Other then blending around the edges of your render, your sig is fine. And I did lesson to what she said, I simply don't agree. I have no problem with cirticism, as long as it is presented as an opinion and not fact. How it works is, someone posts their opinion, and then I have the choice to ethier agree or dissagree with them. The style and technique that Lana and many others use is simply not to my taste.
Originally posted by Vinny Valentine
Eclipso. I have you ignored, but when I saw Lana's posts, I had to jump in. I have to put this in here:You're just getting rated by idiots who can't rate. No offense to them.
Lana is [b]THE
best signature maker on the forum. Just because little 13 year olds, or you get the occasional 8.... Doesn't make it a good sig, it just makes it appealing to little kids.Take her advice, it's true. You could make better sigantures.'
Although, you're right... It's just the opinion of us experianced Sig makers who have been doing it for a long time now. [/B]
Vinny, now I am going to jump in.
I rate his work but that does not make me an idiot, nor the rest. I have seen a LOT of bad sigs that people gush over. Eclipos are NOT as bad as you make them out to be. Your the biggest idiot on this whole forum and I dont care if I get reported or not. Its insane how people go this crazy over sigs. Yes what lana said is true, her sigs are awesome. And there are a lot of other talented sig makers here. But its Eclipso's art and he is expressing him self through it. Lana does her work in her own way, same with every artist. If Eclipso is happy shut up and let him be. You already got in trouble for starting shit with him.
Secondly, speaking over 13 year olds your the closest thing to it 🙄
Originally posted by Raven Guardia
Vinny, now I am going to jump in.I rate his work but that does not make me an idiot, nor the rest. I have seen a LOT of bad sigs that people gush over. Eclipos are NOT as bad as you make them out to be. Your the biggest idiot on this whole forum and I dont care if I get reported or not. Its insane how people go this crazy over sigs. Yes what lana said is true, her sigs are awesome. And there are a lot of other talented sig makers here. But its Eclipso's art and he is expressing him self through it. Lana does her work in her own way, same with every artist. If Eclipso is happy shut up and let him be. You already got in trouble for starting shit with him.
Secondly, speaking over 13 year olds your the closest thing to it 🙄
Child, don't get involved in something when you know **** all about it. I know what a good signature is, and he makes an average signature. The fact he uses the same style over and over again is what makes them go just slightly below average. I'm the biggest idiot on this forum? You don't even know what you're talking about.
I gave him tips on how to improve, and thats what I did. The real fact is, most people who rate his signatures in the Sig Rating thread ARE 13. It's not a viable place to get ratings, unless an experienced signature maker rates them. Also, if you honestly think I act 13, then you don't pay much attention to me.
By the way, I didn't start shit with him. Don't blindly post when you don't know what you're talking about.
Most people agree that I am very good at rating signatures, and knowing what a good signature is. He may have his own style, but that doesn't make it a good signature. He may think it is, and some may... But having a signature you like yourself, and one that is generally great and worth 8/9 | 10 ratings are much different from each other.
Am I harsh? Yes. But, because of my harshness, I've helped many people make better signatures. I've had a very decent amount of members PM me for signature advice and help.
Once again, dont' blindly post something so stupid when you know NONE of the facts of what you're talking about, now know me.
Sorry for taking this off topic, had to explain it for Ms Pissy
Okey, everyone, shut up! Don't start an arguement please!
Main point:
Eclipso, you don't have to accept the styles that Lana is telling you, but you should go like "Okey, thanks for the tips Alana" And then you choose whether to use those tips or not. Really, don't get angry, but in my opinion you don't take criticism really well and thats why you acted so offended. =D Secondly, Vinny, it doesn't matter what signatures she makes, she makes what signature she likes. We can only advise her on how to improve, we can't force her to do it. If she likes what she does, then it's no problem. Raven Guardia, have I ever encountered you on the forum before? Your name sounds familiar.
Originally posted by Eclipso
Vinny you have been told by more then one mod about bashing and trolling in my thread.This is for giving an opinion on my sigs, you did this a few pages back and was warned for trolling. Post your ciritcisim on the current sig once and thats all. Thats how a sig thread works.
I was NOT Warned for anything. I was asked to stay on topic. Nor was I trolling or Bashing, I was defending myself against a blindside attack that had nothing to do with anything here.
Hell, I came here just to see your new signature and check it out.. See if you improved at all, and I saw that shit. Now I'm in a bad mood again.
-Leaves.
Originally posted by Vinny Valentine
Child, don't get involved in something when you know **** all about it. I know what a good signature is, and he makes an average signature. The fact he uses the same style over and over again is what makes them go just slightly below average. I'm the biggest idiot on this forum? You don't even know what you're talking about.I gave him tips on how to improve, and thats what I did. The real fact is, most people who rate his signatures in the Sig Rating thread ARE 13. It's not a viable place to get ratings, unless an experienced signature maker rates them. Also, if you honestly think I act 13, then you don't pay much attention to me.
By the way, I didn't start shit with him. Don't blindly post when you don't know what you're talking about.
Most people agree that I am very good at rating signatures, and knowing what a good signature is. He may have his own style, but that doesn't make it a good signature. He may think it is, and some may... But having a signature you like yourself, and one that is generally great and worth 8/9 | 10 ratings are much different from each other.
Am I harsh? Yes. But, because of my harshness, I've helped many people make better signatures. I've had a very decent amount of members PM me for signature advice and help.
Once again, dont' blindly post something so stupid when you know NONE of the facts of what you're talking about, now know me.
[b]Sorry for taking this off topic, had to explain it for Ms Pissy
[/B]
omfg!
leave him alone, GET OFF IT ALREADY!
He likes his sigs the way they are. He told you that. If he doesnt want to listen to their advice he doesnt need to.
ANYWAY-
Eclipso, So are you planning on making anymore sigs soon? I have kind of run out ideas myself.
LAST POST: I PROMISE!
See what i'm saying? You take CONSTRUCTIVE criticism badly. Well, if your posting sigs here then seriously, get used to it. Taking in criticism is the way to become more skillfull in making sigs. I think I only had become better at making sigs by the crticism and tips taken from various people here.
Originally posted by Lana
Well, Vin, you really are not being nice about it, and to me it just seems like you're continuing your vendetta. And if someone flat-out says they don't want critique, then yes, you need to back off and stop pushing it. And that IS in the rules. So I would say that yes, you need to walk away and leave the thread. I am not going to allow your guys's little fight to be carried into here.
Well you've left your opinion
Originally posted by Raven Guardia
omfg!leave him alone, GET OFF IT ALREADY!
He likes his sigs the way they are. He told you that. If he doesnt want to listen to their advice he doesnt need to.
ANYWAY-
Eclipso, So are you planning on making anymore sigs soon? I have kind of run out ideas myself.
You didn't even read my post did you.
Originally posted by Eclipso
Well you've left your opinion
That was when I was pissed, the day OF being pissed.
Good try.
Originally posted by Spidervlad
LAST POST: I PROMISE!See what i'm saying? You take CONSTRUCTIVE criticism badly. Well, if your posting sigs here then seriously, get used to it. Taking in criticism is the way to become more skillfull in making sigs. I think I only had become better at making sigs by the crticism and tips taken from various people here.
Just because someone leaves criticism dosen't mean I have to agree. Different people like different things. Not everyone will like my sigs.
Originally posted by Raven Guardia
omfg!leave him alone, GET OFF IT ALREADY!
He likes his sigs the way they are. He told you that. If he doesnt want to listen to their advice he doesnt need to.
ANYWAY-
Eclipso, So are you planning on making anymore sigs soon? I have kind of run out ideas myself.
You didn't even read my post did you.
Originally posted by Eclipso
Well you've left your opinion
That was when I was pissed, the day OF being pissed.
Good try.
Okay, number one, EVERYONE STOP THE ****ING ARGUING NOW.
Number two, Eclipso, if you're going to accuse someone of something, know what you're talking about. Spidervlad was not in ANY way trolling.
Now honestly, I'm sick to death of this constant bickering. It had better not start again. I've given far too many chances and am at the end of my patience. Vinny, just stay out of Eclipso's thread, and Eclipso, don't reply to someone if you have a problem with them. I have told both of you this already. Do not make me say it again.
Originally posted by Eclipso
This isn't the off topic forum. This thread is only for commenting on my sigs. Anything else is spam.
I would like you to learn what spam is before you go around saying something is spam, because no, technically it isn't.
Seriously, I'm going to be giving out warnings in about 5 seconds if this BS does not get dropped. And this goes for all of you who are currently bickering.