Magneto and Storm versus Human Torch and Iceman!

Started by masterbruce5 pages
Originally posted by jrodslam
No fair. If Mags can get help from Sentinels, why cant Torch get help from Reed. That IS his brother-in-law.

Magneto is using the sentinels as weapons, ie the Sentinels are not considered allies, but rather tools. It's Magneto's powerset to control high tech weaponry...thus using Sentinels is one of Magneto's powers.

Originally posted by masterbruce
Bobby controls thermal energy.

Magneto controls Electrogmagnetic energy, which would include thermal energy.

Magneto >>> Iceman

Lol, control over energy is control over energy it doesn't matter the "type" with these two individuals.

Bobby wins, he has frozen "laser" beams before, top that!

Originally posted by Soleran
Lol, control over energy is control over energy it doesn't matter the "type" with these two individuals.

Bobby wins, he has frozen "laser" beams before, top that!

control over energy is not all the same across the board

Magneto's control of electromagnetic energy encompasses far more forms of energy than Bobby's limited control of thermal energy.

Originally posted by Soleran

Bobby wins, he has frozen "laser" beams before, top that!

can't top some ignorant writer's idea of science.

Does this guy look like he's someone to be messed with?

Originally posted by masterbruce
control over energy is not all the same across the board

Magneto's control of electromagnetic energy encompasses far more forms of energy than Bobby's limited control of thermal energy.

Kinetic energy, it's kinetic energy even if it is "thermal" energy everything in "motion" generates heat so it's a none issue. Bobby sucks Magento dry or any number of other things.

Originally posted by masterbruce
can't top some ignorant writer's idea of science.

It still happened, comic scinece isn't the same as Real world obviously, Magento still loses.

Originally posted by masterbruce
Magneto is using the sentinels as weapons, ie the Sentinels are not considered allies, but rather tools. It's Magneto's powerset to control high tech weaponry...thus using Sentinels is one of Magneto's powers.

Im not buying that mb. Mags is using the sentinels as wepons, so why cant Torch use one of Reeds toys for a weapon?

Mags powerset is to control high tech weaponry? I thought it was just to control metal? Him taking control of a sentinel and just tossing it is one thing, but using it to where its shooting beams and other parts of its arsenal IS actually using it as an ally.

Originally posted by jrodslam
Im not buying that mb. Mags is using the sentinels as wepons, so why cant Torch use one of Reeds toys for a weapon?

Mags powerset is to control high tech weaponry? I thought it was just to control metal? Him taking control of a sentinel and just tossing it is one thing, but using it to where its shooting beams and other parts of its arsenal IS actually using it as an ally.

actually, If Johnny wanted to use Reed's weapons...that's fair game as far as prep goes, but he can't ask Reed for help.

Magneto has taken control of Sentinels in comics before, quite easily I might add.

Originally posted by masterbruce

Does this guy look like he's someone to be messed with?

He looks like he's either about to explode or start a political party.

Originally posted by Soleran
Kinetic energy, it's kinetic energy even if it is "thermal" energy everything in "motion" generates heat so it's a none issue. Bobby sucks Magento dry or any number of other things.

It still happened, comic scinece isn't the same as Real world obviously, Magento still loses.

Magneto doesn't shoot lasers...so I don't see how Iceman freezing lasers will help him.

Originally posted by Symmetric Chaos
He looks like he's either about to explode or start a political party.

no, actually he looks enraged and about to bring a can of whoopass on anyone dumb enough to be in his way.

How are they going to kill Bobby?

Seriously he would solo the field if he had the mind to.

Originally posted by masterbruce
no, actually he looks enraged and about to bring a can of whoopass on anyone dumb enough to be in his way.

So he's starting a political party then?

Originally posted by masterbruce
Magneto doesn't shoot lasers...so I don't see how Iceman freezing lasers will help him.

Uh, molecules in motion generate heat due to friction, blah blah blah I'm not trying to make this scientific.

Kinetic energy is greater then the "magentic" energy available for Magneto.

Get em Bobby!!!🤘

Originally posted by Symmetric Chaos

Seriously he would solo the field if he had the mind to.

Magneto regularly solos XMen, which includes Bobby.

I have never seen Bobby solo a group of powerful foes of Magneto's level.

Which comics are you reading where Bobby is this uberpower?

Originally posted by jrodslam
Get em Bobby!!!🤘

LOL...Bobby defeats Magneto by building a slip n slide. Magneto prob wouldn't slip if say .... he was flying like he usually does.

Originally posted by masterbruce
Magneto regularly solos XMen, which includes Bobby.

I have never seen Bobby solo a group of powerful foes of Magneto's level.

Which comics are you reading where Bobby is this uberpower?

Basicly it's just a time thing. There isn't much that anyone there can do to kill him so eventually he'll just be the only one left standing.

Either that or he'll stalemate against Magneto's shields.

I agree with bruce on this one, magneto is ruthless and a genius, bobby is immature, and has never been shown to tap into his full potential (which is pretty much endless)

Going by greatest feats magneto > bobby
Going by top potential bobby > magneto

In ten minutes Bobby would have his conciousness spread across the NYC. He'd be unkillable.