Originally posted by batdude123
No to Mangog...and...
No to AS Superman.
Sorry, but he only has five appearances in comics. We also really haven't seen what he's fully capable of either.... so I'm saying no. 😬
Uhh...I'm pretty sure that you OK'd that pick in PM before? 😕
And amount of appearences should not effect it when he has not shown anything that would indicate him to be above Thanos, and when he in fact did already show a strength limit (whereas Thanos hasn't).
You gotta ban the Fallen One too, then. He has only 4 appearences. And Earth X Absorbing Man. He has like three. And Despero, considering that the new Despero with superstrength has like 7 appearences at best. And Vulcan too, 10 at max.
Sorry, I just consider it to be unfair for him to be banned because of speculations of his powers. 3x Superman doesn't make him above Thanos, and he has shown a limit in his strength.
Actually, I'll side with DC here. AS Supes has more appearences than EX AM and Fallen One...probably combined. So either those 2 need banned, or AS Supes should be allowed.
If it's for power-based reasons, then fine. Otherwise, I just want uniform decisions here so that no one can complain about a lack of continuity between decisions.
...but for the record, we also asked about Mangog and BD didn't commmit either way, since he realized he was close to being too powerful.
Originally posted by DarkCrawler
Yeah, I'm sorry, we are not going to be the only ones whose character gets banned just because he doesn't have a set amount of appearences. 😬
don't blame you. the banning seems a little . . . helter-skelter. bats hasn't really taken part in any of these discussions, that makes it tougher.
Originally posted by DarkCrawler
Uhh...I'm pretty sure that you OK'd that pick in PM before? 😕And amount of appearences should not effect it when he has not shown anything that would indicate him to be above Thanos, and when he in fact did already show a strength limit (whereas Thanos hasn't).
You gotta ban the Fallen One too, then. He has only 4 appearences. And Earth X Absorbing Man. He has like three. And Despero, considering that the new Despero with superstrength has like 7 appearences at best. And Vulcan too, 10 at max.
Sorry, I just consider it to be unfair for him to be banned because of speculations of his powers. 3x Superman doesn't make him above Thanos, and he has shown a limit in his strength.
Um... I just told pr "no" to Darwin being allowed w/ Vulcan for this tourney. I also haven't made a judgement on EX AM either.
And I really didn't think about it 'til now, but you have a point about Fallen One...
No to Darwin with Vulcan, but Vulcan himself also has very little amount of appearences. Not much more then AS Superman.
Yet, none of the characters previously mentioned have shown NOTHING that would put them above Thanos. Nada. Zilch.
I don't think you understand it...if we start using stuff that hasn't been in comics, we would obviously be laughed away from the thread. Why would we use something that the character has never displayed? 😬
Originally posted by DarkCrawler
No to Darwin with Vulcan, but Vulcan himself also has very little amount of appearences. Not much more then AS Superman.Yet, none of the characters previously mentioned have shown NOTHING that would put them above Thanos. Nada. Zilch.
I don't think you understand it...if we start using stuff that hasn't been in comics, we would obviously be laughed away from the thread. Why would we use something that the character has never displayed? 😬
I never thought about it, but Superman's over exposure to the sun COULD prove to be a weakness for him.... MEH!!!
I'll allow him.
However, the the judgement on EX AM is still pending...