who likes Jaja binks ?

Originally posted by Schecter

(general comment) i could turn around and label all you adament supporters as mindless fanboys, just to let you know how petty it is to throw labels around and try to win the debate ad hominem, but..2 wrongs...

Wow, aren't you Mr. Right? Don't even try to say you can "label" me as mindless fanyboy. I don't piss and moan like you or anyone else. Instead, I just try to have a little fun and enjoy things. You act like the prequels were made to be bad movies on purpose. That's a load of sh*t dude.

I've heard mulptiple people call Lucas garbage. That isn't a label, it's a fact that that term has been used, and I never said you were the one who used it. Secondly, I wasn't debating, or trying to win a debate against you. God forbid someone speaks their mind to the almighty PVS. I was asking a simple freaken question as to why you all talk so lowly of Lucas. He's accomplished more in his life than anyone of us has. To call him a failure would be a tad bit laughable.

ya thats why he = adoring fan every get rid of him so

Originally posted by Sith Master X
Wow, aren't you Mr. Right? Don't even try to say you can "label" me as mindless fanyboy. I don't piss and moan like you or anyone else. Instead, I just try to have a little fun and enjoy things. You act like the prequels were made to be bad movies on purpose. That's a load of sh*t dude.

I've heard mulptiple people call Lucas garbage. That isn't a label, it's a fact that that term has been used, and I never said you were the one who used it. Secondly, I wasn't debating, or trying to win a debate against you. God forbid someone speaks their mind to the almighty PVS. I was asking a simple freaken question as to why you all talk so lowly of Lucas. He's accomplished more in his life than anyone of us has. To call him a failure would be a tad bit laughable.

i said "general comment" (applying to EVERYONE), and the "mindless fanboy" comment was meant to illustrate the ridiculousness of labeling opponents with petty generalised accusations because they disagree with you. it's called 'irony' and i appologise if the point messed your hair up as it flew over your head.

i cant believe i have to frikin explain this. now read again what i said in its proper context, feel silly, and drop it.

:edit: and its very immature to put words in my mouth. i dont care what e-bandwagon you're fighting for, but if this is personal we can resolve it privately.

This is not personal at all. It's frustration. I'd like to think we could all talk some positive things about SW rather than bash all the negatives.

There were upsides, and downsides to the prequels, and I could say the same for the OT. I'm just as much as PT lover as anyone else is an OT lover, and I never found anything in the law that states that's a bad thing other than a matter of opinion.

Originally posted by Sith Master X
This is not personal at all. It's frustration. I'd like to think we could all talk some positive things about SW rather than bash all the negatives.

There were upsides, and downsides to the prequels, and I could say the same for the OT. I'm just as much as PT lover as anyone else is an OT lover, and I never found anything in the law that states that's a bad thing other than a matter of opinion.

i dont recall stating that your opinion was invalid, which you insist on continuing to repreat. talk about frustrating

I didn't, and I'm not saying you did. I meant that everyone here has a chip on their shoulder whenever someone comes along praising the PT.
We're always just fanboys because we like the prequels or respect what Lucas has done.

Originally posted by Sith Master X
I meant that everyone here has a chip on their shoulder whenever someone comes along praising the PT.

2-i feel strongly that GL has failed to complete his story. i clearly stated that while i feel the OT was a work of genius and love for one's own craft as well as a beautiful imagination, i feel that PT fails completely in continuing this tradition. never did i say that he failed at life. never did i say that people who loved the trilogy are idiots or dont have a valid opinion, never did i say that i knew everything and was 'mighty' etc. so forgive me if i am offended by the constant ad hominem assault.

3-yes it is a debate. a debate is an exchange of opposing thoughts/opinions, which we are clearly having. all i ask is that you address my points rather than trying to dress me down as some bitter hater who has no right to my opinion. that is all.

4-never did i suggest that i was trying to 'win' a debate on a purely subjective topic.

5- for the second time, the "mindless fanboys" comment was meant to illustrate the hypocrisy of labeling opponents rather than addressing their opinions for what they are. it was clearly implied that it was facetious and intended irony.

stop the labeling and we'll get along just fine regardless of our opinions. i assure you of this.

Ok, now kindly, I'm going to point out a few things.

For one, I never labeled you as a hater, not once. Read what I wrote again and you might find that that word never appears. But calling Lucas "fat, lazy and greedy" doesn't help to imply that you exactly like the guy either. You insist that I'm the one who is labeling, yet you label me as "immature." I can assure you that I'm not. I used to be a regular poster on here until all the good people left. Then I had no more interest, but anyone from the good old days can tell you that normally I was pretty honest and respectful.

The "mindless fanboys" comment, yes, I took that too personally. For that, and I'm making this loud and clear "I apologize." I'm sorry, it was a mistake. I don't what else to say. I have no interest in having a war. I interpreted things wrongly. I didn't come back to this place to try and make enemies, and from what I can remember, I liked you when I was around here a while ago. All the Lucas fails stuff wears on me and makes me take things out of context. I'm sorry, it's just an aggrevation to me, and it makes me say thigns that I don't mean.

not that i want to continue this...it just needs clarifying: i didnt label you as anything. i said that what you were doing at the moment was immature. in fact i havent labeled anyone as anything in this thread. (besides , of course, george lucas).

anyway im glad we can let it go.

I can understand why people hate him. I mean, it was his partly his fault that Palpatine got power.

How so?

Because Jar Jar was the one that granted Palpy emergancy powers while he was filling in for Padme.

He is the true Sith Lord.

Darth Jar Jar, I dunno, it doesn't strike fear.

Mesa gonna strike you down.

😂

That worked.

That was laughter not fear.

maybe it was nervous/awkward laughter

But then I tell you that it wasn't.