darthgoober's Amalgam Tournament Conformation Thread

Started by Martian_mind55 pages

As i said,everyone has a char that could stalemate him,but not outwright beat him.

Personally i'm fine with everyone having the one character that pushes it,and even then Tony is being vastly underrated.

oh, and don't forget -- show the wrong scan in a battle and you are SCREWED!!

i think that's the best safety net we have and the best guide that we have to ensure people aree confident in who they choose and what feats they decide to show (or -- maybe more importantly -- are willing to risk have shown AGAINST them in a battle . . . because if i know for a FACT that someone is over the cap, bet your ass i'll show a scan of a feat that clearly indicates said character IS over the cap. 😉 and i'd expect the same tactics to be used AGAINST me. 🙂 )

Originally posted by King_Mungi
No the main reason was in characters were getting in when they shouldn't have and people got upset.

Yet like I mentioned earlier he has gone one on one EXTENDED periods with Captain Marvel so oncwe again don't assume he doesn't have any speed. CM3 still has half the speed of Mercury

He's the cap, so why would he be banned? and when he actually took it to certain characters yes there is PIS involved and that's a fact.

and like I said, what do I think of those picks? 👇 Why no one has raised a fuzz I do not know.

Who cares if he's fought him for extended periods?He still hasn't shown any speed,and Red Hood was dancing around him.WE've only seen a lack of speed.

I never said he should be banned,just that he has beat people above him,therefore your marvel arguement is moot.Alright,Nazi hanging with Marvel who is stronger,faster and smarter is Pis.

Maybe because if everyone has a high pick it's fair,and people want to enjoy a tourney that would be fair rather then have it fall down again because people have made fuzzes where not needed...

Originally posted by leonidas
oh, and don't forget -- show the wrong scan in a battle and you are SCREWED!!

i think that's the best safety net we have and the best guide that we have to ensure people aree confident in who they choose and what feats they decide to show (or -- maybe more importantly -- are willing to risk have shown AGAINST them in a battle . . . because if i know for a FACT that someone is over the cap, bet your ass i'll show a scan of a feat that clearly indicates said character IS over the cap. 😉 and i'd expect the same tactics to be used AGAINST me. 🙂 )

exactly.people are just ******ng for no reason atm...

Originally posted by Martian_mind
Who cares if he's fought him for extended periods?He still hasn't shown any speed,and Red Hood was dancing around him.WE've only seen a lack of speed.

I never said he should be banned,just that he has beat people above him,therefore your marvel arguement is moot.Alright,Nazi hanging with Marvel who is stronger,faster and smarter is Pis.

Maybe because if everyone has a high pick it's fair,and people want to enjoy a tourney that would be fair rather then have it fall down again because people have made fuzzes where not needed...

Bad showings, compared to what we know he can do and even though you do not like it yes he did defeat Hawkman and Alan with ease. This seems to be an all new Nazi as the last one was killed in Villians United

Right and Iron Man beating Silver Srufer isn't PIS? On majority of Nazi's showings he has been shown FREQUENTLY a high match for Marvel. Why is that PIS as that is who he was intended to be, it's his other apperances in other comics that have him in low showings.

That's why there are caps, it's easy to pick over the caps it takes skill to pick the cap and debate with it. If you don't think there should be caps and people should be able to pick whoever make a seperate tourny but caps are implemented for a reason.

i think it's because -- while clear that a couple people ARE likely above caps -- everyone is CLOSE to caps. there are no egregious errors.

i really don't know cap nazi at all, but if i face mm, be damn sure i WILL know him. if mm is confident enough to pick him, well, he should be comfortable enough knowing that if i look, i won't find something to use AGAINST him in our match that will clearly show him being above caps. 🙂 is stalemating cm above caps? sounds like it might be. wonderman could hang with cm for a while as he is in thor's strength class -- or VERY close to it. should HE be banned? he also has some crazy durability feats?

wonderman is as close to cap busting as anyone. if he's allowed, then maybe nazi SHOULD be ok? i don't really know . . . 😬

Well I'll drop it as if he posts someone over the caps it will be outright banned

Yeah there are several other characters who I think should be banned.

Originally posted by King_Mungi
Yeah there are several other characters who I think should be banned.

you may have a valid point, but like i said, i think most are close enough to sorta skate by.

barely in some cases.

Originally posted by King_Mungi
Bad showings, compared to what we know he can do and even though you do not like it yes he did defeat Hawkman and Alan with ease. This seems to be an all new Nazi as the last one was killed in Villians United

Right and Iron Man beating Silver Srufer isn't PIS? On majority of Nazi's showings he has been shown FREQUENTLY a high match for Marvel. Why is that PIS as that is who he was intended to be, it's his other apperances in other comics that have him in low showings.

That's why there are caps, it's easy to pick over the caps it takes skill to pick the cap and debate with it. If you don't think there should be caps and people should be able to pick whoever make a seperate tourny but caps are implemented for a reason.

All new Nazi who was koed by a bell.....impressive...that Alan thing is just pointless as we don't know what happened whether you like it or not.

I wasn't aware you alone could say whats pis and what isn't.that alan and Hawkman thing was pis,unless you think marvel could take them down even easier.Hell,what has alan done lately OYL to show his old level?Get punked by Nazi and be useless against BA,He's hardly been that impressive.

Your not even in the tourney,and considering someone who is agreed with me,i don't think you should be telling me to do anything.If i haven't been debating with you for the last couple of pages then what have i been doing?He is below Caps,prove he's not.

oh, and was it decided how many picks we could swap out in this thread if we felt like doing so?

No idea. Better ask Bada, Digi or Goober.

Btw, Bastion would lose AT LEAST 7-8/10 against pre-extremis IM.

Ok guys check this out. I'm going to be digging up dirt on Bastion and Captain Nazi for the next 24 hours. At the end of that time, I'll announce my FINAL decision in regards to both of them. So anyone with scans involving either of them should PM them to me, to help expedite the process.

That being said, I forgot about some changes when I re did the draft list, so here's the REAL updated version(with changes in bold)...

1.Hank Pym
2.Guardian(Heather)
3.Northstar
4.Spiral
5.Tony Stark
6.Warlock
7.Vision
8.Black Knight
9.Captain Nazi
10.Abomination
11.Karate Kid
12.Bloodaxe

Draft #2

1.Indigo
2.Fixer
3.The Spot
4.Sabertooth
5.Moonstone II
6.invisible woman
7.Invincible(under consideration)
8.Colossus
9.Grail(re-pick)
10.War Machine
11.Shimmer(re-pick)
12.Executioner

Draft #3:

1.Black Panther
2.Wonderman
3.Jean Grey
4.Death's Head II
5.Sebastian Shaw
6.Sasquach
7.Cannonball
8.Bastion(re-pick)
9.Emma Frost
10.Grunge
11.?????(awaiting pick)
12.Booster Gold

executioner -- as in skurge? as in the asgardian god . . .

the limits contiue to streeetttttccccchhhhhhhhhhhhh . . .

🙂

Originally posted by leonidas
executioner -- as in skurge? as in the asgardian god . . .

the limits contiue to streeetttttccccchhhhhhhhhhhhh . . .

🙂


EXECUTIONER?!

Dude, the guys so far over the caps it's not even funny. He gave Thor a fight.

I think there's more than one Executioner. But if it's Skurge, I'm calling bullshit. 😉

Originally posted by Martian_mind
All new Nazi who was koed by a bell.....impressive...that Alan thing is just pointless as we don't know what happened whether you like it or not.

I wasn't aware you alone could say whats pis and what isn't.that alan and Hawkman thing was pis,unless you think marvel could take them down even easier.Hell,what has alan done lately OYL to show his old level?Get punked by Nazi and be useless against BA,He's hardly been that impressive.

Your not even in the tourney,and considering someone who is agreed with me,i don't think you should be telling me to do anything.If i haven't been debating with you for the last couple of pages then what have i been doing?He is below Caps,prove he's not.

I'll bite my tongue, but yes I will prove he is over the caps as I plan on making a respect thread for him most likely after the tourny is said and done as it takes awhile to compile and organize the scans like how I do with all my other respect threads. However, I will lump it into a Captain Marvel villians page as a Nazi respect thread is not the best idea.

A nazi respect thread.......that sounds so very very wrong. 😆

Btw, do you know anything about Bastion?

And is Sasquatch over?

Originally posted by TricksterPriest
A nazi respect thread.......that sounds so very very wrong. 😆

Btw, do you know anything about Bastion?

And is Sasquatch over?

as in sentinel?

and depends on how he uses him, but with the likes of other characters drafted really is there even a point of debating some drafts?

Yeah, the 'sentinel'. The guy who was the fusion of Nimrod&Mastermold. I know he's nowhere near as powerful as those and he's in the damn caps.

Originally posted by TricksterPriest
Yeah, the 'sentinel'. The guy who was the fusion of Nimrod&Mastermold. I know he's nowhere near as powerful as those and he's in the damn caps.

No sorry don't know enough of him to accurately say, but I would question his ability to look at someone causing them to become a Prime Sentinel. I don't know enough about that myself.