Wolverine versus Etrigan

Started by Dum Dum Dugan9 pages

Originally posted by Omega Vision
In comics the extent to which an enemy gets moved by an attack is based less on weight and more on relative power levels.

It's incredibly unscientific but then we're talking about comics here. Even though Spider-Man should logically be able to punch Thor ten stories into the air it isn't going to happen because of Thor's "Super-Inertia" (what I call this phenomena). If Hulk were to punch him however...


not really, heavy hitters like superman have bene hit to the moon. It weight not strength. Ones strength would have zero baring on them being BFR.

again in comics Hulk punches thor numerous times with out sending him anywere, and has done the same to wolverine as well. BFR happens very rarely in comics, comparative to when it does not occure. It has no baring on power level either, characters like wolverine hardly ever get BFR and there vastly weaker then there opponents,

Originally posted by Omega Vision
In comics the extent to which an enemy gets moved by an attack is based less on weight and more on relative power levels.

It's incredibly unscientific but then we're talking about comics here. Even though Spider-Man should logically be able to punch Thor ten stories into the air it isn't going to happen because of Thor's "Super-Inertia" (what I call this phenomena). If Hulk were to punch him however...

10 stories? I suppose. I had a similar dispute when Spider-Man flung the Hulk. I guess it has more to do with appearance and messing up peoples suspension of belief, a smaller character won't generally manhandle a stronger one except for certain circumstances. Stronger characters can resist blows better, Supes for example.

Originally posted by Dum Dum Dugan
not really, heavy hitters like superman have bene hit to the moon. It weight not strength. Ones strength would have zero baring on them being BFR.

again in comics Hulk punches thor numerous times with out sending him anywere, and has done the same to wolverine as well. BFR happens very rarely in comics, comparative to when it does not occure. It has no baring on power level either, characters like wolverine hardly ever get BFR and there vastly weaker then there opponents,

If BFR is based on power levels then Hulk and others hit Wolverine below their strength (low showing).

If BFR is based on weight (which it is really) then Hulk and others not doing it to Wolverine are still low showings.

In comics there are low showings and high showings.

. everytime brick does not bfr an opponents it a low showing......

H1 as always your logic is garbage

don't know why I even click the here bottun.......

new it would be some reiduclous statement aim towards me.

Originally posted by Dum Dum Dugan
not really, heavy hitters like superman have bene hit to the moon. It weight not strength. Ones strength would have zero baring on them being BFR.

again in comics Hulk punches thor numerous times with out sending him anywere, and has done the same to wolverine as well. BFR happens very rarely in comics, comparative to when it does not occure. It has no baring on power level either, characters like wolverine hardly ever get BFR and there vastly weaker then there opponents,

if comics stuck to actual science in that context then you would be right.

they just don't.

Lol at people using bfr for etrigan to win. Desperate

Originally posted by carver9
Lol at people using bfr for etrigan to win. Desperate

It's not like he needs it to beat Logan.

Originally posted by -Pr-
if comics stuck to actual science in that context then you would be right.

they just don't.


which is my entire point. BFR don't happen the vast majority in comics, to say that gunna happen in a fight on forum is a stretch to say the least, more or less a cop out from actually debating the topic.

Originally posted by Dum Dum Dugan
which is my entire point. BFR don't happen the vast majority in comics, to say that gunna happen in a fight on forum is a stretch to say the least, more or less a cop out from actually debating the topic.

but characters do bfr each other a lot. it's actually a staple of superman fights, for example. even hulk did it during (ugh) wwh. it does happen, and is a viable tactic.

etrigan has bfr'd people, like when he punched superman for example.

is it his most likely course of action? no. he has options as it is.

no reason he can't bfr someone, though.

Originally posted by Omega Vision
It's not like he needs it to beat Logan.

That's his only option because if he tries to fight him he is getting blitzed.

Originally posted by carver9
That's his only option because if he tries to fight him he is getting blitzed.

hard to blitz with a face full of hellfire. and a lack of a considerable speed advantage. and etc etc

how fast do you think Etrigan really is?

he squats and has short legs!!

Originally posted by -Pr-

is it his most likely course of action? no. he has options as it is.

no reason he can't bfr someone, though.

That was my arguement from the get go. They can do it, it just not a likely occurance. I just hate when people (not talking anyone in particular)uses the bfr responses, as if every highly strong/brick first move or even likely hood is to BFR anyone they fight, becuase frankly he just does not happen vast majority of the time. Still lol at H1 trying to pretend that when people don't get bfr that means brick holding back and it a low showing.

I agree he can, just not likely occurance. Not to say he even needs to.

Originally posted by King Castle
how fast do you think Etrigan really is?

he squats and has short legs!!


That describes Wolverine perfectly.

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&threadid=476393

Originally posted by carver9
That's his only option because if he tries to fight him he is getting blitzed.

I don't agree with this, this is as likely for wolverine to try as brick going for BFR. There simply not likely occurances, and to pretend they are I feel is ignoring characters histories and comics in general.

Originally posted by Starscream M
No BFR. <---- "hello, look at me!"

vs

I dont get it.

Originally posted by Starscream M
No BFR. <---- "hello, look at me!"

vs

Ummmm.....sure, ok.