Okay guys.
People are perfectly free to disagree with a judgment. Frankly, I disagree with the judgment of this duel myself.
So I shall say three things.
1) Like everything else in life, you cannot expect everyone to agree with you. And this goes for all parties.
2) If you are going to disagree, be polite about it.
3) It's a goddamn sig duel and not that big a deal, and none of the dissenting comments in this thread are bashing and thus not against the rules. If you're getting bent out of shape from something in a duel, I think you need to back away from the computer and rethink your priorities.
So certain parties need to lighten up and calm down, and others need to be a bit nicer.