What Do You MEAN I'm Not Going To Die

Started by Healing Artisan4 pages

What Do You MEAN I'm Not Going To Die

interesting article.

i've volunteered at a hospital for many years and currently work at a medical clinic, and these situations take place time to time.

source: http://news.yahoo.com/s/nm/20070507/od_nm/britain_spree_odd_dc_1

LONDON (Reuters) - A British man who went on a wild spending spree after doctors said he only had a short time to live wants compensation because the diagnosis was wrong and he is now healthy -- but broke.

ADVERTISEMENT

John Brandrick, 62, was diagnosed with pancreatic cancer two years ago and told that he would probably die within a year.

He quit his job, sold or gave away nearly all his possessions, stopped paying his mortgage and spent his savings dining out and going on holiday.

Brandrick was left with little more than the black suit, white shirt and red tie that he had planned to be buried in when it emerged a year later that his suspected "tumor" was no more than a non-life threatening inflammation of the pancreas.

"When they tell you you've got a limited time and everything, you do enjoy life," Brandrick, from Cornwall in the west of England, told Sky television.

"I'm really pleased that I've got a second chance in life... but if you haven't got no money after all this, which is my fault -- I spent it all -- they should pay something back."

If he can't get compensation, he is considering selling his house or suing the hospital that diagnosed him. The hospital has said that while it sympathizes with Brandrick, a review of his case showed no different diagnosis would have been made.

and on the note of cancer, i remember 2 patients who were both diagnosed with benign (doctors said to both patients that it will soon be malignant) breast cancer. the first patient began chemotherapy as soon as possible, and the patient died within 6 years. (these two patients were same age, were diagnosed around the same time, had same background/nationality and nutrition-wise both were healthy) the other patient decided that time was up and death was just around the corner. the patient did not have any chemotherapy. ironically, that patient is still living.

I kinda dont blame the guy.

He should find a good lawyer and sue for medical malpractice. Of all cancers, pancreatic cancer is almost always a death sentance, and I'm sure that the diagnosis caused a lot of stress for him and his friends and family.

Honestly, how the hell does someone **** that up?

-----

Q: What's the difference between God and doctors?

A: God doesnt think he's a doctor.

i dont blame the guy either, but honestly, doctors don't cure, they diagnose and try to treat. when diagnosing, you keep in mind an alternatative diagnosis.

i remember a few years back this nurse told me physicians tend to make misdiagnosis on cancers over 20% of the time. that was a few years back, now i dont know the statistics.

I Also remember an M.D. once telling me, "See that patient with cancer? He's living on borrowed time." I asked him, who's time? The M.D. said "his". Hence, sue his ass ...

edit

Originally posted by Quiero Mota
Honestly, how the hell does someone **** that up?

You apparently know SH*T about medicine.

We are doctors, not gods. We can be wrong. We're not to blame for someone's irrationalty.

This happens more often than you think. Doctors are not infallalbe. That doesn't mean we should lose our jobs over one faulty diagnosis (whcih isn't even the doctor's fault).

Originally posted by Alliance
You apparently know SH*T about medicine.

Apparently neither do those doctors.

Originally posted by KidRock
Apparently neither do those doctors.
Hahaha, good one.

Originally posted by Alliance
You apparently know SH*T about medicine.

We are doctors, not gods. We can be wrong. We're not to blame for someone's irrationalty.

This happens more often than you think. Doctors are not infallalbe. That doesn't mean we should lose our jobs over one faulty diagnosis (whcih isn't even the doctor's fault).


maybe dude should have gotten a second opinion.

Am I the only person that read "If he can't get compensation, he is considering selling his house or suing the hospital that diagnosed him. The hospital has said that while it sympathizes with Brandrick, a review of his case showed no different diagnosis would have been made."?

Have another board of doctors review the case (without knowing the specifics, such as it really WASN'T cancer) and ask them to give a diagnosis. If the hospital was at fault and misdiagnosed him, then yes, he should be compensated. But if the mistake was one that was unavoidable then hey, I'm sorry buddy, but too bad. You're just out of luck.

Originally posted by Alliance
You apparently know SH*T about medicine.

We are doctors, not gods. We can be wrong. We're not to blame for someone's irrationalty.

This happens more often than you think. Doctors are not infallalbe. That doesn't mean we should lose our jobs over one faulty diagnosis (whcih isn't even the doctor's fault).


You're not a doctor.

maybe he is.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
maybe he is.
Maybe he is also God himself.

Originally posted by Bardock42
Maybe he is also God himself.

doubtful. I dont think god would waste his time here.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
doubtful. I dont think god would waste his time here.
Well, but what you think hardly matters to God himself, now does it?

Originally posted by Bardock42
Well, but what you think hardly matters to God himself, now does it?

right back atcha.

Originally posted by Bardock42
Maybe he is also God himself.

He was born in 1986. He's 20. Definitely not a doctor.

Originally posted by Kinneary
He was born in 1986. He's 20. Definitely not a doctor.

Yeah, I know.

Originally posted by Kinneary
He was born in 1986. He's 20. Definitely not a doctor.

maybe he is a prodigy. like Doogie Howser and shit.

so i guess he planned on leaving his family to sort out his massive debt?

Originally posted by Schecter
so i guess he planned on leaving his family to sort out his massive debt?

Same point I would have made. What a dumbass.