Batdude's Tourney Discussion Thread

Started by DarkCrawler144 pages

I think so.

The DigiScoob/branDarth match starts at Sunday, doesn't it?

Nope. You have till midnight tonight PR (thursday eastern time) 😖hifty:

eh. I was thinking monday night? (since most matches start on sunday coughfreakingdelayscough and end Sat. night)

Originally posted by Blair Wind
Nope. You have till midnight tonight PR (thursday eastern time) 😖hifty:

eh. I was thinking monday night? (since most matches start on sunday coughfreakingdelayscough and end Sat. night)

monday night at midnight est? works for me...

Originally posted by pr1983
its cool... i'm just curious is all, i don't mean to overstep any boundaries by it... i just want to be 100% sure what im up against...

it was an open question... my knowledge, admittedly, of black alice and keeper is a tad limited, so people who'd know better than i would, would better be able to judge whether the characters are doing stuff they shouldnt be...

as judges, if you guys feel the need to respond, thats fine, honestly it is, i wasnt asking for hints or help, i just wanted to know whether certain things are legal, nothing more... 🙂

👆

if it deals with legalities, or contested opinions about how a character is used you should raise the questions (demand proof) in the battle, or ask bats directly.

i KNOW what you were getting at. sometimes those kinds of discussions simply lead to more than was actually intended. 🙂

no worries, and certainly no problems with you or sol. 😄

Originally posted by leonidas
👆

if it deals with legalities, or contested opinions about how a character is used you should raise the questions (demand proof) in the battle, or ask bats directly.

i KNOW what you were getting at. sometimes those kinds of discussions simply lead to more than was actually intended. 🙂

no worries, and certainly no problems with you or sol. 😄

i only have ten posts though... i mean, ive already used several here... 😛

😐

Originally posted by leonidas
if it deals with legalities, or contested opinions about how a character is used you should raise the questions (demand proof) in the battle, or ask bats directly.

You can't really demand proof when they're using three characters who have never met and in ways that they've never been used before.

😐

We did put out proof though.

......nice discussion. Leave it to PR/Rewmac please. 😐

Originally posted by DarkCrawler
We did put out proof though.

its not the proof im disputing, its more the case of, say, black alice has never physically met loki, and yet because keeper has, she was able to take his powers... its stuff like that i just want to double check...

(if youve shown that its valid, my bad, must've missed it)

We showed her taking magic powers without physically meeting them too...at least Blair Wind showed it in his post.

Originally posted by DarkCrawler
We showed her taking magic powers without physically meeting them too...at least Blair Wind showed it in his post.

i'll go look, my bad...

Question, why are we all assuming that Odin and Zeus are the "standard" for a skyfather? Unless I'm mistaken, Mephisto is a skyfather level character also(and probably has more appearances than the rest), and some of the stuff being done at this point is arguably on par with him IMO.

i've been through and around for almost all this thread. can someone point out where it was stated by bats that powermeshing can take characters to any level below SKYFATHER . . .?

I don't think Memphisto counts as a Skyfather. Silver Surfer etc. has challenged him in his own realm. Besides, he isn't a leading member of his own pantheon either. He's just ruler of his own dimension, Dormammu is too and he isn't Skyfather.

Originally posted by leonidas
i've been through and around for almost all this thread. can someone point out where it was stated by bats that powermeshing can take characters to any level below SKYFATHER . . .?

It was a while ago .... too many pages to go raking through to find it .... and it may have even been in one of the draft threads.

😐

And Odin >>>>> Mephisto

Most of the time anyway .... once or twice Mephisto has been shown at Galactus level.

Why is there all this Skyfather talk? Odin was never the tourney limit. Thanos is.

Still, I'd really love to figure out what the hell the exact rules are on meshing...because it has a ton of pertinence to our team's future battles.

Originally posted by DigiMark007
Why is there all this Skyfather talk? Odin was never the tourney limit. Thanos is.

Still, I'd really love to figure out what the hell the exact rules are on meshing...because it has a ton of pertinence to our team's future battles.


Thanos is the limit for the individual characters, but batdude said that power meshing could go higher(I believe his exact words were to the effect of "power meshing is ok as long as it doesn't reach skyfather level".

But my point is, that Odin is the TOP skyfather, so he's hardly a good gauge in that department. It's kind of like putting the cap at herald level, and then trying to defend Firelord because he's not as powerful as the Silver Surfer.

No one loves Firelord .... 🙁

problem with the meshing<skyfather is:

WHAT is skyfather? do we use only high showings to decide . . .? seems a pretty arbitrary and debateable ceiling . . . 😬