Originally posted by Validus
It's not being stubborn when that was the result of the vote.Quite frankly, any character who gets beaten by a shrinking GL bubble should be lucky to be considered Mid Herald.
He was in Trans, and the talk was to move him to Mid, so without a ton of votes counted, yes, High Herald was a "compromise" since he was still moving down some. I wasn't pretending that it was the end of the discussion, just a first step, at which point possibly others would be made.
And yeah, the bubble thing, but he's solo'd JLA rosters before, and has psychotic durability. Are we sure it should be mid?
Originally posted by DigiMark007
He was in Trans, and the talk was to move him to Mid, so without a ton of votes counted, yes, High Herald was a "compromise" since he was still moving down some. I wasn't pretending that it was the end of the discussion, just a first step, at which point possibly others would be made.And yeah, the bubble thing, but he's solo'd JLA rosters before, and has psychotic durability. Are we sure it should be mid?
And that was a different Shaggy man. Currently there are now three versions of the shaggy man. Brainless Shaggy, General Eiling Shaggy, and the new Shaggy man.
Originally posted by DigiMark007
He was in Trans, and the talk was to move him to Mid, so without a ton of votes counted, yes, High Herald was a "compromise" since he was still moving down some. I wasn't pretending that it was the end of the discussion, just a first step, at which point possibly others would be made.And yeah, the bubble thing, but he's solo'd JLA rosters before, and has psychotic durability. Are we sure it should be mid?
Originally posted by Validus
There were 6 people who seemed to vote to move him down which is about equal to what we usually have. The topic of High Herald never even came up.
Ok how can you count brainless shaggy man getting owned by a bubble as a way to bring down general eiling? And there is a new shaggy man as well. We need to hold up on him. Plus I don't see ANYONE in the Mid herald catagory getting a majority of wins on him. Hell he can beat most of the top tiered ones.
Originally posted by nvrbeenwthagirl
Ok how can you count brainless shaggy man getting owned by a bubble as a way to bring down general eiling? And there is a new shaggy man as well. We need to hold up on him. Plus I don't see ANYONE in the Mid herald catagory getting a majority of wins on him. Hell he can beat most of the top tiered ones.
My point as well, though I wasn't aware of the different versions until just now. Leave it to DC to royally mess with every character. Anyone with multiple versions (besides DD) I say we wait until after FC to determine. Breaking Shaggy intos multiple versions right now would lead to mass confusion.
Originally posted by nvrbeenwthagirl
Ok how can you count brainless shaggy man getting owned by a bubble as a way to bring down general eiling? And there is a new shaggy man as well. We need to hold up on him. Plus I don't see ANYONE in the Mid herald catagory getting a majority of wins on him. Hell he can beat most of the top tiered ones.
Hulk is far more impressive than General and has soloed more impressive teams yet for some reason, when people try to move him up, everyone complains about it. Meanwhile, Hercules should be Mid Herald and General at High or Trans.