally posted by WrathfulDwarf
Technically both Hal and SS possess Cosmic feats. To me Thor is on a different level of power. Both magical and cosmic.

I never consider SS or a GL to take on a god. Thus I've always consider Thor to be more powerful.


Thor just has the sheer power and strength surpasses Surfer or Hal. The Mjinor can pretty versatile, i have seen thor use it to absorb energies to absorbing souls.
he has a good combination of raw power and versatility that puts him on par with Hal or Surfer. Most people find it hard to belive however. 😬

Priest Senior Member

Originally posted by nvrbeenwthagirl
Thor is a small God. He is even mortal. I don't consider him to above cosmic beings. Cosmic beings have always trumped God's in comics anyway.

what the heck are u talking about?
Thor is immortal.. period

WrathfulDwarf THE LOOSE CANNON
Originally posted by Priest
Thor just has the sheer power and strength surpasses Surfer or Hal. The Mjinor can pretty versatile, i have seen thor use it to absorb energies to absorbing souls.
he has a good combination of raw power and versatility that puts him on par with Hal or Surfer. Most people find it hard to belive however. 😬

Would you care to contribute to a thread in which Gods, Cosmic, and Titans is discuss?

Your imput would be very appreciated. 🙂

nvrbeenwthagirl Restricted

[QUOTE=8373841]Originally posted by Priest
what the heck are u talking about?
Thor is immortal.. period [/QUOTE
NO he is not. He is not immortal like the Olympians. He may be long lived. The Asgardians can die. Isn't that why he takes Odin's place?

Priest Senior Member

Originally posted by nvrbeenwthagirl
NO he is not. He is not immortal like the Olympians. He may be long lived. The Asgardians can die. Isn't that why he takes Odin's place?

Odin and Thor are diffrent tho, thor had already surpased Odin being a eldergod.
But it is widely reguared that thor is immortal, and stated in comics many many times that he in fact is immortal.

Priest Senior Member

Originally posted by WrathfulDwarf
Would you care to contribute to a thread in which Gods, Cosmic, and Titans is discuss?

Your imput would be very appreciated. 🙂


send me a link ill check it out.

juggernaut66666 Legendary

BTW Thor is a "hybrid".

Soleran Fast As Time
Originally posted by nvrbeenwthagirl
[QUOTE=8373841]Originally posted by Priest
[B]what the heck are u talking about?
Thor is immortal.. period [/QUOTE
NO he is not. He is not immortal like the Olympians. He may be long lived. The Asgardians can die. Isn't that why he takes Odin's place? [/B]

Thor isn't the same as Odin.

Thor is the product of Odin and Gaea not two asgardians.