Thorinn VS. Quickshot

Thorinn vs. Quickshot

Judge: Artemis1860

Render: Link

Criteria: No larger than 540x200 and 50kb

Deadline: January 3rd 6:19pm (GMT-6 timezone) aka. 96 hours from thread start (roughly, normally I give 72, but extra time due to new years)

You may begin. 😄

Links a girl? ermm

Originally posted by Thorinn
Links a girl? ermm

rofl, what's sad, is it actually took me a minute to understand what you meant.

And no, Link isn't, but this is a link, as in url.

I thought it was better than "pink elf"

😂

I'll get started in a day.

lol. alright, sweet. 😄

Any specific name or anything?

Nope. Just be as creative as possible.

my entry

Originally posted by quickshot
my entry

😂

Suckup. 😛 😉

*steals render*

Originally posted by masterkit
😂

Suckup. 😛 😉

*steals render*

😆

i only chose Artemis's name as it hardly suited me

Originally posted by quickshot
my entry

nice thumbsup however brightness loses detail

Entree. 😮‍💨

Quickshot's Entry:

+ Color works well with the render
+ Nice border
+ Text has good placement and is readable
- Brightness washed out the render a bit, though it added a softness that seems to go well with the sig.

Thorinn's Entry:

+ Nice background for the most part (though if you stare at it long enough it looks a bit like someones bare butt, just blurred. 😕 )
+ Colors showed the render in more detail.
- Render Placement. Needed to be a little lower, as her one eyebrow is cut off and it makes it look odd.
- Top and bottom only border kinda makes it look like a movie, but needed to be at least a little thinner. The eyes are drawn to the border before anything else.
- Text, though it fits into the sig well, it fits too well, half of it is kinda hard to make out.

Damn you guys made this hard. Honestly, I think both sigs are amazing, I couldn't give an actual judgement until just now when I typed out all the good and bad of the sigs.

I must declare the victor... quickshot!

there is nothing wrong with the top/bottom border lookmhm

I love this render

I must make more sigs.

Originally posted by masterkit
I love this render

I must make more sigs.

same, I may have to make a sig with it myself. rofl. I like yours btw.

Originally posted by BakaXero
there is nothing wrong with the top/bottom border lookmhm

Originally posted by Artemis1860
same, I may have to make a sig with it myself. rofl. I like yours btw.

thanx

Right now i'm turning her into a dark elf. 😄

Originally posted by masterkit
thanx

Right now i'm turning her into a dark elf. 😄

sweet. I'm actually making a sig with her myself, which is odd, as I don't often make girly sigs.

And to Baka and TOH. I never said there was anything wrong with it normally. But in this case with this render and that sig, it does not work in my opinion and experience.