Anakin Skywalker (ROTS) vs Darth Vader (ESB) in Space!

Vader is as well, at least in this fight. Wouldn't you think Vader would underestimate his younger version?

Maybe 😉

Maybe, but just a little and thats a maybe and Anakin would be more arrogant, he doesn't know who Vader is and he thinks of himself the best pilot in the universe by far, which he is in his time, but Vader is on pair with him.

It could go either way...

I think Vader is better than Anakin anyway, but with a superior craft (his ship is better than Anakin's) he definately takes this.

I don't know, Advent said that Anakin has a better craft and i would say that his reflexes are betters then Vaders, but i agree that Vader is a smarter pilot.

I'm afraid Advent is wrong. Anakin does not have a better craft. She has made the mistake of assuming that because Anakin's craft is far faster in atmosphere it is far faster in space. This is not so. Yes, Anakin's craft is the faster one, but only by a small amount in space.

Vader's craft IS more advanced than Anakin's. His ship has fewer laser canons, but this is unimportant in a dogfight because a short burst from 2 OR 4 lasers canons will destroy Anakin's ship anyway. It's the same reason the A-wing, which is possibly the most dedicated dogfighter in all of SW has only two canons. Neither ship needs much firepower.

Vader's craft has better shields and armor. It's a simple byproduct of having a ship more than 20 years more advanced than your opponents.

I don't know, maybe your right, but i will wait to see, what Advents reply is and then decide who has a better chance of wining. But i sense its going to be a long argument between you two.