Originally posted by ExtraMision5555
Oh okay, bat told me to post my conclusion jhere? im still not completely sure where he wanted me to cast my vote since the poll is closed? but im ready to vote, anyways, ill clear it up with him. BTW its over right?
Yeah. And so are you a judge? Because ignore what I said if you are one...judges are free to post their comments/analyses/etc.
Originally posted by DigiMark007
PM? Ok, cool. I'd love to hear her general thoughts about the fight as well...but either way's fine....
So:
Poll - Bran/Goober
ExtraMission - Digi/Scoob
Lethal - Scoob/Digi
Oh I just explained that I wasn't fully convinced of some of the others teams plans and with you guys collaboration of adding you characters together it kinda just blew the others out of the water.tongue12
Okay. I read over the posts again (a while ago but I had stuff to do) and have deliberated.
First off, I'll say that I think both teams were very creative and persuasive in their initial write-ups. I liked bran/goober's plan - it made good use of the characters at their disposal in imaginative ways. However it seemed like Scoobs/Digi had basically prepared a stratagem tailor-made for countering anything in bran/goober's plans. Incredible foresight or dumb luck? Either way the manner in which their opening strategy shattered bran/goober's put their team in an unenviable position of being on the defensive from the get-go.
However it did seem the defense was largely based around trying to discredit the abilities. I would have liked to see them at least try and counter based on what was put forward, but it's understandable considering the opening posts. I feel that Digi/Scoobs did defend the reasoning behind their strategy well. And as both teams did rely on a degree of supposition, I allowed a bit of leeway on either side.
So overall I have to say I think Digi/Scoobs came out on top in this match and have to give my vote to them.
N.B. the fact that darthgoober had to do most all of the debate himself also probably didn't help - and I'd commend him on debating very well alone against two as versed as Scoobs and Digi.
Originally posted by xmarksthespot
Okay. I read over the posts again (a while ago but I had stuff to do) and have deliberated.First off, I'll say that I think both teams were very creative and persuasive in their initial write-ups. I liked bran/goober's plan - it made good use of the characters at their disposal in imaginative ways. However it seemed like Scoobs/Digi had basically prepared a stratagem tailor-made for countering anything in bran/goober's plans. Incredible foresight or dumb luck? Either way the manner in which their opening strategy shattered bran/goober's put their team in an unenviable position of being on the defensive from the get-go.
However it did seem the defense was largely based around trying to discredit the abilities. I would have liked to see them at least try and counter based on what was put forward, but it's understandable considering the opening posts. I feel that Digi/Scoobs did defend the reasoning behind their strategy well. And as both teams did rely on a degree of supposition, I allowed a bit of leeway on either side.
So overall I have to say I think Digi/Scoobs came out on top in this match and have to give my vote to them.
N.B. the fact that darthgoober had to do most all of the debate himself also probably didn't help - and I'd commend him on debating very well alone against two as versed as Scoobs and Digi.
You shuold be my speaker or something
Lol
This is essentially what i was thinking, and ide say the ultimate decideing factor of this thread was:
I feel that Digi/Scoobs did defend the reasoning behind their strategy well. And as both teams did rely on a degree of supposition, I allowed a bit of leeway on either side.
I did the same, and with that said, Digi and scoob defended thier strategy very soundly, and perhaps protheticly it was indeed almost tailored for thier offense.
Thats basicly a better version than my vauge post above. And why i voted how i did.
Thankyou xmarks 🙂
Thanks to all the judges. It's appreciated greatly guys....not just voting for us, but reading through everything and taking the time to make a reasoned opinion. 👆
And good match to bran/goober. In my mind, you could have easily won this tourney. We prepped for you guys for an uber-long time, simply because your team is one of the hardest to plan for, and also among the most powerful.
Kudos on a good tourney showing.
Originally posted by xmarksthespotYa, I know. Darth did well though...
N.B. the fact that darthgoober had to do most all of the debate himself also probably didn't help - and I'd commend him on debating very well alone against two as versed as Scoobs and Digi.
I have had some problems, or I would have posted my retort.
I was actually going to take about a month or so off... but I came to congradualate Digi/Scoobs.
Also, sorry Darth about not posting more than once (wow???). I know you wanted to win, and I let you down.
I'll try to do better in my next tourney.
Well... I did shitty on this one (let myself down as well)...
Anyway, good luck in the final Digi and Scoobs. Hope you win this b*tch.
Originally posted by Badabing
I hope everything's okay Bran.
Originally posted by DigiMark007I'm a big boy... I'll be OK... just won't be on as much.
Yeah, no hard feelings to bran. Hope everything turns out well....but yeah, goober did a great job, and my conversations with him in PMs only made me more impressed.
Anyway, I personally think Darth is the best debator in this thing (no offense, or anything). He is certainly impressive, and he came up with the prep and battle plans. Who do you think picked our characters? I knew really nothing about AM/UX (just have the comics) to be honest... and I still have no god damn clue who SA is.
I would have went for Surfer...
Anyway, sorry to Darth, and good job to Digi/Scoobs again.