The best lightsaber fighters . . .

Started by ToMacco11 pages

Obi-wan is the man, my friends.

I'm the best saber fighter in SW

well i challenge you...*drawes lightsaber, the yellow blade lights up my faces...how sexy*

after you're done modelling, tell me

tell you what?? how damn sexy i am in that yellow glance-light from my lightsaber...

you want to fight me or seduce me?

Actually if we are talking purely about sword fighting skills, then except for Maul, I'm really not impressed with any of the other fighters shown in the SW movies, either the OT or the prequels. I mean, none of the actors in the movies, i.e. Alec Guiness, or David Prowse, or Mark Hamill, Liam Neeson, Ewan Mcgregor, Hayden .... none of them are really sword fighters ... Alec Guiness and David Prowse especially. So most of those lightsabre fights, for me, have a kinda cosmetic look to them.

Except for Darth Maul. Because Ray Parks IS in fact i genuine martiall artist, and he looks like a real fighter using those swords.

I'm not talking about the characters here ... but of all the actors, Ray Parks is definitely the best fighter ... he's no actor, but he's a genuine fighter. He'd beat any of the other actors in a real fight. Which is why, I divorce the characters from the actors playing them. I mean ... Count Dooku would beat Darth Maul in a lightsabre duel. I just ignore the fact, that on screen, it's a bit of the stretch of the imagination to see that, cause Cristopher Lee wouldn't stand a chance against Ray Park in real life.

Artistic license, I guess.

well..i guess no actor in the sw universe would. But, as a character, as still think Maul's one of the best. right there besides Dooku and MAce. Those are the trio. The last 2 have more class. And i'm dyin to see how sidious performs

please,... die 😄

Christopher Lee is a trained swordsman!

80 year old wrinklies regularly beat younger, flashier fighters in Kendo.

I like Dooku's ease when fighting....but the younger and flashier are also really cool to watch.....

dooku like Vader....slow and not interested

Well, Dooku's style is my favourite. It has brainpower behind it.

Cristopher Lee certainly does stand out in the fighting sequences no doubt ... u can tell he's not bullshitting, and that he knows his stuff. It's just that, aged 80, I don't see him standing a chance in a real fight against Ray Parks. But of course, Count Dooku over Darth Maul anyday.

Well, he probably couldn't, because he is a fencer, not a combat swordfighter, but the point is that an 80 year old beating a young martial artist is in no way odd.

agreed.....*see Ueshiba😄*
BUt then..it wouldn't matter who the best is...they're all arranged in the saga so that many eliminate eachother. Not necessarily the best being left alive.

Well u know, if on screen, they hypothetically showed Dooku beating Maul ( because Dooku IS a stronger jedi than Maul ), that would be right of course ... the way they've been characterized Count Dooku, although an old man, is stronger than Darth Maul.

However, that would again create, in my mind, a tinge of unreality ... cause Ray Parks, is obviously stronger and faster and more powerful than Cristopher Lee, who, though trained in fencing, is NOT a combat fighter or a martial artist, which Ray Parks is .. and no matter how the fight director would try to cleverly disguise that, it would still definitely come out to a certain extent.

ah but you see you aren't supposed to see Ray Park or Christopher Lee....one problem with the way people see movies today is that they know far too much about them....therefore they are not impressed like they used to be

I know I'm not supposed to see Ray Parks or Cristopher Lee ... but if they were ever shown on screen in a lightsabre duel, no matter how cleverly they covered it up, at some point it would be clearly to me as a viewer, that Ray Parks is a stronger and faster man than Cristopher Lee ... so although I would not be looking at Parks and Lee, but at Maul and Dooku .... it would apppear as if ... Maul is stronger and faster than Dooku ... but that of course is not true ... cause Dooku is the stronger sith ... that's where the artistic license thing comes in ... I would just ignore that part of it I guess.

I doubt I would notice anything. And stronger and faster has little to do with it; it would be down to the portrayed skill. If Christopher Lee WAS a trained combat sword master then I doubt it would actually look any different.