Silver Surfer vs All Star Superman

Originally posted by Redatom65
Superman beats him, Allstar in the stomp

Originally posted by Priest
WRONG on both accounts ermmgrin

bump

surfer takes 7 out of ten majority. power cosmic could make superman so weak and could crush him if and when surfer felt likt it. it ends when surfer wants it to. supermans rep gets him the 3 upsets out of ten. which aint much but its something.

Originally posted by quanchi112
surfer takes 7 out of ten majority. power cosmic could make superman so weak and could crush him if and when surfer felt likt it. it ends when surfer wants it to. supermans rep gets him the 3 upsets out of ten. which aint much but its something.

This is All-Star Superman, Superman's superior in every way. This would be a VERY hard fight for Silver Surfer. I say All-Star Superman takes this 6 / 10, all close wins/loses.

Isn't All Star dying from solar radiation? Wouldn't that mean that Surfer could just take him out by bombarding him and expedite the process?

Originally posted by darthgoober
Isn't All Star dying from solar radiation? Wouldn't that mean that Surfer could just take him out by bombarding him and expedite the process?

Given that we know All-Star Superman survives....that might backfire really really badly. haermm

Originally posted by TricksterPriest
Given that we know All-Star Superman survives....that might backfire really really badly. haermm

Even if he is dying right now, we know that the solar radiation doesn't kill him. Temporal physics. The masked Superman is the future All-Star Supes. Thus, he survives the solar radiation.

Surfer might be able to kill him with the solar radiation, but it might just be like pouring TNT on a fire. Sure the fire will go out, but it will take you with it.

Originally posted by TricksterPriest
Even if he is dying right now, we know that the solar radiation doesn't kill him. Temporal physics. The masked Superman is the future All-Star Supes. Thus, he survives the solar radiation.

Originally posted by darthgoober
Has ever been established how/why he survived?

❌ The series is still on-going. But we know he survives due to the temporal physics involved. 🙂

Originally posted by TricksterPriest
❌ The series is still on-going. But we know he survives due to the temporal physics involved. 🙂

surfers power cosmic when used to its fullest it to powerful its a planet destroyer with ease. he can turn things into whataver he wants. superman goes down swinging

Originally posted by darthgoober
So he may still find a cure or way to halt/slow the process in the future right? That doesn't prove that it wouldn't work NOW. Maybe no one has ever attacked the future All Star with high concentrations of solar energy. If all we have to go on in that regard is speculation(which is bad to base an argument off of), then at present the only facts available are that Supes is dying from solar radiation and Surfer can produce that radiation in HIGH amounts. So by the actual on panel evidence we have available at this point, Surfer should probably take the majority here. If it is ever established that solar bombardment ISN'T a viable tactic then my assessment will change, but for right now that seems to be the most logical breakdown.

Seems like a very good point to me, if this can be dis proven I will stick with my original AS supes 6 / 10 if not Silver Surfer 8 / 10

Originally posted by mykke
Seems like a very good point to me, if this can be dis proven I will stick with my original AS supes 6 / 10 if not Silver Surfer 8 / 10

Originally posted by darthgoober
You mean I actually CONVINCED someone that Surfer would take the majority over a version of Supes that wasn't already inclined to believe it anyway 😱 . I don't think that's ever happened to me before...

😆 Shocking, I know. I still think Superman can take partially due to higher combat speed and the fact that I believe he can KO Surfer in a few punches.

Normal Superman is already retardedly, illogically powerful. All Star Superman takes the wankage to a whole new level.

AS Superman 8/10

surfers power cosmic is to powerful for superman it would focus on his weaknesses

No limits fallacy, hooray! Can you quantify his powers? If not, the vast uber-wankage of AS Superman takes this.

surfer using his capabilities and powers to their fullest would do whatever he wanted to superman. powercosmic is better than anything kryptonians have

Originally posted by TricksterPriest
😆 Shocking, I know. I still think Superman can take partially due to higher combat speed and the fact that I believe he can KO Surfer in a few punches.