Originally posted by illadelph12
Actually, I think a mistake was made. This thread was opened Monday, 7/9, at about 45 minutes to midnight (PST) by Goob. Sunday would have been day 6. So long as Stacks got his posts in Sunday, 7/15, before midnight, the posts should in fact be legal.
if they are, i'll reset them... anyone seen goober?
Originally posted by illadelph12
Also, normally the matches are posted Sunday at midnight and arguments begin Monday.In this case the thread was opened late on Monday.
It's Goobs call though.
Personally I think Stacks is getting shafted.
i'll let goober have final say... i still have copies of stacks' posts (well, the two large ones anyway), so i can revert them to their original state...
Originally posted by Joey Stacks
What's irritating is how quick the trigger was pulled based on SCOOBLESS'S match length opinion. I don't know what timezone you're in, but here (Illinois) match started on Tuesday. Even if a week magically becomes 6 days I still made the time limit in spades.
i've already said, if goober says to change it back, it'll be changed... simple as that...
Judge's Vote
I'll make this short and sweet. Joey Stacks made a good debate but he seemed to be trying to discount Scoobless' amalgam more than making his own case.
Scoobless did a better job backing up his claims with scans. He stayed the course with his plan. I thought Joey's scans (the scans that I was able to see) were more of a leap of faith regarding some of his claims.
My vote goes to Scoobless. He made a better case and had better support for his claims.
Scoobless
Judges vote..
Alright, you all know I'm not one for writing an essay on why I picked who I did.... So here ya go. 🙂
Joey:
You seemed to waste most of your posts trying to discredit Scoobles character, rather then mounting a good strategy for yourself... I personally didn't see much from you that really stood out.. I'm not trying to be mean here, just fair.
Scoobles:
Your strategy was one of the best I've seen so far. Your posts were able to not only discredit Joey's discredits lol, but you were very methodical with your tactics, everything seemed to be well thought out and planned..
[ie. you knew, and provided evidence showing, exactly what your character could do for you, and you used it's powers wisely throughout this match].
Because of this, my vote goes to Scoobles.
Good job to both of you. 👆
JUDGE'S VOTE
Let's keep this short and sweet, I agree with both Galan and Badabing here; Stack's spent too long trying to prove Scoobless wrong, leaving his amalgam and tactic lacking. Whereas Scoobless (as usual) had a very clever and well though out strategy, he backed it up very well aswell.
This match dragged out wayyy too long, so yeah.. I might aswell finish it with this:
SCOOBLESS