Batman versus Nightwing and Robin!

Both sides have 1 day prep.

Fight in Gotham!

I think Batman prevails after a long hard frought battle. The day of prep helps him more than Robin and Nightwing. Also, he knows them better than the back of his hand since he trained them.

These are the two best "humans" to attempt to take the dark knight. Either one of them could come closer to it than anyone else without vast superpowers. Alone they come very close to defeating him especially Dick, you make it two on one and the two are the only ones capable of coming close and, Bruce has really got to prep tp be ready to see if the students can surpass the master.

Bruce vs. Dick = Bruce 7 or 8/10
Bruce vs Tim = Bruce 9/10
Tim and Dick = Tim and Dick at least 7/10

Robin and Nightwing win....Robin is smarter than Bruce, and Dick can equal Bruce in a fight. Add in Tim to the melee, I'd give it to the team 7-8/10. Also, sure Bruce knows them, but they know Bruce just as well.

Originally posted by Darth Macabre
Robin is smarter than Bruce

Originally posted by outavodka
😆 😆 😆.....but no seriously 🤨 wat the hell are you talking about???

Originally posted by Darth Macabre
What are you laughing at? Bruce himself has said Tim is smarter than him.

false modesty

Originally posted by fsufan89
false modesty

tim & dick definately edge out a majority
nightwing is allready a good match for bruce, throw in robin and it tips the scales in their favor

Originally posted by Darth Macabre
No....An honest observation. Tim's character is based on his mind; he's not the physical type like Dick or Jason. He's a true detective and intellectual.

.........who learned his skills from Bruce

he potentially could be smarter than him. but he never ever will in comics. and besides Bats knows eons more knowledge than him.besides what could he possibly do. And NW is quite smart. always has been. but i'd say in the end Bats wins cause he'd come running in with his batjet and annihilate his proteges

Originally posted by fsufan89
.........who learned his skills from Bruce

Originally posted by Superherovandal
he potentially could be smarter than him. but he never ever will in comics. and besides Bats knows eons more knowledge than him.

agreed bats has been doin this since tim was in diapers

Originally posted by Superherovandal
he potentially could be smarter than him. but he never ever will in comics. and besides Bats knows eons more knowledge than him.besides what could he possibly do. And NW is quite smart. always has been. but i'd say in the end Bats wins cause he'd come running in with his batjet and annihilate his proteges

yeah but he never will in actual comics. and anywho that was a robin comic anyways. thats like she-hulk in her comics she beats thanos but actually she never could.

Originally posted by Darth Macabre
Robin is smarter than Bruce,

😑

Originally posted by braz
😑

Example: Wow, you think Tim has more potential to be knowledgeable than Bruce is idiotic.....As for the fight....

Originally posted by Darth Macabre
What are you laughing at? Bruce himself has said Tim is smarter than him.

I think you mean Bruce has indicated that Tim has the potential to become an even greater detective than himself 😐

Bats 6-7/10

Bruce is still smarter and more skilled than either of these two

Originally posted by Grimm22
I think you mean Bruce has indicated that Tim has the potential to become an even greater detective than himself 😐

Bats 6-7/10

Bruce is still smarter and more skilled than either of these two

Bruce is more knowledgeable, absolutely...But Tim has the potential to be better (smarter).

Originally posted by Grimm22
I think you mean Bruce has indicated that Tim has the potential to become an even greater detective than himself 😐

Bats 6-7/10

Bruce is still smarter and more skilled than either of these two

but at the same time?
i duno
i could see it going to the latter