1.He does better, and he doesn't need Han's help, he takes out Vader on his own.
2. He does better, he uses the Force to pinpoint the AT-AT's weakness and destroys several of them on his own.
3. He is smart enough to keep his lightsaber on him. When the Rancor attacks him he cuts thought the metal beams behind the door into Jabba's throne room, and lets the Rancor in there to kill everyone (what Luke was trying to do).
4. This would never need take place, they'd all have been eaten by the Rancor already... but he pwns them. During the Clone Wars he took out countless numbers of Battle Droids, those guard wouldn't be threatening at all. How many of them are there? 20-30? They get slaughtered.
Re: Anakin(Rots) switches places with Luke
Originally posted by playa1258
How would Rots Anakin do in the same scenerios Luke was in throughout the first trilogy.1. Attack the first death star
2. Battle of Hoth
3. Infiltrate Jabbas palace,and battle the rancor.
4. Battle on the sail barge.
I don't know if ROTS Anakin would shoot Vader down -- the one aspect that Vader didn't suffer in after Mustafar was piloting, and with twenty more years and more experience in the Force, he's possibly better than he was before.
In any case, though, ROTS Anakin is much better than Luke, so he destroys the Death Star with pathetic ease.
The Battle of Hoth would be similarly easy; he probably wouldn't get shot down, and would take out several walkers.
Since Anakin probably wouldn't decide to, for no apparent reason, entrust his weapon to a droid, he would ignite it, let the rancor out, and help it kill all the villains.
If the sail barge battle was to take place anyway, he would have no trouble winning the fight by himself. ROTS Anakin is far more powerful and skilled than Luke, who managed fine.
So, yeah. ROTS Anakin takes all of these with ease.
I think number one and four would go worse. A lot worse.
1. Anakin being greedy and cocky would try and loop behind Vader, and challenge him one on one, seeing that he went against all logic and took off after Asajj during the Clone Wars. In the mean time, Yavin would be blown to bits, and Anakin eventually shot down.
2. Battle of Hoth, he takes a few of the AT-AT's by himself, kicks some as, takes some names, etc.
3.Kicks ass, takes more names, uses the force to tame the rancor, rides it, is unnecessarily flashy, but ultimately victorious.
4. He wouldn't have the lightsaber, seeing as how he wouldn't ever let it leave his side and it would have been taken when he was captured (even thought that wouldn't have happened in the first place), so he'd be doing this without a lightsaber, and Boba would kill him.
Or:
He does have his lightsaber, he receives it, kills the thugs, jumps to the other skiffs, kills those thugs, kills Boba after a cool battle, jumps on the main barge, kills everyone, and then looks back to realize that he forgot to save Han, Chewie, and Lando, who are by this point, toast.
Originally posted by jollyjim311
I think number one and four would go worse. A [B]lot worse.1. Anakin being greedy and cocky would try and loop behind Vader, and challenge him one on one, seeing that he went against all logic and took off after Asajj during the Clone Wars. In the mean time, Yavin would be blown to bits, and Anakin eventually shot down.
2. Battle of Hoth, he takes a few of the AT-AT's by himself, kicks some as, takes some names, etc.
3.Kicks ass, takes more names, uses the force to tame the rancor, rides it, is unnecessarily flashy, but ultimately victorious.
4. He wouldn't have the lightsaber, seeing as how he wouldn't ever let it leave his side and it would have been taken when he was captured (even thought that wouldn't have happened in the first place), so he'd be doing this without a lightsaber, and Boba would kill him.
Or:
He does have his lightsaber, he receives it, kills the thugs, jumps to the other skiffs, kills those thugs, kills Boba after a cool battle, jumps on the main barge, kills everyone, and then looks back to realize that he forgot to save Han, Chewie, and Lando, who are by this point, toast. [/B]
1. You do realise that that was Anakin as a padawan. He clearly learn't from his mistake afterwards when Obi talked to him. ROTS Anakin, knowing the death star would kill them, would certainley do his job. That's like saying Anakin would try to go after every droid ship during the battle of courascant in the beginning of ROTS, instead of going to rescue the chancellor.
4. Seeing how he would pwn in 3, he wouldn't be taken to this situation. However, pretending he got captured, it would all depend on wether or not he had planned this whole thing, or if we are just picking up from the last one. (If we are, this one doesn't exist).
So it is impossible to make a statement, but since this kinda is "What happened if ROTS Anakin and Luke changed places", this IS Anakin when R2 has his lightsaber. So Anakin pwns here as well, and does BETTER than Luke. He wouldn't forget his friends, he's probably the least likely person to do that.
Padme in the arena, he didn't leave her side once.
Has saved Obi-Wan's ass 9-10 times during the clone wars. If he was as stupid to rush into action as you say, he wouldn't have time to save him either.
1. Anakin being greedy and cocky would try and loop behind Vader, and challenge him one on one, seeing that he went against all logic and took off after Asajj during the Clone Wars. In the mean time, Yavin would be blown to bits, and Anakin eventually shot down.
1. He destroys it to , Luke at this point is a World Class pilot, but he hasn't develop his Jedi senses like Anakin did. And in my opinion ROTS Anakin is the best pilot ever.
2. He does better then Luke, he doesn't get hit and destroys more AT-AT and other vehicles.
3. He kills the Rancor in a straight duel, doesn't need to run like Luke, he jumps on him and stabs him in the brain, like in the CWC, on the planet of Nalvanians.
4. He slaughters them all, even Boba Fett.
Originally posted by darthsith19
No, Vader would go down to Anakin before Anakin even starts his trench run. As soon as Vader comes and starts targeting X-Wings, Anakin goes after him - Vader got punked by Han Solo in the Falcon. Anakin would take him for sure. Then he proceeds to blow up the death star, and Biggs never dies, a few other rebel pilots are saved as well.
Vader is a superior pilot to Anakin. He lost no abilities in that area, has only gained experience, plus has a better ship.
1. He WOULD do hell of a lot better than Luke. He would probably be smarter than him and wouldn't need Han to help him with Vader.
2. He would bring down some AT-AT's and would have NEVER been shot down. Maybe he could even win the battle for the Rebels, with help though.
3/4. I think he would keep his lightsaber with him and would probably kill the rancor or tame him and terrorize the palace to save his friends.