Maul and Qui-Gon pwn. Maul alone could do this: In TPM he faught Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan two on one and t was pretty much a stalemate until the last two seconds. That was when he wasn't at his full strength. TPM Obi-Wan and Qui-Gon > AOTC Obi-Wan and Anakin. Maul'd take them. But with Qui-Gin on his side? Qui-Gon takes Obi-Wan while Maul pwns Anakin.
I don't know.
Maul would definately make this duel long, as he is still likely more skilled (and he is physically more powerful and trained) than either opponent. But, obviously, Obi-Wan has increased his skills by a decade's worth of training and is more powerful than his TPM opponent. And, I've argued before, AotC Anakin is at least AotC Obi-Wan's equal in sheer swordsmanship and ability (though the mental and tactical advantage and experience is still in Obi-Wan's favor by a considerable amount) - as shown when he was the one giving Count Dooku a noteworthy bit of difficulty in AotC, according to the novelization, the databank, and several other sources.
However, Anakin is more physically powerful than Qui-Gon (which was one of Qui-Gon's major disadvantages). I'd say that if the two of them worked together (which they are capable of doing) they'd win this fight - albeit with difficulty. Otherwise, I'd say Maul wins with moderate difficulty.
Maul and Qui-Gon would probably win, but you seem to forget that Anakin and Obi-Wan spent 10 years together, they know each others moves well, while on the other side Maul and Qui-Gon wouldn't be a good team, they don't know each aether and they would have a hard time working together, because of Mauls double bladed saber. If OBi and Anakin fight with smart tactics, they could win, but Anakin is the weak link here, he can be easily provoked and therefore loses hes calm and fights reclesly.
I agree. But I do think that this kind of battle will force it into a 1 on 1 on both sides, it is highly likley, and that will bring Qui-Gon and Maul to a quick victory.
I do however, think that neither Qui nor Maul is going to have an easy time against Anakin, being very dangerous when fighting with all his strenght (so that even Dooku had to fight very concentrated). But M and Q win...
AOTC Kenobi and AOTC Anakin win.
AOTC Kenobi would take on Maul, while AOTC Anakin would take on qui gon, it would be a long fight, but in the end AOTC Anakin would win because he is so much younger, and Qui gon would get tired out. After that AOTC Anakin and Kenobi would double team on maul, and kill him.
Originally posted by Darth_noodleLol he would win because "he is so much younger"? Then i guess luke skywalker as of TESB would OWN vader because he is "far younger".
AOTC Kenobi and AOTC Anakin win.AOTC Kenobi would take on Maul, while AOTC Anakin would take on qui gon, it would be a long fight, but in the end AOTC Anakin would win because he is so much younger, and Qui gon would get tired out. After that AOTC Anakin and Kenobi would double team on maul, and kill him.
And EVERYBODY IN THIS FORUM NEEDS TO STOP ACTING LIKE MAUL IS THE BEST THING SINCE SLICE BREAD. IF HE WERE SO GREAT HE WOULD HAVE SURVIVED LONG ENOUGH TO BE IN THE SEQUEL TRILOGY BUT HE IS THE ONLY SITH TO HAVE DIED AFTER ONE MOVIE. SIDDIOUS ALL SIX MOVIES. VADER FOUR MOVIES. DOOKU TWO MOVIES. BUT MAUL ONLY ONE MOVIE.
Originally posted by GahLakTus
Lol he would win because "he is so much younger"? Then i guess luke skywalker as of TESB would OWN vader because he is "far younger".
Ok, seriouslly, you need to shut up and learn how to read. Maybe you should go back to first grade, they might actually teach you something!
I said that AOTC Anakin would own qui gon because he has a far greater stamina than qui gon does. Did you see how Maul got qui gon tired so quick? thats the same thing that would happen if AOTC Anakin fought qui gon.
Originally posted by Darth_noodleI think your the one who needs to learn how to read seeing that you couldn't even read that i stated mace is superior to vader in saber combat, or the fact that i said i DO have a life and clearly elaborated how.
Ok, seriouslly, you need to shut up and learn how to read. Maybe you should go back to first grade, they might actually teach you something!
If i cant read your pathetic arguements, its most likely its because you don't make sense
Originally posted by Darth_noodleExactly, and TESB luke skywalker has MORE stamina than vader which you claim is a shitty ass weak sith lord, so why didn't he defeat him as of TESB?
I said that AOTC Anakin would own qui gon because he has a far greater stamina than qui gon does. Did you see how Maul got qui gon tired so quick? thats the same thing that would happen if AOTC Anakin fought qui gon.
Yoda is 800 friggin years old, yet he wasn't tired when fighting dooku or palpatine.
Originally posted by GahLakTus
I think your the one who needs to learn how to read seeing that you couldn't even read that i stated mace is superior to vader in saber combat, or the fact that i said i DO have a life and clearly elaborated how.If i cant read your pathetic arguements, its most likely its because you don't make sense
Exactly, and TESB luke skywalker has MORE stamina than vader which you claim is a shitty ass weak sith lord, so why didn't he defeat him as of TESB?
Yoda is 800 friggin years old, yet he wasn't tired when fighting dooku or palpatine.
Because luke did not have the experience, nor the skills to defeat vader. Stamina is only one aspect that luke has which is better than vader, vader was still the better swordsman, and force user. Use your common sense if you have any.
Originally posted by Darth_noodle
Because luke did not have the experience, nor the skills to defeat vader. Stamina is only one aspect that luke has which is better than vader, vader was still the better swordsman, and force user. Use your common sense if you have any.
Lol and quigon has more experience and skill compared to AOTC anakin and you said anakin would win because he has more stamina.
Now your contradicting yourself by saying it involves other aspect like skill and experience.
Oh and prove lukes stamina is greater than vader seeing how he got so tired in TESB despite vader merely toying with him.
Hell yoda who is 800 years old wasnt tired during his duel with palpatine, somebody much younger.
This is ridiculous, Maul beat te Jedi that was referred to as "the Order's finest swordsman" (Anoon Bondara), he took out all of Black Sun at once, and he took on Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan at the same time and held his own, and this was with an injured ankle. Unless Kenobi gets lucky again, Maul has him down good. And seeing as this is in the Geonosian Hanger, where there are no holes in the floor or rivers of lava, I don't see how Kenobi could get lucky. As for Anakin and Qui-Gon, age doesn't mean sh*t, Vader owned Luke in ESB, Dooku whooped Kenobi's ass and Anakin's ass and he is more than twice as old as either of them. Plus look at Yoda. Qui-Gon's lightsaber instructor said Qui-Gon was the best swordsman he'd seen in over 400 years. Qui-Gon was supposed to be one of the best swordsmen in the TPM Jedi Order. Anakin is good, but by AOTC he isn't one of the best yet. Plus, Anakin's more likely than not to get cocky right away and get f*cked up quickly, like he did against Dooku. Jinn takes him out.