Good is a point of view Anakin...wow!

😂

Chill out man 😎

Ya, I thought that sounded kinda un-chill

I'm cool, I'm cool 😎 😎 😎

I just worry when people suggest that there's actually something to be said about people who think what they're doing is ok becasue they see it as a good thing...that has no place in what's actually good and bad.

evil often operates under the general assumption that the ends justify the means.

Thats only if the ends are never reached. If they are reached, it becomes historical fact.

I was wondering when someone was gonna bring that up.

If Hitler won, then history would have favored the Allies as villains living in a corrupt, incompetent, genetically inferior, and all in all bad society.

Since we won, we tend to view Nazi society as wrong and evil. Conflicting preferences, but only one won out.

And since we all live in a society that defines evil the way we do, then from an outsider's POV, Palpatine is just Hitler on a much, much grander scale.

Originally posted by Alliance
Thats only if the ends are never reached. If they are reached, it becomes historical fact.

i will not answer to you unless you eat your humble pie from another thread

😂 I keep threads seperate.

i dont 😈

:edit" come on dude, dont make me be the bad guy

cathy the crab says "eat your humble pie alliance. yum yum"

😈

ok ill stop

Thats your problem then. 🙂

very nice sig btw, i always admired your art

...but the avi's coming off as a bit......nevermind

Thanks. 🙂 Unfortunately, sigs aren't actually real artwork. I try to make them though.

so yeah....the topic...evil.😈

queeq should this be filed in the "does good and evil exist" graveyard that is the philosophy forum? 😈

no, becuase its primarily SW.

no, its primarily "is 'good' a point of view or absolute"
palpatine being a hypothetical model.

😈

And we've derailed it and made it another Alliacne vs Ush "what is Star Wars" thread.

ill make a thread

search before you make a duplicate.

impossible

I hate this thread. But ush is right: Palps knew he was evil, that is clear from all his expressions, and he used his evil to get his way. He clearly says that he's out to make the Sith rule the universe and Sith only think about themselves. Ergo, case close.

Now, you can add SW related stuff to debate it. If it turns to points of view on good or evil I will close the thread on your OB1 butts.

Its clear form his expressions?

The only thing that shows is that Lucas thinks Palps is evil.