Fumbles of the Empire

Originally posted by Alliance
Is this some strange seperatist war strategy?

Its kill them all and rearrange the landscape strategy.

What did the CIS do differently?

Originally posted by Count Makashi
Its kill them all and rearrange the landscape strategy.

Since the damn station was operational anyway...the gournd battle wasn't even needed. they should have just let the rebels land and then Alderaaned the moon. Leia, Han...all gone...Luke's anger would have been insurmountable and he would have turned. "crush the Rebellion with one swift stroke"

Perhaps the Empire should have simply installed shields on the damn space sation?

You were being sarcastic right, i meant they destroy everything around the Shield Generator,(even there own men, don't really care for stormtroopers, Clones are my boys)i am sure they were accurate enough.

NO DESTROYING YOUR OWN MEN.

The "shield generator" should have simply been used as a decoy to lure the rebel leaders there and then when the shield is "deactivated" the death star simply Alderaans the moon.

There should have just been a shield generator on the damn Death Star II.

Originally posted by General G
What did the CIS do differently?

What did they do at all?

Kicked ass.

Originally posted by Alliance
NO DESTROYING YOUR OWN MEN.

The "shield generator" should have simply been used as a decoy to lure the rebel leaders there and then when the shield is "deactivated" the death star simply Alderaans the moon.

There should have just been a shield generator on the damn Death Star II.

Sacrifices must be made.

Films must end.

History winds upon itself.

Originally posted by General G
Kicked ass.

Failed miserably.

Originally posted by General G
Sacrifices must be made.

If you are able to kill some major Rebel leaders in the process, it would then be a worthy sacrifice. There is something that is known as "acceptable losses."

but why waste the troops if you can get the scum without having a presence there?

Yea i agree with Alliance Destroy Endor and kill all of it without any storm trooper loses at all

The Death Star was far too close to Endor for that, I think is the simple answer.

And if they could have pout the generator on the DS they would have done, so evidently they couldn't.

As queeq says, films have to end. This level of questioning of it is ratjer anal.

Originally posted by Alliance
but why waste the troops if you can get the scum without having a presence there?

Because they have millions more!

Originally posted by Ushgarak
The Death Star was far too close to Endor for that, I think is the simple answer.

And if they could have pout the generator on the DS they would have done, so evidently they couldn't.

As queeq says, films have to end. This level of questioning of it is ratjer anal.

Yeah, but what else can we argue?

They may have end up putting it on the Death Star, remember it wasn't finished.

They should have had Storm Commando's on that Moon...but hay thats EU isent it?

Originally posted by Ushgarak
The Death Star was far too close to Endor for that, I think is the simple answer.

And if they could have pout the generator on the DS they would have done, so evidently they couldn't.

As queeq says, films have to end. This level of questioning of it is ratjer anal.

Questioning is such damnable activity. The death star might have been too close to endor...but the DSII wasn't finished yet.

And the point is.

That the shield generator could have been on the Death Star 2 by the time it was finished.

Defense before Offense...the Empire messed that up.